Friday, December 22, 2023

My Gift, Joe


I think about Pam's review of this album a lot. Not, like, excessively, and not in between December 26th and November 20th-ish, but during the holiday season, when I'm attempting to review various seasonal Christmas albums or write about Christmas generally, I always have that harrowing Assumption B.V.M. tale in the back of my head. The saddest part of the whole thing is how normal the story is, and how numb we all are to yet another tale of a local religious leader (and mostly always a priest) committing some heinous sex crime against children. As they say, if clowns did as much raping as priests did, circuses would be illegal.

I also don't think that these facts necessarily negate any pleasant or warm memories we have from our youths, not even the ones that are connected to any sort of religious ceremony. I too had the religious rituals, growing up. I wasn't a chreaster, though I did slowly leave the Church, eventually, one missed Mass at a time. I remember a few "Children's Masses," and I recall fondly the lighting of the Advent candles, the Christmas Bazaar in the Church Hall, the incense in the packed church during a stuffy 4 PM Xmas Eve Mass in which like four or five people would pass out. I was an altar boy too; I'm quite lucky that Father Harrison was only abusive in an egotistical and draconian "traditional" way, rather than a sexual way. Father Harrison is salivating at the idea of Pam divorcing me, since it would fit into his worldview of the "right" and "wrong" way to get married. Oh well, that's better than Father McFadden, who, if you asked him, would be forced to admit that he loudly advocates for policies that would have KILLED Pam. Fuck these bozo priests.

But there was a sense of a community, ya know? At least back in the day. You gathered at a special time of year to celebrate. That's all. Having an insanely hot Pam McD***** sing your Mass, or grimace as a rapist talks to children about Baby Jesus, that's all just part of the package. It's not a matter of holding onto the traditions, as much as it is recalling them fondly, and giving them space to evolve. I won't be going to Mass this Christmas Eve, but I'll still be gathering with my chosen community, and I'll still be celebrating in the way that my community chooses.

Maybe Carrie Underwood is trying to hold onto those old traditions a little too tightly. I don't necessarily care to hear the stodgy religious holiday tunes, and especially not from some American Idol anti-masker. I do understand the impulse, though. You grew up with these tunes. They remind you of something good. And, like any good conservative would, you view those memories through rose-colored glasses, completely ignoring the rot at the core. It's okay. Let us be ignorant too, just during Christmastime.

This album is a fucking ballsack, by the way.

GRADE: 0.5 pukes out of 5

No comments: