Let's take you back to my old Christmas Eve tradition. I must have written about it before. It's nothing exciting, and definitely nothing worth writing about once, let alone twice, but I bring you back today with purpose, if you'll stick with me.
From the age of zero until the age of COVID, I spent every Christmas Eve with the paternal side of my family, featuring aunts and uncles and cousins who have showed up on this blog in different shapes and forms over the years. There were many niche traditions homegrown over the years, like the "Christmas bags" or Grandpop's Christmas outfit or Grandmom's baked mac and cheese or the godparent/godchild gift exchange or on and on forever.
I spent every Christmas Eve with these people for three entire decades, and there were very few traditions that had anything to do with music. During a brief stretch when my cousins and sisters were learning instruments at their respective elementary schools, there were forced and stilted solo performances of, like, "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" on the alto sax or whatever (I was spared the ritual due to "Jingle Bells" being literally impossible to play faithfully on the snare drum), but other than that: no music traditions. I don't know if I've ever heard any of my family members sing at all, ever, unless I'm forgetting some karaoke thing in my soaked 20s.
I spent every Christmas Eve with these people for three entire decades, and there were very few traditions that had anything to do with music. During a brief stretch when my cousins and sisters were learning instruments at their respective elementary schools, there were forced and stilted solo performances of, like, "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" on the alto sax or whatever (I was spared the ritual due to "Jingle Bells" being literally impossible to play faithfully on the snare drum), but other than that: no music traditions. I don't know if I've ever heard any of my family members sing at all, ever, unless I'm forgetting some karaoke thing in my soaked 20s.
So when Pam claimed that Ella Fitzgerald sounds like if my Aunt Maggie was singing, I was taken aback. Objectively, the claim is not true. It can't be, because Aunt Maggie doesn't sing. Subjectively, I guess there's truth to it, but I am just so perplexed at the very thought of my smoker-voiced aunt singing anything, let alone a vibratto'd "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas," that I can't bring myself to agree with Pam on this count. I just can't do it. Aunt Maggie was my gym teacher for three weeks in sixth grade, and those three gym classes consisted of my aunt saying "here's a bag of basketballs" and then going behind the school to smoke cigarettes. That's the aunt I know. Not some professional singer. This is not the type of family members that is singing like Ella Fitzgerald.
I can't get past it. I can't get the claim out of my head. There is so much else I need to talk about here, though. Before Pam said that about my aunt, I was going to structure this review around Fitzgerald's version of "Sleigh Ride." Great tune. I had wondered prior to hitting play on this album whether I was going to recognize any of the songs, and here is the one I recognized, since my kids like Elf, and so I've seen the film and heard the opening of this song countless times in the past couple years (including multiple summer viewings).
I feel like I focus on the idea of "original Christmas songs" in these album reviews, but there's another idea that needs more mention here—the idea of the "definitive version." "Sleigh Ride" was written as a light orchestra standard in 1946, so it's not an Ella Fitzgerald original. But does Ella Fitzgerald have the definitive version of "Sleigh Ride" now? Certainly in this household. If you were a Phil Spector kinda guy, then you might say the Ronettes have THE version of "Sleigh Ride." If you binged The Voice during COVID, then maybe you think Gwen Stefani has the definitive version. I'm not saying there is an answer here, more so making the case for the thought experiment of: there are a finite number of holiday standards, covered over and over every year, so let's now argue over who does the best and/or most famous version of each.
One person I know for a motherfucking fact does NOT have the definitive version of this song is Aunt Maggie. An absolutely absurd claim that, because I'm writing this review now and etching it into stone, will haunt me for the rest of my Christmases Yet to Come.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment