Wednesday, August 6, 2025

A Year of Blind Spots: The Downward Spiral

Joe is working through a list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


The Downward Spiral
Nine Inch Nails
1994

What 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die has to say about The Downward Spiral by Nine Inch Nails:

Want something cheerfully glum? Take the Cure. Glossily glum? Pink Floyd, perhaps. Nastily, noisily, suicidally glum? Viva les Nails.

"The big overview," said mainman Trent Reznor, "was of somebody who throws away every aspect of his life—from relationships to religion. [It] also looks at vices as ways of trying to dull the pain. I'm talking about myself... Not that that's any great leap for me."

This paean to pain was born at the L.A. house where Charles Manson's followers murdered actress Sharon Tate. Bad vibes abounded: having failed to cook chicken for the under-nurtured Reznor, visitor Tori Amos concluded the house was cursed. Horror soaks the songs, though Reznor denies the recurrent "pigs" are related to "Piggies," the Beatles track that became a Manson anthem. Amid the industrial likes of "March of the Pigs" are seductive moments. The danceable "Closer," its drum sampled from Iggy Pop's "Nightclubbing," boasts one of the decade's most-quoted choruses: "I want to fuck you like an animal."

Finally, there is "Hurt." "The best anti-drug song I ever heard," said Johnny Cash, whose cover version became his epitaph. Cash's heartbreaking video was by Mark Romanek, who also directed the disturbing "Closer" clip.

The Downward Spiral is as far from easy listening as multiplatinum rock has ever reached. If it "speaks" to you, and you are not Trent Reznor, be very worried. But its lacerating guitars, deafening drums, and astonishing songs are worryingly intoxicating.

And Tori's chicken? "I didn't ask," shrugged Reznor. "The ghosts ate it."

What Joe has to say about The Downward Spiral by Nine Inch Nails:

Recorded at the Manson compound? C'mon, man, that's some try-hard edgelord bullshit. It doesn't ruin the album or anything, but it definitely explains a lot about why I'm not totally invested in this. Wearing glumness like a badge of honor and shrugging off ghosts to seem cool, none of that really appeals to me. Rough industrial music that screams a lot and has a lot of discordant sounds and clanking and shit like that? Catch me on the right day, and I love that shit. But we don't need to overdo it with the fascination with the macabre. Just play the damn music.

There are moments on this album that can easily stand on their own, and don't need ghost chicken to pop. The chorus in "Heresy" is probably my favorite part of The Downward Spiral. It's corny, but Reznor sells it, yelling "God is dead!" as loudly and with as much distortion as possible. That three-song run from that song to "Closer" (with "March of the Pigs" in between, that somehow feels really poignant by the time it gets to its piano-only outro) is a great run. I did a doubletake hearing the "fuck" in "I wanna fuck you like an animal" for probably the first time, after three decades of radio stations censoring it for me.

I like when NIN attempts to make songs, and not when they slip into their future selves by making soundtrack music. The back half of the album gets there often enough that I wondered what was wrong with my iPod's volume multiple times. And that's before we get to "Hurt," which of fucking course Johnny Cash's name gets brought up in the goddamn book blurb for a goddamn Nine Inch Nails album. Fuck that lame bullshit. I hate the cover and now I can say that I hate the original. Poor baby is hurt? Aw. Sowwy. Go back to giving the middle finger to god, please.

Though there are many, many differences between the two bands, I can't help but equate Nine Inch Nails with Linkin Park in my mind (if Marilyn Manson had decided to not be a rapist, he might've eventually ended up in this paragraph too), just in the sort of dark alt '90s milieu that both bands' commercials peaks arrived in. I spoke about this for Hybrid Theory, how a certain type of kid listens to this music, because they can "relate" in some way. Nine Inch Nails feels way more authentic, but they're in the same ballpark. Maybe that's why I always cringe a little bit.

But you can't argue with the craft. The songs (as opposed to the soundtrack practice) hold your attention throughout. Glum? I guess technically. But more glum in that they are performatively glum and that's what makes them interesting. Sonically, it doesn't sound glum, it sounds angry and cluttered, and that's a good thing. Lyrically? Sure, whatever. I just think that the wild industrial shit that we have here is the whole story. We don't have to make up bullshit about ghosts and Manson and chicken. The music is deep enough that it can tell its own story. Don't force it.

No comments: