"Can you give her 400 movies she's never seen before? Please, doctor, help her." "Give her movies? All this child needs is a blog." "She needs a blog...? WHERE AM I SUPPOSED TO GET A BLOG?!"
1988
Isao Takahata
The schedule allowed for a weeklong break in between three-month sessions of Film Club, but I figured I would ask if anyone wanted to watch another movie and write a little something during that break. If no one else wrote anything besides me, I will not delete this intro, on principle alone.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Joe
The fact (fact? I'm pretty sure it's fact and not urban legend) that Grave of the Fireflies and My Neighbor Totoro were shown as a double bill to Japanese audiences in 1988 is borderline obscene. I'm not talking about their respective quality value—both films are beautiful, poignant achievements in art and emotion—but more so the fact that they are very clearly made for different audiences. My kids loved Totoro; I honestly don't know how they would react to Fireflies. I don't think they would know how to react? Because it deals with emotions that haven't really passed their radar in any significant way yet? For reasons that I can't seem to articulate right now, showing Grave of the Fireflies to children, either in my household or in a late-'80s Japanese movie theater, feels like some sort of child abuse.
I'm pretty new to the whole Studio Ghibli thing, having had my first outing less than a year ago in Spirited Away. So far, the four films I've seen (that, plus Kiki's Delivery Service and My Neighbor Totoro and Ponyo) were all made by Hayao Miyazaki, who would appear to most as the "head" of Ghibli, having made all their most well-known artworks. But he co-founded the animation studio with Isao Takahata, who directed Grave of the Fireflies. Because of this, even though I just said that Totoro and Fireflies are worlds are emotionally, they were made by the same studio in the same year, and so I can't help but think about how the two are similar as well. In other words, the things that I've professed for the last year that I love about Studio Ghibli films, I'm wondering now how they apply to Grave of the Fireflies.
Three things. The first thing that I profess loving about Ghibli films is that they typically lack a standard "villain" character. The conflict is more internal than external. I would say that Fireflies somewhat meets this description, though not entirely. Takahata has often claimed that this film is NOT an anti-war film, that it is instead simply a depiction of two children as they struggle to exist in a society that is breaking down. Despite this, you cannot deny that the film explicitly takes place during wartime, specifically in Japan during the final days of WWII, when the U.S. was firebombing Japanese civilian communities (did you know that more people died this way than from the atomic bombs hitting two of Japan's cities?). So while it's never stated outright, you could probably make an argument that the United States is the villain of Grave of the Fireflies. That would be an inference on the part of the audience, however; as depicted on the screen, there is no villain. The circumstances of our main characters exist and there's no room in their lives to examine those circumstances, since they are so pressing that it's all they can do to just survive, and not ask why.
That bleeds into the second thing I usually love about Ghibli films, but in a depressing way. In all of the Miyazaki films I've seen so far, there are major elements of magic, ranging from magical realism to straight-up fantasy. What I appreciated in all of those films was that, when, say, a child experiences something fantastical, the adults in their life immediately believe the child, and take them seriously. A lesser film would have the girls from Totoro tell their dad about the creatures in the forest and have the dad say "stop, you're talking nonsense." But the dad in that one responds with something like, "wow, that's amazing, we need to respect the creatures of the forest!" Or the mom from Ponyo immediately accepting the fact that her son's best friend was originally a fish. Does that happen here? Tough to say, especially because I don't know if I would say that there are significantly fewer instances of "magic" in this film.
Maybe this is why the adults are all so dismissive of the children here, whether we're talking about the aunt who belittles the kids for being a burden on her, or the doctor who shrugs his shoulder when giving Setsuko's death sentence. The magic would be surviving such dire circumstances; the adults all know that there is no magic here. But that doesn't stop Setsuko and Seita from attempting to find it anyway, however briefly, as the fireflies illuminate the abandoned bomb shelter they call home. In the morning, the fireflies join their mother in the grave, and the magic is shattered, but they continue to seek out that magic until the very end.
The third thing that I usually love about these films, but the hardest quality to describe perhaps, is the idea that all these films depict characters that are "existing," as opposed to "traveling." I don't mean that literally, I am talking more about the plot. There is very little A-to-B, there is very little overt conflict of the hero-vs.-villain variety. I also don't want to call them "plotless," but it's closer to plotless than many other movies. Spirited Away—a little girl exists in a weird dreamland. Kiki's—a girl witch sets up a business in a new town. Totoro—two little girls move into a new house and explore their surroundings. Ponyo—a little boy forms a bond with a fish. Your typical movie would take any of these and attach one more "and" to the description. "And then this happens." But the "and" never arrives in Ghibli films, and I love them for that reason.
Can you say the same of Grave of the Fireflies? Probably? The description would probably look like "Two little kids attempt to survive in wartime." What would be the "and"? I don't think there is one! They attempt to survive. That's it. Maybe a lesser movie would take the children in these circumstances and either 1) depict them as particularly unlucky, i.e. that more hardship befalls on them than your typical sibling pair during this time, or 2) depict them as, through the grace of a higher power or plain dumb luck, escaping the hardship and surviving and maybe even thriving. Neither are the case here! Seita and Setsuko's circumstances are not uncommon for the population and time period in which they live. They struggle as many others struggled. Their story is special to us only because it is being depicted in a beautiful, masterful animated film. That's the magic of the film itself, and of Ghibli films generally. There doesn't need to be anything extra. We see the characters as they exist, and it becomes even more impactful than if "and something else happens."
I didn't need Grave of the Fireflies to fit within whatever Studio Ghibli framework I've built in my own mind in order for me to love it. It succeeds in a vacuum too, and then some. But in this film that appears to share at the very least the same heart as the Miyazaki Ghibli films, if not the exact same molecular structure, at the end the of the day I still feel that same sort of elation that I've seen something truly special. If there is a secret sauce, then the directors of this film studio were sharing it, and I've seen it here yet again. Grave of the Fireflies proves yet again why I keep returning to these Studio Ghibli films.
GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
GROUP AVERAGE GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
I'll be in the comments if anyone wants to chat some more about it!
(NEXT TIME: I wanted to watch the highest-ranking film on the AFI 100 that I haven't seen yet, and that ends up being #12 The Searchers.)

3 comments:
I first saw this movie a year and a half ago or so, after being on my to-watch list for so long but delayed because of how sad everyone told me it was.
I ended up plexing it with two roommates who I wasn't fighting with, but not exactly close with. Sort of in the middle of a roommate scuffle; not the first time, probably not the last.
And my god was it sad! Which is why, despite wanting to, I couldn't watch it again this week. Maybe sometime soon. Like you said, this movie feels the most "grounded" or just "not magical." The constant ratcheting up of the situation for these kids has the anxiety drive of Good Time with the aesthetic quality of Totoro.
But my god is it beautiful as well. No surprise it's constantly in the conversation of best animated movies ever. The depth of joys between Setsuko and Seita mirrors the depths of their despair. You're really riding high when they first get rice or they first find their little cave.
When I first got done watching the movie with said roommates, E said "people called this movie anti-US propaganda when it came out." I don't know if that's true (that they said it), but I could believe people believing it. As said, there's no villain in the movie, but as a US watcher it's hard not to feel something and then ascribe a targeted villain.
Fucking Miyazaki, so magical.
"Saw it before / could not stand to see it again" seems to be a pretty common and absolutely understandable reaction to this film. Something that I saw at one point was Takahata saying that he purposefully included the death scenes at the very beginning to soften the blow when it finally happens toward the end of the movie. Meaning that if we knew they were doomed, maybe we'd be a little more emotionally prepared. I think it technically works, but I also think it changes the tenor of film, and possibly makes it sadder, like sad in that whenever the characters are happy, that happiness is undercut with the knowledge of where this is all going.
The anti-US thing is interesting to think about, still. Takahata literally denies that it's true, but that's the thing about movies—we see what we want to see. Or see what we NEED to see, I guess. Once Takahata puts it out into the universe, he loses control of his creation. If we want to sit here in 2025 and be horrified with the idea of America causing so much death and destruction abroad (and maybe connect it to all the death and destruction America is causing within America this year), then that's our prerogative.
Post a Comment