Wednesday, July 2, 2025

The First Time I: Did Ayahuasca

This is The First Time, a column where Zach either 1) writes about the first time he did something specific in his life and talks about any pop culture connections surrounding it, or 2) tries something for the first time ever in 2025 and writes about it—sees a new movie, eats a new food, etc. etc. etc.


The hardest drugs I had done until two years ago were alcohol and marijuana. I had Valium here and there when I was in China and Vietnam, and it made me happy and sleepy, but it wasn't anything overly crazy. I had always wanted to do some kind of mushrooms at some point, but the moment never came, and I wanted to be around the right people when I did it.

It was early 2023. I was becoming better friends with someone who lived in Jerusalem, too. Over and over again, he brought up his medicinal journey with ayahuasca, how it changed his life. How he had done several "ceremonies" up to that point. "I think you'd love it," he told me. "I think it would be great for you."

I've tried lots of things. CBT therapy, DBT therapy, somatic therapy, meditation retreats, Torah study, I don't even know what else. Workshops of different kinds. I'm always trying something new. Some things work better than others. It all has value. And I'm kind of willing to try anything.

Why not at least try it?

I was nervous about not going with anyone who I knew. It would be a gathering, in the forest, with 80 people, led by a mysterious figure named Shimon. For 450 shekel, I'd get three cups of ayahuasca tea, access to the event helpers, guidance.

My friend reassured me. "Your feelings are valid," he said. "You still should go. You'll open up to a whole new reality."

It was June. He lent me his chair that opened up on the ground. I got a ride, with a very nice woman who was looking for some kind of a fresh start. We arrived early, and I had time to journal. It was a beautiful space. People trickled in, everyone wearing white. I, too, had dressed in white, and was happy to fit in. With me, too, was a journal, a vomit bucket, and lots and lots of water. I hadn't eaten since the morning, just as I had been told to do. If I felt sick—if I vomited—it was the poison I had inherited, any kind of poison, spilling out of me. It was a good thing. They said as much.

They said they would be starting at 9 PM, but it was soon 10 PM, and 11 PM. I thought I saw Shimon, the tall, regal figure, sitting in the middle of the band that would be playing around him that night. More and more people assembled. I had my mat and blankets ready, too. They made a few announcements about the tea, about the order of the night. "Viva la medicina!" they cried. And everyone repeated after them, like a chant that everyone already knew that I wasn't a part of yet.

The two helpers surrounded us at that point, burned incense next to our bodies, used large fan-like things to spread it around us. 

It was time.

"One by one," Shimon said. And, sure enough, people got up off their mats to walk to the front, where they would be served their first cup of medicinal tea. I went up and kneeled in front of Shimon. How should I act? How should I look at him? What should I say?

All I did, in the end, was tell him that was my first time. He nodded, sagely, and poured what I assume was a smaller cup than he would give to others. I drank. It tasted disgusting, of course. Bitter and terrible. I choked it down. It wasn't meant to taste good.

I went back to my place. I laid down, and I waited.

I didn't feel anything, really. Maybe a little nauseous. The music got bigger, louder, wrapped around me like a cloud. Time stopped being time. A half hour in I started to hear the sound of retching. One person, then another. Vomiting was taking place all around me. Nearby, someone was crying, sobbing, really. I didn't feel anything. Or did I? It's that feeling when you smoke pot and you're not sure if you're high or not. I really couldn't tell.

And then the music stopped. "Time for the second cup," Shimon said. I felt woozy, but not much more. I got up, after most people, and made my way over to the front, next to the band. I proffered my cup. He filled it. And I drank. It was just as nasty as the first.

I laid back down. Still nothing.

It was only a few minutes later that it hit me all at once. 

They say that ayahuasca can be compared to an abuela—a kindly grandmother, guiding you along whatever path you need. Suddenly, I had a vision of a grandmother in front of me, smiling at me. Immediately afterward, it was as if an asteroid hit my brain. Galaxies opened up, and I entered into another realm. It was as if something had scooped out all the junk that was situated at the top of my brain and uncovered everything true underneath, all within the span of a few seconds.

I began to go places. Suddenly, I realized something. About my first love. It hadn't been my high school girlfriend. It had been baseball, when I was six years old. "I love baseball," I realized. And I realized that this wasn't just a casual sentence. I had actually been in love with baseball as a kid, with all my heart. I had been in love with the Orioles and Cal Ripken Jr. and the McGwire/Sosa chase of 1998 and playing with bat and ball in my backyard on my own. And that my love for baseball had been in place of something else, in place of a love I hadn't felt from my parents. 

I know my parents love me. But they hadn't given me the exact kind of love I had needed. And how could they, I realized! Right in that moment an immense wave of compassion for them washed over me. I had blamed them, up to that point, for not saying "I love you" enough, for frustratingly not connecting deeply over emotions, and so on. In that moment, though, I started to think about my grandparents. All great, loving people, and on my mom's side my grandfather was a functioning alcoholic who was busy running a business and not around much; my grandmother was incredibly hard on her children to the point of being moderately verbally abusive. On my dad's side, my grandmother died before I was born of a rare disease, and my father rarely talks about her. My grandfather was a universally sweet man who really didn't go into talking about his feelings. 

I realized, in the core of my body, deeply, in the middle of the trip, that my parents didn't have the tools to love me the way they needed. They had needed to emotionally defend themselves from pain. They didn't have the language of therapy to fall back on. My father was harboring the untreated grief of losing his mother at a young age. My mother had a much more challenging home life as a child than she let on.

It wasn't their fault. 

Without the love I had gotten from them, I had turned to baseball. And I am still trying to find love, almost desperately, in so many ways. Anyone who's read anything I've written on this blog knows that I'm pretty fixated on pursuing and finding romantic love. I'm sure it's connected to this whole thing.

Physically I felt these realizations coming from the deepest part of my brain, the one that was uncovered by the dust and soot of life and all the weird things and anxieties that come with it.

At some point I started to murmur to myself. I don't know what I was saying, but it must have been loud. All of a sudden I felt a hand on my shoulder. It was one of the helpers.

"Hey," he said. "No worries, but just try to lower the volume a bit?"

His eyes were so kind and he had said it in such a nice way. I felt completely ashamed, though. The ayahuasca made me confront some of my anxieties here, too. "Everyone is judging me for being loud," my brain called out to me, loudly. "Everyone hates me. In the morning, no one will talk to me. I will never be invited back."

Suffice it to say that none of that happened. No one cared in the morning, no one even knew it was me! I even asked around, and no one knew what I was talking about there. There were vomiting sounds; there was crying, music. One voice wouldn't stand out. But it helped realize how much my fear of what other people think has an effect on my existence.

At some point, there was a third cup. I could barely walk up to get it, and was worried I'd fall over. But I had it. 

Most of my major breakthroughs throughout the ceremony happened, as I described them, during the second cup. But I was able to play some good games with myself during Cup #3. I was able to think of anyone in my life and go incredibly deep on them, understand them on a deeper level than I ever had. That girl I had just dated and ended things with the week earlier? She just wanted to get married, and it was incredibly unfair no men wanted to marry her yet. I went down into the coal mine of my brain and focused on my brother, my other brother, my parents again. I learned so much about them. It sounds wild, but the ayahuasca was a guide.

And just like that, it started getting light. The band playing had kind of just been there all night. It was more part of the mosaic, of the whole hazy experience than anything. I hadn't been listening to the music, but I noticed when the music was gone.

Recorded music started coming through as we started to come out of our high. Cat Stevens's "Morning Has Broken" played. I sat up. Others started to move around and dance. I felt nauseous, unable to move my body. There had been a few points during the night where I had thought I'd vomit, but I didn't. A seasoned ayahuasca professional might say that I hadn't fully let go of my toxicities. Maybe that's true. 

We made a circle at the end and all hugged one another, clapped hands with one another. And then it was over.

I stayed around the ceremony location for another few hours. I secured a ride back to Jerusalem with someone, chatted with others. The tension I always feel in my jaw had completely disappeared. That was one thing. There was breakfast, but I couldn't eat much. I had a conversation in a group with Shimon at some point. I took a swim in the lake that was there. Then we got on the road, sometime around 11:30 AM.

My ride dropped me off outside Jerusalem, so I had to still get home. The cab driver at the bus station tried to cheat me, but I held way more firm against him than I normally would have. Something about the ayahuasca had made me less tolerant of bullshit. The same phenomenon reared its head the following week at work: I was more productive that week than I had ever been in that job. I didn't need the distractions of sports blogs, news, however I normally pass the hours. My brain drilled down to what I needed to do, and I did it.

That Friday, the morning after, I wrote nonstop in my journal for five hours. My friend who had connected me to the ceremony came over that night for dinner. I spilled my guts to him. He understood everything. I have no idea what I said to him, but he got it. 

I still felt sick, unsteady, and that feeling stayed with me the whole weekend. I slept twelve hours that night. I had no tolerance to interact with others who hadn't been part of some kind of ayahuasca experience, and, thankfully, my roommates were away that weekend. 

The ceremony stays with me, even to this day. I haven't done another one yet. But I plan to. I want to eat mushrooms first, though, with the right people around me.

No comments: