Wednesday, July 16, 2025

Never Seen It #233: Bringing Up Baby

"Yes, I did see the blog, but I didn't see him. Well that is, I didn't see him really. Yes, I spoke to him twice, but I didn't talk to him." "But I don't understand. Did you watch 400 movies you've never seen before or didn't you?" "Well—no I don't know—well how do I know? Well, because... because... well there's someone at the door—you see there are some things that are very hard to explain."


Bringing Up Baby
1938
Howard Hawks

I will say upfront that I laughed a lot while watching Bringing Up Baby. That's gonna be the thesis for this blog post, that the movie is funny. There are other things to say about it, but it's all gonna come back to that. I guess it's somewhat interesting that I laughed out loud so often at a film made in 1938. If there is graph somewhere with the year of release on the x-axis and the "level of funny" on the y-axis, then Bringing Up Baby is gonna be practically by itself in the top left corner. So far, anyway. I've been watching more pre-WWII movies recently than I ever have in my life. I would wager that Bringing Up Baby was so funny that I forgot about how old it was, which is cool.

Eventually, we will get to the point where films devoured in this Film Club that are really really old are only footnoted as such, because it won't matter anymore. Until we get to that point, it's just a fact of life that we're gonna say "this is old and" or "this is old but." This is old but: it's funny as fuck. This is old and: it actually has a pretty interesting moment that's only interesting because of its age.

That moment happens during the best scene in the film. This is a screwball comedy, and one comedic moment leads directly into another, so I'd end up explaining the entire movie in order to explain this one scene, but suffice it to say that Cary Grant is in a dress. Or, like, a nightgown. Definitely feminine, probably light pink even though the black-and-white cinematography makes that a guess. He's with Katherine Hepburn's Susan, whom he just met that day. She's meeting her aunt at her aunt's home. The aunt brings a dog. David is exasperated throughout the entire film because Susan talks a mile a minute and seems intent on ruining his life. He's trying to leave the house but found out Susan sent his clothes into town to get cleaned, for instance. Hence, the nightgown. 

So anyway, Susan's aunt arrives at front door, and naturally, she has some questions about why a strange man is in her home, and why that strange man is wearing the particular clothing that he is. She says, "But why are you wearing these clothes?" and David says, "Because I just went GAY all of a sudden." He does a little jump when he says the word "gay," and the camera follows him. I noted the line at the time, wondering what to make of it, whether people were even using "gay" as a way to describe homosexual individuals, or if Cary Grant meant "happy," or what. As it turns out, this may or may not have been the first mainstream use of "gay" to denote homosexuality, which is absolutely fucking wild. Wild for so many reasons! Like, it's claimed that this line was ad-libbed, but then how the synced camera movement at that jump?

To be clear, I don't think that this moment is the reason that Bringing Up Baby is considered a great movie, is on both the AFI and BFI all-time lists, is in the Library of Congress, etc. I think all those things happened because it's funny as fuck, just a really well-built comedy that builds and builds and features crackerjack performances from the two leads and a whole host of wacky supporting characters. But isn't it interesting too how tiny moments can build a film's myth like this? I would imagine that there are a sizeable number of cinephiles who only remember Bringing Up Baby because of David jokingly calling himself gay.

We take what we need from a film like this. We laugh because we can relate. Something I'll take away from Bringing Up Baby is how frustrating and confounding it can feel to want to say something but not be able to. Cary Grant basically spends the entire movie attempting to say something to Katherine Hepburn and getting cut off. This is seriously the entire film. I wonder how many complete sentences the man was able to get out. What I'm saying is that I fucking get it, man. That scene when he's in the nightgown, and he keeps trying to cut in but the aunt and Susan and hollering at each other and the dog is just yip yip yipping without pause, fuck, dude, I felt David's pain. The look of defeat when he would try to say something and then not be able to and dejectedly shut down for a few seconds before trying again, I get it! I feel that way all the time! And that's what made it so funny. Comedy as seeing one's own pain reflected back at them.

There are other aspects to the film that might be worth writing about another time—e.g. how "typical gender roles" of this time period are reversed, how Susan is loud and brash and condescending and forceful and David is meek and constantly steamrolled and is eventually the "prize" to be won—but I don't have the patience for that. It's a funny movie. I feel like Cary Grant and Katherine Hepburn, who continuously held up production of Bringing Up Baby because they couldn't stop laughing. I'm having trouble writing because I can't stop laughing. The leopard mixup, Susan's fake gangster voice, even the way David spoke (took me a minute, but I recognized that voice from Tony Curtis's impression of it in Some Like It Hot). It's all really funny. That's the most important thing to note here.

GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5

NEXT TIME: Group B has some thoughts about Jacob's Ladder for you!

No comments: