1993
Jane Campion
I've been thinking a lot about communication in the days since I have viewed The Piano for the first time. That was probably the point; this isn't a revelatory though, the communication stuff. The Piano is one of those movies where the theme is evident and obvious from the beginning, but its obviousness does nothing to blunt its immense impact.
Ada is an elective mute, so she does not speak. She can communicate with her daughter through primitive sign language, with others through hand gestures and stern looks and sparse words written on tiny pieces of paper, and otherwise... she speaks by playing the piano. This is her preferred communication style. We see throughout the film how the relationships in her life are measured by the way that the piano can speak to those relationships. Mainly speaking here about her husband, who "doesn't listen" because he doesn't take seriously the piano (he wants to leave it on the beach originally), and a neighbor with whom she eventually has an affair, since he connects with her while she is playing that piano.
And so we see how this is operating. The piano and the mutism are symbolism for communication in relationships. Two people—spouses, friends, any type of relationship—can form a strong bond through clear and intimate communication. I know this in real life. Pam and I watched Seven Samurai, all three and a half hours of it, and afterward Pam expressed to me that she no longer wished to watch movies, and that she felt that she needed to get better at saying no, like for instance when I asked her to be part of a Film Club that she didn't want to be a part of, but she still said yes, and that caused friction, and she yelled at me because she didn't want to watch a three-and-a-half-hour samurai movie but she did it anyway, and this was my fault... throughout all this, I'm thinking about the piano. Let's communicate, baby. Crack open that large box on the beach and stick your hands inside and play me a tune, play me your heart. I'm listening.
And so we see how this is operating. The piano and the mutism are symbolism for communication in relationships. Two people—spouses, friends, any type of relationship—can form a strong bond through clear and intimate communication. I know this in real life. Pam and I watched Seven Samurai, all three and a half hours of it, and afterward Pam expressed to me that she no longer wished to watch movies, and that she felt that she needed to get better at saying no, like for instance when I asked her to be part of a Film Club that she didn't want to be a part of, but she still said yes, and that caused friction, and she yelled at me because she didn't want to watch a three-and-a-half-hour samurai movie but she did it anyway, and this was my fault... throughout all this, I'm thinking about the piano. Let's communicate, baby. Crack open that large box on the beach and stick your hands inside and play me a tune, play me your heart. I'm listening.
If this was a movie that a small group or a Zoom was discussing, as opposed to a film that I'm assume will be quickly washed away with the blogging tide without much comment, then we'd probably be discussing those last few minutes. I'm going to do so here anyway, to myself (or maybe not—discuss away, Piano friends, communicate with me), about what happens there. SPOILERS, obviously.
So Ada's husband, Alisdair, gets all jealous and cuts off one of Ada's fingers—her piano-playing fingers!—and basically tells her and George to get the fuck out of here. They escape on a boat. The boat barely fits the piano, but George, knowing how important this thing is, insists that it goes with. Except that Ada is terribly depressed—about the finger, about life—and she insists that the piano goes overboard. George reluctantly submits, and pushes the piano over. Ada's foot gets wrapped up in the rope tied to the piano, and she's pulled underwater. The narration makes it clear: when Ada unwraps her foot from the rope and swims to the surface, that is a choice. She chooses to live. She could've easily chosen to die with the piano, but she chooses life. The epilogue shows her happy with George, her finger repaired, deep passionate kisses and sonatas on her new keys. She chose life, and life rewarded the choice.
I'm of two minds about this. The first is that it's a crucial theme, that choice of life, and I am always happy to see it on the screen. I think back to all the times in my life when I chose life. Sometimes that choice is more difficult than other times, but I always seem to choose it. It's cool to reflect on it, and see it symbolized with a swim to the surface. The second is that I think that this idea comes out of nowhere. The Piano, for the majority of its runtime, is about how humans interact, bond, communicate, and the struggles therein. Life and death rarely played into that. And now all of a sudden, here we are.
Or maybe I just missed something, which is honestly pretty likely. Hopefully one of those hypothetical friends can hop into the comments and be like "nah, Joe, c'mon, didn't you hear the monologue from eleven-year-old Anna Paquin at minute 38 of the film about how Holly Hunter needs to LIVE goddamn it LIVE?!" Or it could be more subtle than that. Like how communication itself is our lifeforce, how I feel like if Pam and I were suddenly unable to communicate that I would probably wanna get dragged to the bottom of the ocean too, how maybe death is the logical endpoint of this conversation about communication, that connection with others, no matter how you do it (pianos or otherwise), is the only thing that makes us want to live in the first place. Something something the Maori are speaking their own language this whole time something something etc. etc. You get it.
If the purpose of that final choice was to keep the conversation about The Piano going for an extra few days, even if that conversation is happening just between me and the film itself, then consider it a success. Who needs to talk to anyone else about this. My eyes work, I silently type on my own keys, communicating and choosing to live.
GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: Group C is making abstract art with Pollock.

2 comments:
You're really going to be upset at the third option, which I believe is your least favorite film trope if I remember correctly. What if she actually drowned?
Ha! I didn't even consider this, probably because, as you mentioned, I hate it. I wouldn't hate it if The Piano had hinted in any way that this was a possibility. I wouldn't even hate it if there was an actual REASON for that twist, thematically, like if it added something to our understanding of the character in any way.
But as it stands, if someone is actually making that argument, that she actually drowned, then that argument is being made on shitty reddit threads where basic ass bitches are coming up with "fan theories" for no other reason other than to feel clever about themselves.
What if she actually drowned? My response would be: okay, fine, she actually drowned, fucking so what???
Unless you, Frank, are actually making this argument, in which case, I'd love to hear a Why. If anyone has one, it's you.
Post a Comment