Saturday, July 19, 2025

A Year of Blind Spots: Black on Both Sides

Joe is working through a list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


Black on Both Sides
Mos Def
1999

Back in April, I listened to D'Angelo's Voodoo for the first time, and was delighted to learn that the album was put together by a musical collective called the Soulquarians. Somehow, the addition of this particular myth added to my experience of the otherwise really good R&B album (even if "myth" is literally, depending on who you ask, like I know that D'Angelo himself would probably balk at the existence of the collective). And at the time, I promised that we would cover another Soulquarians-produced album this summer. The summer has arrived, and here we are.

Except, despite Black on Both Sides' placement on the Soulquarians' Wikipedia page, I don't see any evidence that this album actually had any tangible connection to Questlove or J Dilla. I suppose it's one of those "in spirit" things, in which Mos Def becomes part of the collective because of how Black on Both Sides sounds, and then that album is retroactively included in the canon. To my ears, it does sound like it has a sonic connection to Voodoo, especially the loose rhythms, the wide pop culture references, the heavy focus on theme of being Black, and the excessive borrowing from other genres (soul, but there's a heavy metal breakdown at one point too). So maybe I was wrong to hype up this album's connection to the Soulquarians, but the sounds and emotions hit the mark nevertheless.

This album was marked as a Blind Spot long before I had ever known about Questlove and J Dilla and D'Angelo and so on working together. The first time I became aware of his existence was as the co-star of the 2008 film Be Kind Rewind, which I reviewed on an old blog (it eventually made its way here). It's a terrible review, but, ya know, I didn't really know what I was doing. I still don't, but I definitely didn't then. I don't really even remember the movie all that much, my viewing of it happening half a lifetime ago at this point. But 2008 Joe liked it, and had kind things to say about Mos Def.

And then I just found the other day an old 2020 blog post about a beer made by a brewer that also apparently brewed something with Mos Def at some point. This wouldn't have been significant to me in 2020 if I didn't know who Mos Def was in 2020. I probably only knew who he was because of Be Kind Rewind. That blog post embedded a song from this album. Obviously, it's still a blind spot.

So now I'm here, and I'm listening, and it's good. This is "conscious hip hop," meaning that the themes are not necessarily uplifting, but definitely pointing more toward the direction of uplift than, say, the urban dystopia of Wu-Tang. The thesis statement comes in the middle of the first song, "Fear Not of Man": "So if hip-hop is about the people / And the hip-hop won't get better until the people get better / Then how do people get better?" This speaks to the power of music, yes, but it is specifically speaking to the power of Black music.

As always, this white man explains himself. I am Black on neither side, but this is an important album for me to hear. It's about experiencing things from other perspectives. It's about learning something new. That's what I've been doing with hip hop in general, right? Forget about the racial makeup of the genre, and just think about how different hip hop music sounds from the music I grew up with. I want to learn, though, and the only way to do that is through openness and humility and constant exposure. Why couldn't the same tenet apply to other ways of life? Why wouldn't an album about different experiences be appealing to me, the humble learner?

At the very least, we can document how far we've come, and how far we have to go. The verse that hits me every time I hear it is this one from "Mr. N*gga" (asterisked because I am a white person writing this blog post):

"You can laugh and criticize Michael Jackson if you wanna;
Woody Allen molested and married his stepdaughter
Same press kicking dirt on Michael's name
Show Woody and Soon-Yi at the playoff game (Holding hands)
Sit back and just bug, think about that
Would he get that type of dap if his name was Woody Black?"

In 1999, this was a great take. An important one, even. Woody Allen was still making films to great success; Jackson was on the downward swing. I knew about Michael Jackson's child abuse as long as I could remember, and it took till I was an adult for me to learn about Woody Allen's child abuse. Mos Def is right, there is a difference. Now, the interesting part is that I sense the implication from this verse being that people should stop picking on Jackson, whereas my stance is that both of those fuckers should be buried as far down as we can possibly go. But I think Mos Def is more just trying to paint a picture of how there is a discrepancy between races, and that over long periods of time, that sort of discrepancy is going to weigh on communities. You can rope my struggles with Bill Cosby into these thoughts (I can't believe that the only time I told that story on this blog was while writing a Blind Spots entry while blackout drunk... sorry about that.)

The more I listened to Black on Both Sides, the more I liked it. The lyrics constantly revealed new angles, and the soulful production kept things moving well. I hyped it up for all the wrong reasons, but it ended up matching the hype all the same.

No comments: