2008
Hayao Miyazaki
I don't need my kids to like a film. I suppose it could make a movie-watching experience more meaningful, if they love it. But it's not necessary. It's more like: if they love it, then that means something to me, but if they hate it, then I don't really give a shit.
For the record, they really liked Ponyo, but it's not like they are at an age yet where they can explain why they like it beyond a simple gut-check. It was fun because it was colorful and kind and had cute characters and small-scale adventure. Their enjoyment was not a surprise either. This is their third Studio Ghibli film (after Kiki's Delivery Service and My Neighbor Totoro), and they really liked those other two, and Ponyo's thing is that it was explicitly designed for children and families, and not to mention the past three Family Movie Night films have been live-action early-'00s teen classics (two Lohan vehicles and Hathaway's charming breakout film) and maybe it was time to switch it up, so there was very little chance that it was gonna be a flop in the K*** household.
And they liked it, and so did I. But I'm not going to come into this space—Puke on Your Birthday, a very adult-oriented space!!—and say some shit like "this movie was valuable to me because my kids liked it." That might be true for some movies and other entertainment but it's a vapid way of looking at it. I tolerate shit like Frozen 2 because of my kids, I barely like it because they love it, but I'm not gonna say that it's great because they think it's great, ya know? There's gotta be more to it than that. Children are beautiful in their innocence, but c'mon, they don't know shit about movies.
This is all on my mind because my own adult takeaway from Ponyo is that it's a movie about parenthood. I haven't seen this theory around so it's probably a "see what you want to see" or "see yourself in the art" kind of thing, but so be it. But think about it. Fujimoto is a father who has concerns about his daughter Ponyo and her behavior. He struggles with the idea of her growing up and having to make her own mistakes. Ponyo's mother, Gran Mamare, talks him out of taking drastic action, and helps him see that Ponyo is not a thing to be controlled, but rather loved. Lisa goes through a similar path with Sōsuke. She's protective of her son, and goes to great lengths to keep him safe. But when an emergency arises and she has to go, she doesn't flinch at making the hard decision to leave her son in charge of his own destiny.
The fantasy element is that Ponyo and Sōsuke are both five years old, and logically that's too young for any of this shit to be happening. But no one said the movie Ponyo had to be logical. In fact, that's kind of the whole deal with Studio Ghibli films, right? There are magical elements, and the adults in the film never question the magic. They believe, just like the children do. There is never conflict like "I refuse to believe that this magic is real!" like there'd be in American cinema. It requires you to buy into the plot a little more, but it also makes for a more gentle and more satisfying film.
But shit like that, the idea that Ponyo is about being a parent, the idea that we as parents sometimes need to meet our children at their level and buy into the magic they are creating, none of that is something that I would expect to be able to talk to my six-year-old about. She's wicked smart but this kind of thing comes in time. I'm really only here because this is my 207th movie I'm watching for the blog. It takes time. It takes many years, and lots of practice. And I'll never be "good" at it, but I've committed to trying to get there forever.
It's fun because this there's no floor to the depth on films like this, even ostensible children's films. Imagine we're meeting up on Zoom tonight about Ponyo (instead of Rear Window). What would I want to talk about it? Probably I'd talk about the idea of Studio Ghibli films never seeming to have a true villain, which is pretty fascinating in itself, and how Ponyo played off of that idea by presenting Fujimoto originally as the villain, before eventually revealing that he's just a worried father. I'd also want to talk about how we need to adhere only to themes that the film itself is willing to engage in, like how one might be tempted to talk about how "Ponyo's tsunami must have killed a bunch of people," but how that's probably a willful misinterpretation of what Ponyo is attempting to say.
I'd love to get some discussion going in the comment section eventually about shit like this. I also understand that this isn't really something that I can force, especially for the films I'm watching because I want to watch them (as opposed to watching them because Film Club chose to watch them). Watching a film like Ponyo with my kids, though, makes me wonder whether I'll eventually be able to have those types of discussions with them. If not, it's all good. We'll always have Ponyo.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: As implied above, the plan is to have a Zoom discussion with Film Club about Rear Window. I'm hoping that I can take some notes and put together a blog post about it in a couple days. This is the first time, so we'll see how it works out.

No comments:
Post a Comment