Etta James
1960
Honestly, I'm just trying to make it past the title track. If I can do that, I'm good.
"At Last" is a good song, but an overplayed song. If you've been to a wedding in your lifetime, you've probably heard it. If you haven't been to a wedding because you're like sixteen years old and you have your whole life ahead of you, then you've probably heard it in a movie where the love interests have a slow dance together. I can't think of any specific examples of either of these scenarios, so it could be that I'm talking out of my ass here. More likely, though, it's that the song is fucking wallpaper noise, so cliché and trite that it completely blends into the nitrogen in the air when I hear it. The newlyweds might as well be dancing to "4'33"" for all I can fucking hear it in those moments.
Still, c'mon, it's also not as bad as that hyperbolic paragraph makes it out to be. It can't be bad, not with a great singer like Etta James in charge. To my ears, her vocals give Aretha Franklin's a run for her money. She can (and does) sing the treacliest sad depressing ballads on earth, and it still sounds fresh and exciting because of that voice. "My Dearest Darling" and "Stormy Weather" are two of the slowest songs on the album, and also two of the best—how the fuck often do I ever say that about an album?
I read something this week that made Etta James' music fully click for me. Maybe it was supposed to be obvious, I don't know. You can tell me. Here it is: this is the blues. I read someone somewhere say something like "James is the singer that made me realize that the blues didn't have to be an old guy strumming his guitar on the back porch." And that's true, I really would have that image if you had told me to picture "the blues" (Sunny War literally asked me to picture the blues a couple years ago, and I literally wrote about this imagery when prompted). Etta James says that the blues can be lush and big and powerful. The blues is a feeling, and that feeling is usually trending toward sadness, but that sadness can be portrayed as a showstopper, it can wielded like a weapon, it can feel big and powerful and at certain times unstoppable. Etta James makes the blues into something unstoppable.
I don't have enough knowledge to say this definitively or with any evidence, but I'll say it anyway. Etta James invented Motown. Not literally, but you get what I'm trying to say. She spearheaded the sound that that music record label would perfect. Trace "A Sunday Kind of Love" directly to Smokey Robinson, trace "Tough Mary" to the Marvelettes. Had Etta James been surrounded by a little more songwriting talent, she would've been bigger than Diana Ross.
It's an unnecessary argument, because James is still canonical, still one of the all-time greats. I'm just saying that it's easy to see how her greatness inspired so many others to surpass her eventually. But I'm also not saying that this is the Elvis Theory in action. Sure, I'd reach for the Supremes quicker than I would At Last!, but I really like this album, and I don't think it withers under the comparison against its descendants. You might even call it something like "a greatest hits collection of 1950s music," if you consider "greatest hits" to mean "the sounds that are worth keeping from the previous decade to bring into the next." Music blew up in the 1960s—I'm not a boomer so I don't need to obsessively explain to you why that is—and that all starts here. The beginning of the end, the end of the beginning, one voice to bring us into the next.

No comments:
Post a Comment