1982
Barry Levinson
The ideal is that each person is approaching a movie differently, and each viewer has a different takeaway based on their own personal experiences and how they relate to the film they just watched. But that's not always the case. Sometimes, the feelings evoked in a film and the reason that the film worked so well is so universal that similar takeaways are unavoidable. I watched Diner, and I thought about it in a certain way, and I quickly found out that the film is beloved because pretty much everyone who watches it feels the same way. And that's okay!
Here is the sentiment that everyone takes away from Diner: "Hey, these friends are just like my friends!" And it's true. When you have a film that's this comfortable lingering on long, plotless scenes of a group of friends just hanging out and shooting the shit, then it's inevitable that you compare that to all the times that you and your friends did the same thing at that age. Diner is a comfort because it's so true to your own experience. If you love your friends, then you feel all warm and fuzzy when this on-screen group of pals remind you of your friends.
I think in the past I might have said that Diner, in being the same movie for so many people, was a failure in some way, not interesting enough. But now I'm saying that containing emotions so universal that everyone sees the same movie when they watch it is an incredible success. Especially because, I mean think about it this way: yes, everyone is picturing their own friends sitting around the table at a diner, but everyone has a different friend group. That's what makes it special. We all see ourselves in the characters of this film, and none of us are the same, and so Diner has managed to tap into something really special. You see?
I will cop to the possibility that I am only saying this because I am a dude, and this is a dude movie. I mean, Diner does not even try to give any life to any of the female characters. Maaaaybe with Ellen Barkin as Beth, but even then, she ends up being plot fodder for her husband character Shrevie (Danile Stern) and ex-boyfriend Boogie (Mickey Rourke). I'll even admit that Diner dips into misogyny by having the absurd Eddie (Steve Guttenburg) give his fiancée a quiz about the Baltimore Colts football team in order for her to prove that she is "worthy" of marrying him, and everyone goes along with this as if it's normal (including the poor girl's parents, apparently). Not to mention that you don't ever see the fiancée's face, even though the film ends at her wedding.
I'm not defending sexism, but I will defend Diner. This is a slice-of-life film, and it's bold in that it shows a week in the life of a group of friends and doesn't pull punches. These are flawed human beings. They are crude (some more than others), and there is no one in their lives to call them on their shit. But so think about your own group(s) of friends again. What, are they perfect? No. You put up with their shit, their flaws, because they are your friends. I don't expect Billy (Tim Daly) to bail on Timmy (Kevin Bacon) for his drunken bullshit any more than I'd expect any of my friends to bail on me for mine.
There's a scene when the normally level-headed Shrevie goes fucking ballistic on Beth because she put his records out of order. Dude was an asshole, and this makes Diner true to life, because there is that asshole in all of us, all of our friends. Schrevie's friends find out about it and basically say "hey man, hope y'all work it out." And they mean it! It wouldn't be true to life if Boogie had been like "Oh that Shrevie! He needs to learn how to respect women!" That sentiment would be morally true but not true to how we as humans operate. I've witnessed my friends and their partners in blowout fights! They worked it out! We're all still friends!
There's a scene when the normally level-headed Shrevie goes fucking ballistic on Beth because she put his records out of order. Dude was an asshole, and this makes Diner true to life, because there is that asshole in all of us, all of our friends. Schrevie's friends find out about it and basically say "hey man, hope y'all work it out." And they mean it! It wouldn't be true to life if Boogie had been like "Oh that Shrevie! He needs to learn how to respect women!" That sentiment would be morally true but not true to how we as humans operate. I've witnessed my friends and their partners in blowout fights! They worked it out! We're all still friends!
Credit to Barry Levinson for writing a script that allowed for this much grounded work by the actors involved, that left room for natural conversation to flow around coffee and roast beef sandwiches at four in the morning. Credit to the actors involved, that they were able to so accurately portray the comradery that comes so easily for real-life people who are friends for twenty-plus years. Credit to the people I surround myself with, for being so easy to be around.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: I'd like to watch The Spirit of the Beehive. There's an indie rock band who named themselves after this movie, and they are a little too much for me. So I'm assuming that the film itself is going to be challenging too. Maybe if I like the movie, I'll be able to understand the band a little better.

No comments:
Post a Comment