1995
Marc Rocco
I needed this. A pulpy courtroom drama with no grand filmmaking ambitions, just an attempt to tell a gripping story with some competent actors and an intriguing and occasionally moving plot. At the very worst, I'm shoring up my skills at the parlor game Six Degrees to Kevin Bacon. At best, I'm killing two hours on a quiet Thursday morning in the haunted cubicle.
I have arrived here by chance. I was writing a long bit about Kevin Bacon and eventually that bit swerved into some mid-'90s film I'd never heard of. A month or two later, I'm gathering films for a new Never Seen It list and using blog posts with the "Movies" tag for inspiration, and Murder in the First popped up, and so here we are. Maybe that's not purely "by chance." The road to watch this film required like four distinct decisions on my part. I'm mainly just explaining that no one recommended this film to me. It in fact feels like a movie about which no one really remembers its existence. But I'm here, and that's my choice, and it honestly comes down to me just kinda liking these types of films.
"These types of films" is: courtroom dramas. I'm struggling to think of one that I didn't like. I've been in some courtrooms, and none have ever been as exciting as the ones I see on the screen. I'm not a lawyer and so my own experiences have been limited, but I think that if you asked any of the four lawyers on staff here at Puke on Your Birthday (I won't call them out by name, because they'll sue me if I do), they'd tell you the same thing—courtroom proceedings are largely boring. Nothing like you see in the movies.
But that's the whole point, right? I'm not watching movies to see my own droll truancy-related courtroom experiences played back at me. I'm watching to see something I've never seen before. I'm watching for the excitement, the drama, the twists and turns. Creative liberty enhances the movie magic. Sometimes, I don't want to think about accuracy in a movie. Fictional courtrooms seem to get me to the place I wanna be more often than not, and so I lean into it.
Yes, the tropes are here. A lawyer gets assigned to an impossible case and becomes the only one who is actually fighting for his client, and he goes up against great odds and pulls off insane stunts in the courtroom to miraculously sway the jury and save the day. This kind of thing has become a trope because it fucking works. I got wrapped up in the drama. I was right there with the PTSD-riddled Kevin Bacon on the witnessed, dropping a couple tears when he was dropping a couple tears over the idea of standing up against injustice even though it's probably going to mean his life. I don't care if the value of this film as ART is pretty low. It's just entertainment. I was entertained.
The trope of "fighting an unjust system" lends itself to reflection on our current climate, if you want it to. I would understand if you don't. It kinda goes against what I was just saying about this being a fun popcorn flick that doesn't have much value as art, doesn't it? Still, I've been radicalized for a few years now, and so it's kinda impossible at this point to watch a film like this, witness the injustice as portrayed in this particular fictional form, and not think "wow, things are just like this today, or worse!"
Bacon's Henri Young was locked away for a petty crime, was heavily punished when he tried to escape, and that heavy punishment so traumatized him that stabbing an inmate with a spoon became a natural course of action. Christian Slater's James Stamphill then asks the question, was Young a killer, or did the punishment itself turn him into one? It's the same sort of question we ask when police harass a citizen and then arrest him for "resisting arrest," or when a human being from a neighboring country seeks refuge and is sent to a supermax prison because we decide to call immigration "illegal." The real villain is a society that calls human beings "animals" despite the fact that their behavior only occurs because of society's severe limitations.
I don't know if this is worth talking about for a movie like Murder in the First, because I don't know if a movie like Murder in the First has the power to change anyone's opinion about the idea of justice. When someone like me sees a film about the story of Henri Young, I see the character as a symptom of a general illness in our world, an example of how the system crushes those born without the privilege of being spared. When someone more conservative sees a film about Henri Young, they might see him as an exception, a rare case of a man being brutalized by individuals who chose to do harm of their own volition, and who themselves should be punished for their crimes. I don't know what I would do to convince that person to see it my way; I don't expect Murder in the First to do any convincing either.
Especially when that conservative strawman could point toward the "based on a true story" claim, and how the story as portrayed in the film is not all that true. Henri Young committed more crimes to start his sentence, was punished less severely than is shown here, lived years past his big trial and was not a martyr, skipped parole again after release and disappeared forever. He did not "bring down Alcatraz," as the movie posters for Murder in the First claimed. In the context of "this is a movie," I think that's the right decision, to use this real story as the basis for a fictional story about justice and bravery and courtroom theatrics. In the context of "statement about justice," the fictional element blunt the impact that this might have on someone who needs to hear about it and reflect on it.
But that's just me getting on my high horse about social justice, and y'all don't need to hear that right now. When it comes down to it, I don't need to see that type of movie either. I just need to see some people arguing in a courtroom while the ornery judge yells something like "you're out of order!" or "you're dangerously close to contempt!" That's a sweet spot for me. I'm glad I could indulge today. A decent film, but a real good time.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: There are a decent number of films on this list that could easily slot into Family Movie Night, so I'm going to attempt the feat and get my children to watch Ponyo with me. They really enjoyed Kiki's Delivery Service and My Neighbor Totoro, so I don't think it's that tough of a sell.

No comments:
Post a Comment