Saturday, April 12, 2025

A Year of Blind Spots: Tarkus

Joe is working through a list of albums that he considers "blind spots," i.e. albums that he's never heard but feels like he should.


Tarkus
Emerson, Lake & Palmer
1971

What 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die has to say about Tarkus by Emerson, Lake & Palmer:

As the International War Crimes Conference convened in Oslo in June 1971, so Emerson, Lake & Palmer unveiled their sophomore album: a comment on the futility of war, the cover sports an armadillo tank.

Keyboardist Keith Emerson, bassist/singer Greg Lake, and drummer Carl Palmer began work in January on a concept devised on tour by Emerson, inspired in part by Argentine composer Alberto Ginastera, and recorded in six days in February.

"Carl was very stuck by different time signatures," Emerson told Contemporary Keyboard. "He told me that he'd like to do something in 5/4, so I said that I'd keep that in mind and started writing Tarkus from there. Greg wasn't too sure about it. It was too weird. But he agreed to try it, and afterwards, he loved it."

The opening magnum opus is marked by siren-like keyboard and rattling percussion fusillades between "Tarkus" and three adversaries—the brooding "Stones of Years," parping "Iconoclast," and fractious "Mass"—before defeat by an evil "Manticore" of Persian mythology (cue cathedral organ and phased drums).

These battles are flanked by "Eruption"—Emerson's synths, Hammond and Moog, complemented by Palmer's explosive tub swipes—then the soaring "Battlefield" and the dramatic "Aquatarkus." The second half brings light relief with the honky-tonking "Jeremy Bender" and rock 'n' rolling "Are You Ready Eddy?" (for engineer Eddy Offord). "Bitches Crystal" and Infinite Space" are jauntily jazzy, while "The Only Way"—a Bach-based baroque—questions religion.

This is an album that defines prog rock grandeur.

What Joe has to say about Tarkus by Emerson, Lake & Palmer:

I'm on the fence about prog rock (or at least how prog rock existed in the 1970s, anyway). Some of it is cool, some of it is lame. I'm not sure I know how to explain it in full detail what the difference is between the two, but here's the best I can do. I don't like it if it sounds anything like Jesus Christ Superstar.

"Tarkus," the 20-minute epic title track of ELP's second album, doesn't sound anything like Jesus Christ Superstar. It's way heavier, has darker themes, is cooler (by default), features way more cowbell. This is all subjective, but this is how I'm choosing to describe it. I'm sorry. I'm mostly sorry because Easter is in eight days and so I'm going to be subjected to the actual soundtrack, but at least I'm suffering through the real thing instead of suffering through some bullshit that sounds like it.

This is my first experience with Emerson, Lake & Palmer. It's a name I know, and I definitely despise their 102.9 WMGK song of choice that I've heard too many times in my life ("Lucky Man"), but didn't really know anything about them beyond that. (Okay, there's an Emerson St. in my neighborhood, and I often have idle thoughts about Palmer St. in Fishtown, and wonder whether there is a Lake St. somewhere in this city... I just checked, there isn't.) This could have gone either way. Just because it's one of 1001 albums I allegedly have to hear before I die doesn't mean it's any good.

The big centerpiece is good. Real good, even. I love when bands in the 1970s go fucking bugnuts over weird time signatures. I might not be able to drum along, but I love getting lost in the polyrhythms. So give me those 20 minutes over and over. The back half of the album is more hit-or-miss, mostly miss. A band like ELP clearly thrives in the prog rock trenches, and shouldn't have anything to do with honky-tonk pianos and doo-wop facsimiles. That shit's lame. That's sub-JCS lame. I don't even know what to say about it that could be worse than that.

I don't know, man... maybe I'm just less interested in any music that comes on after the epic highs of "Tarkus." Maybe I suddenly hate "Thunder Road" if it comes on the iPod shuffle after "Tarkus." So I won't go too far in my criticisms of such dumb-sounding songs as "Bitches Crystal." Instead, we can focus on the good stuff. You want some prog rock that doesn't sound like some dumb bullshit about Jesus as a hippie? Click play below, and then feel free to click pause after 21 minutes.

No comments: