Margaret Glaspy
Week 61: March 29-April 4, 2020
Sunny's review on this one was the best review I've reread in a while for this column. Not just because he's a good writer and not just because his was the only other review besides my own for this album, but also because it finally, finally acknowledged COVID in an album review. Not only that, but he managed to tie it into his opinion of Devotion, how the music was nice but felt small next to this global fucking emergency that we were currently dealing with. Good stuff.
I admit that I haven't listened to Devotion too many more times in the past five years. This is what happens when a sophomore album is deemed a slight step down from the sparkling debut album—you find yourself still reaching for the debut more often than not. I would've probably liked Devotion a lot more if I'd never heard of Emotions and Math. Which is a shame, because it's not really that much of a step down, I've decided after a couple of relistens. Yeah, sure, the synths feel a little out of place, but that's just a matter of my expectations being out of sync with Glaspy's intentions. She achieved what she was trying to achieve with this one.
It's just interesting that my review ended with "I'm definitely gonna try this one out a few more times" and then I basically ignored it for five years. I guess technically I wasn't lying when I said that, since here I am, trying it out a few more times, albeit just a little late. Just like I can't possibly understand the emotions that I felt five years ago during the beginning stages of lockdown, I also can't understand why I came down so hard on this cool little album. 2.5 pukes seems harsh. It's a 3-puker at least! Maybe more if my mind had been in a better place!
The intro for the Sunday write-up basically acknowledged how tough it was to care about Record Club during times like those. The number of reviews received proves the claim correct. But it also forces me to remember that frustration at not being able to write like I usually do when I'm by myself. I wasn't by myself anymore, ever. I was home five days a week with the wife and kids. I love them with all my heart but they all make it very difficult to write album reviews as a hobby. In terms of my own writing during those troubled times, this short and light review was probably a low point. Future iterations of album reviews would build upon the fear surrounding COVID explicitly. To talk about "what it sounds like" during a time of international crisis makes the review seem pretty insignificant. It's important to reach and attempt to find the significance.

No comments:
Post a Comment