Good evening ladies and gentlemen, that's all the songs we know, goodbye ladies and gentlemen, so let go.
Friday, April 3, 2020
Devotion, Joe
Devotion opens with the voice of a robot, and continues apace, with plenty of chilling synths and cold beats. This is something I could learn to love, but I'm not quite there yet.
It's tough to write this review without touching on Glaspy's first album, Emotions and Math. I adore that album, a collection of idiosyncratic guitar rock. I have to mention it, though, even if you're reading this having never heard of Margaret Glaspy before this week, because my issues with Devotion stem from Glaspy forgetting the first half of that original equation. There's plenty of cold math here, but where's the emotion?!
She finds it occasionally, to be fair. "Without Him" gets into it during the choruses—Glapsy has a unique and enjoyable voice, and it hits all the right notes on this song, finding the pathos underneath all these unfeeling rhythms. "So Wrong It's Right" rocks out, a welcome upper to distract from all these downers. "Stay with Me" is Glaspy up to her old tricks, and I love it.
But there are others just don't connect in the way that she is so obviously capable of. "What's the Point" layers on these distorted sounds that almost sound like St. Vincent, but it doesn't work nearly as well. "Young Love" has those distant '80s-prom chimes, you know the ones. Meh. "You Amaze Me" brings back the guitar, but goes in the opposite direction—too boring!
I get the clawing desire to stay fresh—had this been Emotions and Math II, maybe the complaint would've been that it's just the same fucking thing. If Glapsy really is making a concentrated effort to "kill what keeps us alive," then good for her. But the results, unfortunately, are uneven, and only occasionally shows sparks of her previous brilliance.
As always, I will wait around long past this week of Record Club is over, to see if anything further reveals itself to me, or if we should just chalk this up to being so close but with no cigar.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment