1973
Víctor Erice
I'm trying to get into the habit of living in the moment while I'm watching movies. I'm not talking about "distractions," though that's important too, of course—put the fucking phone down, focus on the art, don't you dare do the goddamn chores with the goddamn movie in the goddamn background. That's true for all movies. While (fully, intently) watching The Spirit of the Beehive, I was thinking about something else. I was thinking about how I sometimes find my mind getting pulled into the metatextual. I'm thinking too much about the movie while the movie is happening. I wish I could just watch the movie and lose myself in it every time.
This becomes an issue when I'm watching an artful film that does not focus on "action" pieces, and are content to sometimes veer away from any semblance of a plot. I spend too much time preoccupied with wondering what kind of movie it's going to be, whether this quiet, contemplative film is going to suddenly turn violent or something. When Isabelle fakes her death, just a little prank on main character Ana, I sincerely thought that she was dead. And it's not that I think the film would be better or worse if she actually did die, it's more that when that kind of thing happens, I can see the decision tree branching out in front of me. The blog post starts to write itself in my head, and then, when Isabelle wakes up, the eraser has to come out and erase what was written about death suddenly appearing on screen, and so and so on.
Sam and I were talking about this a few weeks ago, how some people don't like Letterboxd because the task of writing a review for a movie distracts them from the act of watching that movie. If you substitute "Letterboxd" for "Puke on Your Birthday," then the problem applies to me too. Well, okay, maybe not a "problem." Did Ebert take notes during his first viewing of a film? Probably. I just think it would be a more meaningful experience if I did away with that, if I just fully engaged with a film and let it wash over me and worry about the deeper discussions after the credits roll.
It's a matter of trust. Trusting yourself to be able to think back on that experience through a critical lens. That's the only difference, whether you're doing it during or afterward. It's important to think critically and deeply about art, it's just a matter of timing, that's all. I could have spent a lot of time during my viewing of The Spirit of the Beehive being preoccupied with those thoughts: why is all this happening, what does it all mean, is something else going to happen, will I be surprised, is this symbolism, why do I feel this way. The cool part is, when you push all those questions to the side until later, you can still manage to be affected by the art, emotionally speaking.
The first question isn't "what did it mean?," but rather "how do I feel right now?" Had I asked myself that at the end of The Spirit of the Beehive, I would've said that watching this film was a meaningful experience. The why doesn't matter, at first. I just knew I saw something special. I spent a lot of time wondering what certain scenes "meant." I spent a lot of time wondering if there was going to be anything "exciting." I don't need there to be, it was just on my mind. I'd argue that there was excitement—the soldier getting found out, the search for Ana, the magical realism of, uh, Frankenstein's monster coming out of the woods.
This is a great film to start to ask these meta questions about the experience of watching movies, because I have very good reason for not fully understanding all of its intentions on the first go-around. The first is that I have never seen the original film Frankenstein, so that means that, probably for the first time, a Never Seen It movie has spoiled another Never Seen It movie on the list. Freshly freed from the shackles of alphabetization, I have moved Frankenstein to the front of the queue, so we will touch back on this next week.
This is a great film to start to ask these meta questions about the experience of watching movies, because I have very good reason for not fully understanding all of its intentions on the first go-around. The first is that I have never seen the original film Frankenstein, so that means that, probably for the first time, a Never Seen It movie has spoiled another Never Seen It movie on the list. Freshly freed from the shackles of alphabetization, I have moved Frankenstein to the front of the queue, so we will touch back on this next week.
But the second part is that this is all supposed to symbolize the repressive Franco regime of post-civil war 1940s Spain. I don't know anything about this, I'm just regurgitating what I'm told, that it's symbolism for a historical time period that I have no clue about. It's fascinating to learn about it from a film context. For example, it's not that Spain "didn't know" what The Spirit of the Beehive was really about, and it's not that the symbolism was so thick that it "snuck through" the intense censors of that country. It's actually that Spain knew full well what was going on here, but let the film be released in Spain (eventually) because they believed it was "too artsy" to be understood by Spaniards. Whoops! Everyone knew anyway!
On the other hand, I don't really care to learn any history from this time period. I'm not saying I'm refusing, and I'm not saying that it wouldn't be helpful, and I'm not saying that I'll never know anything about the Franco regime or the civil war in this country. But I'm not interested enough in it to go out of my way (though I'll probably hear something about Francisco Franco at some point years from now and be like "oh shit, the guy implied in The Spirit of the Beehive!"). I say this because I sincerely don't think I need to know about it to understand the movie, which, yes, is about post-civil war Spain, but it's also about more universal topics as well.
For me, The Spirit of the Beehive is about a child learning the lesson of "kindness as an act of resistance." Ana sees a little girl go against societal norms and act kindly toward a hideous Frankenstein monster who approaches her. She's killed for her efforts (again, this is blank that I'm going to have to fill in next week). After the film, Ana asks her sister about it, why the girls was killed, and why the monster was killed. Isabel, who hasn't learned the lesson about kindness yet, shakes it off as "all movies are fake!" (which is a fucking hilarious takeaway for me in this context, Never Seen It being the antithesis of Isabel's take), but Ana absorbs the lesson all the same. And when she comes across someone whom society has deemed a "monster," she acts kindly. I won't spoil The Spirit of the Beehive like Frankenstein was spoiled for me, but I'll say that it doesn't go well. She knew it wouldn't go well, hence, the bravery of performing the kindness anyway.
It gives me a new perspective on childhood innocent. I think this is probably the "why" of why I felt emotionally impacted by this film, and it's something I'm only coming up with now. Children are deemed "innocent" before they learn harsh truths about the world we live in. They are in default mode, and are only later reprogrammed. Note that in that default mode, children are typically kind. Some may call it naïveté, but I'm thinking now that maybe it's something valuable to be harnessed. Not so much "looking up to children for their effortless kindness," but more so... I don't know, just appreciating the fact that humans are born into this world kind, and that maybe in making efforts to preserve that kindness a little better, we can learn lessons on how to change the world.
And see, I wouldn't have come up with that if I was thinking too hard during the film. Sometimes it takes a little longer. Sometimes it takes years! Like, now I'm thinking that this idea that The Spirit of the Beehive stirred within me is also having a trickle-down effect, and it affords a new perspective on a whole different movie too. I bet you that if I watched Pan's Labyrinth again, being a film that was obviously influenced by The Spirit of the Beehive, a lot of the color I missed would be filled in this time around, the themes of "childhood innocence" fleshed out after further reflection.
So I'm going to keep practicing. I want to be fully present in body and mind for each film that I see. It'll be interesting to find out whether that mindset can be applicable to all movies, or if it was just a valuable experience for The Spirit of the Beehive because it's a verifiable Great Film. Like, six hours after writing this (I'm writing far in advance), I'm planning on taking whichever children wanna go to see A Minecraft Movie, which I imagine is going to be dogshit. But you bet your fucking ass I'll be present, fully alert, and all in.
GRADE: 4.5 pukes out of 5
NEXT TIME: As mentioned above, I am pretty much obligated to watch Frankenstein next. Assuming that two random dudes aren't gonna pull up to my neighborhood with the movie on old-school film reels to show it at the local gymnasium for a dollar a ticket, I'll probably just end up watching it on my work laptop.

3 comments:
I was lucky enough to see this last summer at a revival screening. The magic realism and the call for gentleness reinforced for me that art like "Spirit of the Beehive" is hiding in all corners of the world waiting to be seen.
Víctor Erice released a movie in 2023 called "Close your Eyes," his first narrative feature in 40 years. I bought the Blu-Ray but admittedly have not watched it yet. I think I'd like to rewatch "Spirit" before seeing his new one.
^ This is Sean G. btw.
That's pretty cool that you got to see this in theaters (hopefully some cigar-chomping dudes showed up with the reels last minute in a rickety van). You're right that the magical realism is probably the key here, and how we can think about it alongside the magic of movies themselves, how we are affected by this art so deeply. Let me know how that new movie is when you see it!
Post a Comment