(*ranked based on how I feel about each album presently, not how I felt about it when I wrote the corresponding review)
(**I linked to each of my reviews, but in many cases, maybe even most cases, there were better reviews written that week, so check out the archives to see some of the superior work PoYB's contributors put forth in the past 52 weeks)
(***Should go without saying at this point, but my opinions about any particular album are not a reflection on the person who chose the album originally, and indeed, if you picked an album and I didn't like it, then that means you are challenging me and us and yourself with something otherwise unfamiliar or unloved, and I tend to appreciate those picks more so than safe, fun, 4/5-pukes album picks in the grand scheme of things)
52. Sex over Love by Blaqbonez
2024 was probably the first year of Record Club that didn't feature an album that I fucking HATED. There was nothing that felt insulting or aggravating or offensive. No CANDIACEs or Harlows or Adeles this time around. I don't know if that's a mark of our maturation as a group (choosing albums that aren't necessarily designed to just piss people off, which can be fun, but feels thin sometimes) or a mark of my own maturation as a Music Listener (being able to find something at least interesting in every album, even the bad shit). But something's gotta be last, and this was definitely the worst one. I just didn't hate it like I hate the worst of the worst, if that makes sense. It's possible that I spent so much time building up to it with the dumb premise that maybe the music got squeezed out a bit.
51. II by Boyz II Men
I wish I could say this sucked shit, because I think the way they drag these fucking corpses out for every #Philly event is pretty distasteful and lame, but, ya know, it was just really boring.
50. Infest by Papa Roach
I wish I could say this sucked shit, because I think the way they drag these fucking corpses out for every #Philly event is pretty distasteful and lame, but, ya know, it was just really boring.
50. Infest by Papa Roach
The good song is only good because we were young and impressionable once. The rest of the album betrays the cold hard truth that we all must find in adulthood at some point.
49. A Chaos of Flowers by BIG|BRAVE
Some people can see figures emerging from the white static of a broken TV screen. It's a certain kind of brain. I just don't have that kind of brain. I'm working on it. I think you can train yourself to be that way. I'm almost there. I found value in the exercise. I still couldn't see the art. Not yet.
48. Fallen by Evanescence
This music would be a lot better if they didn't take it so seriously.
47. Sugar Ray by Sugar Ray
I'm sensing a pattern here. If you pick an album based purely on the fact that you liked the big hit from that album when you were a kid, then we are most likely going to find in the present day that the album has a whole lot of filler. "When It's Over" is good in the same way that "Last Resort" is good and "Bring Me to Life" is good. But what the hell else is there? Just the detritus of pop culture's distant past.
46. A Little Bit of Mambo by Lou Bega
Now, on this album, the main song sucks cock. But the album is rescued from the basement of this ranking because it randomly features a deep cut that I fell in love with. Why do I love "Icecream"? I have no idea, man. Maybe because it's funny to love such a song. But I really have listened to that song at least once a week since we covered this wretched mess of an album. Lou Bega, your watch was correct twice today.
45. Oas by Dina Ögon
I'm sure if I listened to this album again, I'd like it. But I don't feel like listening to it. And that's not a good sign, is it? I just keep remembering it as elevator music. I know it's not that. I know it. But for whatever reason, Oas didn't leave a good last impression on me. It's fine. It's good. It's fine.
44. In Real Life by IKE
I listened all year. My ears were open. I would've absolutely noticed if I heard it in the wild. Like at a Phillies game or something. I would've turned to whoever I was sitting next to and been like "Yo, this was a Record Club album, let me tell you about it..." But that never happened! I'm starting to feel like IKE was never all that important to the Philly sports scene in the first place! (To be honest, I'd take IKE over Boyz II Men any day of the week, but obviously I'm in the minority on that one.)
43. My Name Is Joe by Joe
I am not so vain as to claim that My Name Is Joe was better than it was, even if my name is Joe. I honestly just feel bad for how jealous and possessive this Joe sounds throughout. That's not how the ideal Joe should behave!!!
42. A LA SALA by Khruangbin
I was recently told that "Khruangbin is good music to have sex to." This was one of the rare moments in 2024 in which I did not take the mention of an RC band as an excuse to talk about RC.
41. Mindfuck Ultra by Yambag
I don't know if I loved it or even liked it, but it's a nice album to keep in the back pocket. Maybe for a hypothetical situation in which someone says that they like hardcore music and you wanna have something that you can bring to the table. Or maybe just to make a self-owning joke about the weird-ass shit we listen to. "What was the coolest music you heard this year?" "Probably, uhhh.... Mindfuck Ultra?!"
40. Kavana by Zusha
It was a long year. I remember thinking this album was cool but not necessarily catchy. I recall three dudes walking around some fucking cool area of a cool neighborhood in cool cool cool New York City looking impossibly cool. I get the appeal of hipster spiritual music. It was only kind of for me.
39. OIL OF EVERY PEARL'S UN-INSIDES by SOPHIE
Sometimes the artist's death makes the music bigger; I don't think that happened here. Maybe deeper? I appreciated my time with this album. It was fascinating in so many ways. But I haven't listened to it since. I picture it like snorkeling. It's beautiful under the ocean, but I just have trouble breathing through those fucking things without accidentally taking some water in the lungs.
We won't mention the artist's name. Or the subject matter. Or really anything. I really need to relisten to this album. It's hard to believe that we even covered an album like this in Record Club. In other words: WHAT THE FUCK WASSSSSSSS THAT?!
37. Bando Stone and the New World by Childish Gambino
The fact that there is still no update about this alleged film says to me that I was right all along. It's fake. But the album is real, and I kinda liked it. So now I'm wondering if that was the right move, keeping that card close to the chest, or if Glover's final album as Childish Gambino would have landed better if he had revealed his full hand. I have no idea!
36. Metamorphosis by Hilary Duff
There's catchy with a purpose, and then there's catchy for catchy's sake. This album was so catchy, and it was so fucking clear, perhaps more so than any other album we've ever covered here, that it was catchy just to be catchy, just to hide the fact that there was very little substance behind the catchiness. I'm not saying this is a bad thing. I'm saying that it's reed-thin and borderline offensive how sinistrally catchy this motherfucker is. And I kinda like that.
35. Şehir Rehberi by Pamela
This one felt like the album that's suffered the most from being a non-English-speaking collection of songs. I mean, that's my fault, as a lazy audience member. But still. Granting the inevitability that most English-speaking listeners are not going to look up the lyrics' translations, I'd say that I just regret being part of the "most listeners" on this one. It was a concept album! About traveling through town! Seems pretty cool! I didn't get that at all! Fuck me!
34. Cheap Thrills by Big Brother and the Holding Company
Fuck, dude, it's been such a long year. I can remember sitting in a gymnasium somewhere in December 2023 while my kid did Girl Scouts and I'm idling away the hour with the other silent dads who are similarly looking at their phones and I'm writing some notes in my phone about Record Club and deciding that "Cheap Thrills" sounded like a weirdly appropriate album name for our little music club, and then smash cut to twelve months later and I'm wondering where the time went. Janis Joplin, all year. It was pretty good.
33. Teenage Dream by Katy Perry
It was what it was. A glamorous, meteoric pop album. You know all the songs. One thousand of Nate's cousins were able to squeeze out an album review based on that familiarity. Is it good? Does that even fucking matter? I mean, it matters for our purposes, but shit's different out there than it is in here. I will say this: it was fascinating focusing a lot of energy on this wild success in Katy Perry's past, and then almost immediately witness a catastrophic failure of a new album in the present day.
32. empathogen by WILLOW
The bar was extremely low, so nepo baby was always gonna clear it. Absolutely wild that she managed to clear it with such originality and charm.
31. When I Woke by Rusted Root
The big song carries the water for this album. The rest of the songs soundtracked so many pot-fueled soft-swap swinger parties in the '90s.
30. Bo-Day-Shus!!! by Mojo Nixon and Skid Roper
Occasionally clever, occasionally cringe, pretty much instantly memorable based on its proximity to the CLASSIC 1993 motion picture Super Mario Bros. (featuring Mojo Nixon as Toad). If Mojo Nixon is the king, and the king is everywhere, then Mojo Nixon is in my diarrhea.
29. Overthinking Everything by Footballhead
I don't even know what the hell was so bad about my week back in early March that led me to splatter my existential crisis all over this pretty decent album. Whatever happened, it's been solved. I have inklings but let's save 'em for somewhere else besides a blurb of an album that is only kinda pretty sorta great whenever I relisten (which is occasionally).
28. plastic death by glass beach
The band's ambition takes it to some dark places on this one. I've listened to this one more post-AotW-week than almost any other album on this list, and it really just comes down to the ambition swallowing the songcraft occasionally. Still, absolutely wild ambition, and I'm so glad that we tackled it in this club.
27. Forever for Now by LP
I wish more people loved this album (like Zach did). I wish fewer people were uncanny-valleyed out of it (everyone else did, including me). You know who would've flipped their fucking shit over this album? Gary. This would have been his favorite fucking album of all time. 2024 was so full of so many joys, but we really did miss Gary.
26. Sleigher by Ben Folds
The RC annual holiday album has never been this high in the year's-end ranking. It's not recency bias, I swear. I really do think it was a worthwhile album! I won't go as far as to say that it's "an album you could enjoy year-round," but it's the closest we've ever gotten to that in this context.
25. Deeper Well by Kacey Musgraves
I've been hard on Kacey this year because it's fun to punch up, but I'll cop to that fact now, and say that this is a nice album. Real nice. I have no qualms with it staying in the rotation due to familial obligations.
24. everything is alive by Slowdive
I am currently listening to the so-called classic Slowdive album from 1993, Souvlaki, and it's... pretty good! I probably just need a little more time with it. I will say, though, that nothing about it so far has moved me as touchingly as "shanty" and "the slab" did here. It's gonna take some more exploration to figure out what happened in the 30 intervening years between the two.
23. SABLE, EP by Bon Iver
The "back to basics" thing is never a good move, because there are always gonna be diminishing returned. It took me a really long time to understand 22, a Million and i,i, but I'm there now, and I don't wanna go back. I like For Emma, Forever Ago, but at this point it's my least favorite Bon Iver album. I don't need an EP that purposefully sounds like that.Still, a "back to basics" move for Bon Iver is still gonna be great. Especially if it's a throat-clearing EP that doesn't come with any of the baggage that a hypothetical full-on acoustic LP in 2024 would have. I have no fucking qualms sitting down for fewer than fifteen minutes to hear one of the premiere folk talents of our generation bang out some slow, sad ones. Especially this time of year—cold, reflective. There's a reason that the TikTok teens are listening to Xerox copies of this band, even if they're too ignorant to know it. There's a reason that Bon Iver remains the strongest musical link between Ye and Swift. There are some things that are universal.The prevailing theme over these twelve minutes seems to be: guilt. Not being able to move past fuck-ups. Again with the universality of emotion. Who hasn't felt guilt in this way? I totally get the impulse to express that guilt through lush quiet soulful music. I also wish that I was hearing Justin Vernon vomit out that guilt over towering synthesizers that sound like computers fucking each other. But that's just a personal preference. The appreciation remains, even in this guise, the return to basics thing.I remain cautiously optimistic that Bon Iver will remain here, out in the wild center of confusion that is our world, and that they will not retreat back into the wilderness again. Let's not get back to anything too basic.GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
22. Make That Feeling Come Again! by Beautiful Bend
The dusty bargain bins of the metaphorical record stores that RC occasionally plunders will not always yield gold. But it's kinda nice when you find a random and mostly forgotten album in some corner of the music world and you present it to the group and it's... kinda great? Not the best thing ever, but expectations more than surpassed in this case. I wish all disco was like this.
21. Fine Art by Kneecap
20. Blackgrass: From West Virginia to 125th St by Swamp Dogg
I was familiar with Swamp Dogg's first album, and now I'm familiar with Swamp Dogg's most recent album. 54 years and 24 other albums separate the two. And yet there's a constant—Swamp Dogg is weird, and talented, and somehow always the coolest motherfucker in the room, regardless of whether he's doing funk or he's doing bluegrass.
19. 10,000 Days by Tool
I love Record Club and how sometimes it forces me to listen to the long, dense cult classics that I wouldn't have had the stamina to check out otherwise, 10,000 Days was really good, and I have RC to thank for that.
18. Street Worms by Viagra Boys
This—among many other things this year, but definitely this album by Viagra Boys a little bit too—made me realize that we need more strong women to raise strong men. If you're a strong woman, have a son! We need you! To men and women, moms and dads—please stop raising sons that listen to Joe Rogan and vote against women's rights and talk about football and lack empathy.
17. Manning Fireworks by MJ Lenderman
F — fine
I — I should admit that I probably downplay it because it's too popular in the circles I run with
N — no, I certainly don't hate it
E — even though it wasn't the best album that we covered in RC this year, Manning Fireworks was far, far from being the worst
I was familiar with a lot of this album already, and in that way, I processed my nostalgia. I was not familiar with other parts of the album, and, due to the week that it coincidentally lined up with this year in Record Club, I also used Born This Way to process my shock, and then grief. Very weird, very sad, very helpful.
Just relistened to Imaginary People the other day after a hot minute of forgetting about it. I remain impressed! This feels like the type of album I'm going to listen to three times a year and, eventually, after like fifteen years, I'm gonna look back and think that maybe it was one of the best albums that we ever covered in RC. But that kinda thing takes time. It takes decades. I think Viv & Riley have the staying power though.
I'm really, really glad that Rise and Fall came out in 2023, and that this album and artist were mostly left out of the conversation regarding 2024's best because of that. Too complicated. Still, let's all give thanks to the idea of Record Club touching base with the most popular and most complicated and possibly most important pop star of the year. I still don't think it's going to end well, but I'm fascinated with the journey there anyway.
Beirut is an interesting case, and I'm glad we got to explore it in this context. The Beirut that we grew up on seemed big, communal, celebratory. Like many bands from that era, Beirut eventually shrunk in size, and has become a little more insular, a little lonely, a little personal. Rare, though, that a band gets even better under those circumstances. Here is the exception, not sure if it proves any rule.
It was really fucking fascinating to see what Record Club would look like if it regularly pulled 20+ reviews. There was definitely a sense of "okay we're exploring every inch of this thing," which I liked. But I think there was also a sense of averaging out the opinions. Like maybe more reviews means that we walk away thinking that this album was "just okay," since there were just so many opinions. I, for one, really liked this Huey Lewis thing, and I refuse to kowtow to the average.
Almost six years in, and I'm still weary about covering albums that have outsized presences in the music scene already. Any album known as a "classic," in other words. But then the thing about Stankonia is that it's only really known as a "classic" relative to most other music. Within the context of the OutKast discography, I don't see many people ranking it in even the Top 2. I have some more work to do to figure out where it falls for me, but I liked it, and I just thought that maybe the ubiquity of this album and this band did it no favors within RC, that's all.
I wish I had the time and energy to write a "Top Ten Moments in Music This Year" list. If I did, then that rising action on "Killing Time" with the swallowing of the key and all that other stuff would absolutely be #1 for me. Scratches an itch in some unexplainable way. The rest of the album will come in time, if you want it to.
I am glad that this is the Mountain Goats album we landed on, if it was inevitable that RC eventually cover a Mountain Goats album. I wouldn't say that it "sounds like" many or most of their other albums, because they aren't that kind of band. But I also think that it gives the correct impression that these fuckers can do pretty much anything. "Songs about action movies" is a good bit, and they stuck the landing. Now it's time to check out at least twelve other Mountain Goat albums, if you haven't already.
We had some good reviews in Record Club, but this is the album in 2024 that makes me think about some other reviews that I read, on worse publications than PoYB. I think about the Pitchfork review, obviously, and how harsh it was, an opinion which I didn't necessarily agree with, but definitely appreciated in the same way I appreciate a cold splash of water on my face after a good workout. I think too about the Stereogum review, written mere hours after the album's release, that adequately captured the joy of a communal event such as "A-list rap star surprise-releases a great album" (if not necessarily an accurate portrayal of the album itself). I like these two poles, and I like to think that we try to land somewhere in the middle of the two each week in Record Club.
Some albums are great and some albums are impossible to write about because they are great in not necessarily unique ways and some albums are both of those things, at the same time, great and unwritable. Martha's album was that album for us in 2024, to the point where I sat down to write this prompt and had to go back to the review to prove to myself that I actually wrote something and didn't just take a week off so that I could listen to more of Courting Strong.
16. Born This Way by Lady Gaga
I was familiar with a lot of this album already, and in that way, I processed my nostalgia. I was not familiar with other parts of the album, and, due to the week that it coincidentally lined up with this year in Record Club, I also used Born This Way to process my shock, and then grief. Very weird, very sad, very helpful.
15. Imaginary People by Viv & Riley
Just relistened to Imaginary People the other day after a hot minute of forgetting about it. I remain impressed! This feels like the type of album I'm going to listen to three times a year and, eventually, after like fifteen years, I'm gonna look back and think that maybe it was one of the best albums that we ever covered in RC. But that kinda thing takes time. It takes decades. I think Viv & Riley have the staying power though.
14. The Rise and Fall of a Midwest Princess by Chappell Roan
I'm really, really glad that Rise and Fall came out in 2023, and that this album and artist were mostly left out of the conversation regarding 2024's best because of that. Too complicated. Still, let's all give thanks to the idea of Record Club touching base with the most popular and most complicated and possibly most important pop star of the year. I still don't think it's going to end well, but I'm fascinated with the journey there anyway.
13. Hadsel by Beirut
Beirut is an interesting case, and I'm glad we got to explore it in this context. The Beirut that we grew up on seemed big, communal, celebratory. Like many bands from that era, Beirut eventually shrunk in size, and has become a little more insular, a little lonely, a little personal. Rare, though, that a band gets even better under those circumstances. Here is the exception, not sure if it proves any rule.
12. Fore! by Huey Lewis and the News
It was really fucking fascinating to see what Record Club would look like if it regularly pulled 20+ reviews. There was definitely a sense of "okay we're exploring every inch of this thing," which I liked. But I think there was also a sense of averaging out the opinions. Like maybe more reviews means that we walk away thinking that this album was "just okay," since there were just so many opinions. I, for one, really liked this Huey Lewis thing, and I refuse to kowtow to the average.
11. Stankonia by OutKast
Almost six years in, and I'm still weary about covering albums that have outsized presences in the music scene already. Any album known as a "classic," in other words. But then the thing about Stankonia is that it's only really known as a "classic" relative to most other music. Within the context of the OutKast discography, I don't see many people ranking it in even the Top 2. I have some more work to do to figure out where it falls for me, but I liked it, and I just thought that maybe the ubiquity of this album and this band did it no favors within RC, that's all.
10. Imaginal Disk by Magdalena Bay
I wish I had the time and energy to write a "Top Ten Moments in Music This Year" list. If I did, then that rising action on "Killing Time" with the swallowing of the key and all that other stuff would absolutely be #1 for me. Scratches an itch in some unexplainable way. The rest of the album will come in time, if you want it to.
9. Bleed Out by the Mountain Goats
I am glad that this is the Mountain Goats album we landed on, if it was inevitable that RC eventually cover a Mountain Goats album. I wouldn't say that it "sounds like" many or most of their other albums, because they aren't that kind of band. But I also think that it gives the correct impression that these fuckers can do pretty much anything. "Songs about action movies" is a good bit, and they stuck the landing. Now it's time to check out at least twelve other Mountain Goat albums, if you haven't already.
8. GNX by Kendrick Lamar
We had some good reviews in Record Club, but this is the album in 2024 that makes me think about some other reviews that I read, on worse publications than PoYB. I think about the Pitchfork review, obviously, and how harsh it was, an opinion which I didn't necessarily agree with, but definitely appreciated in the same way I appreciate a cold splash of water on my face after a good workout. I think too about the Stereogum review, written mere hours after the album's release, that adequately captured the joy of a communal event such as "A-list rap star surprise-releases a great album" (if not necessarily an accurate portrayal of the album itself). I like these two poles, and I like to think that we try to land somewhere in the middle of the two each week in Record Club.
7. Courting Strong by Martha
Some albums are great and some albums are impossible to write about because they are great in not necessarily unique ways and some albums are both of those things, at the same time, great and unwritable. Martha's album was that album for us in 2024, to the point where I sat down to write this prompt and had to go back to the review to prove to myself that I actually wrote something and didn't just take a week off so that I could listen to more of Courting Strong.
My review was 652 words long, which is absolutely one of the shorter reviews I wrote this year. But there was a time in the past when those 652 words would have been comprised mainly of such sentiments as "I don't know what to write here, there's nothing to write about, I'm padding the word count by writing about the fact that I don't know what to write about." Not doing that whole thing this time around shows growth and promise. Loving this band and loving their first album just as much as I love the rest of the albums I was already familiar with proves that I will never grow or change, that I'll always be the same.
6. The Blonde & Pink Albums by Trixie Mattel
By far the biggest surprise of Record Club this year, and it's not even close. Do you know how much I am dreading the return of Drag Race in a couple weeks? I turn into the protagonist of American Fiction whenever I watch that show (getting Jeffrey Wright as a guest judge would be such an insane pull for that show, but I am going to try to wish it into existence). The women look beautiful on stage but have personalities that are mostly nails on a chalkboard for me. Have you heard their music? Holy shit. Hand me the noose.
And yet here is a winning drag queen, Trixie Mattel, who sounds like the second coming of Adam Schlesinger. What the fuck?! How did this happen? I am not complaining. This album brought me so much joy this year. But a lot of that joy came from the sheer improbability of the thing, that's all.
At some point in the summer, we were coming home from somewhere, maybe a Phillies game? It was late, and the kids were half-sleeping and half-restless, and Pam puts on a bullshit algorithm soothing sounds thing, and I'm like, yo, we listened to an album a few months ago that would be perfect for this situation. So we listened to Waak Waak ga Min Min. Now that's what I think about when I hear this album. The hook for me with this thing has always been the wide scope of legend and storytelling; I'm still adding to the story.
I'll always take the argument over ignoring the argument. It's my fatal flaw. I lack just enough humility to always be drawn to arguing the fact that I am RIGHT. So it makes sense that my hook for this one is "I don't really agree with this dude." Certainly not in a right-left way (can't imagine any conservative musicians ending up at #4 on such a list), but more in a "we believe the same basic principles but use them to view the world differently" sort of way. Which is totally cool. It actually helps me appreciate the album! Doesn't hurt that most of this shit is painfully catchy as well!
I mostly appreciate the opportunity to explore new (to me) music in Record Club, but every once in a while, it's nice to place roses at the feet of albums that I already know very well and love deeply. There's an alternate scenario in which I'm approaching this album from the vantage point of someone who is familiar with the first two album and doubts whether the rest of the discography can measure up. Sure, in that case, I'd be saying that Infinite Arms is pretty good, pretty good, ya know, more of the same, yadda yadda. But I've had so much fucking time to let this thing breathe. A lifetime of Band of Horses. I'll take a few more lifetimes of this, please. Infinite, perhaps.
Cheating! Choosing one of the most critically acclaimed bands of all time, and then choosing the album that has more or less been crowned as the best album that band ever did, at least by large swaths of budding music critics in the upcoming generation. It's cheating! Of course I loved this! I always have!
5. Waak Waak ga Min Min by Waak Waak Djungi
At some point in the summer, we were coming home from somewhere, maybe a Phillies game? It was late, and the kids were half-sleeping and half-restless, and Pam puts on a bullshit algorithm soothing sounds thing, and I'm like, yo, we listened to an album a few months ago that would be perfect for this situation. So we listened to Waak Waak ga Min Min. Now that's what I think about when I hear this album. The hook for me with this thing has always been the wide scope of legend and storytelling; I'm still adding to the story.
4. Love Ire & Song by Frank Turner
I'll always take the argument over ignoring the argument. It's my fatal flaw. I lack just enough humility to always be drawn to arguing the fact that I am RIGHT. So it makes sense that my hook for this one is "I don't really agree with this dude." Certainly not in a right-left way (can't imagine any conservative musicians ending up at #4 on such a list), but more in a "we believe the same basic principles but use them to view the world differently" sort of way. Which is totally cool. It actually helps me appreciate the album! Doesn't hurt that most of this shit is painfully catchy as well!
3. Infinite Arms by Band of Horses
I mostly appreciate the opportunity to explore new (to me) music in Record Club, but every once in a while, it's nice to place roses at the feet of albums that I already know very well and love deeply. There's an alternate scenario in which I'm approaching this album from the vantage point of someone who is familiar with the first two album and doubts whether the rest of the discography can measure up. Sure, in that case, I'd be saying that Infinite Arms is pretty good, pretty good, ya know, more of the same, yadda yadda. But I've had so much fucking time to let this thing breathe. A lifetime of Band of Horses. I'll take a few more lifetimes of this, please. Infinite, perhaps.
2. In Rainbows by Radiohead
Cheating! Choosing one of the most critically acclaimed bands of all time, and then choosing the album that has more or less been crowned as the best album that band ever did, at least by large swaths of budding music critics in the upcoming generation. It's cheating! Of course I loved this! I always have!
I appreciate the pick, sarcastic words about cheating aside. Those four weeks of RC in April were designed to attract as many reviews as possible, designed to make the album captains try to game the system by choosing popular albums. In Rainbows was an all-timer of an attempt. The biggest swing is still admirable even if you miss the ball completely, pulling half the reviews as your Katy Perrys and your Huey Lewises. "Nice cut!" I'll yell from the bleachers.
For as long as we continue to perform the weekly ritual of Record Club, I plan on performing this yearly ritual of ranking all my favorite albums of the Record Club year here within the final review of that year. I wonder how often, when all is said and done, that my favorite RC album will also be an album that was released that current year. I can imagine not that often? Because the thing about RC is that there's always gonna be a couple "classic" albums that come in well-established, and the End of the Year list offers no handicaps for those albums without that benefit.
1. Tigers Blood by Waxahatchee
For as long as we continue to perform the weekly ritual of Record Club, I plan on performing this yearly ritual of ranking all my favorite albums of the Record Club year here within the final review of that year. I wonder how often, when all is said and done, that my favorite RC album will also be an album that was released that current year. I can imagine not that often? Because the thing about RC is that there's always gonna be a couple "classic" albums that come in well-established, and the End of the Year list offers no handicaps for those albums without that benefit.
And yet here we are, Tigers Blood, approximately nine months old, easily the best album we covered in RC 2024. Easily the best thing Katie Crutchfield has ever done, too. The fact that Tigers Blood isn't #1 on my overall Top Albums of 2024 list should easily prove that it was a strong year of music (either that or I have a subconscious aversion to placing the same artist at #1 over multiple years, and Saint Cloud was just as good in 2020). I don't need any more time than this. It's already a classic.
The great thing about this fucking album is that it's grown, and I've grown, and we've grown together, me and Tigers Blood, these last nine months and change. All those good, hearty, complicated emotions that I was dealing with vis-à-vis Tigers Blood and through my album review, I've continued to examine them, and the emotions have flowered and have become even more beautiful, and Tigers Blood has been here the whole fucking time, soundtracking that journey. It's been something.
I would've loved Tigers Blood even if RC hadn't covered it. But I'm thankful that RC gave me the opportunity to see it the way I did, at the time, and document that experience in real time.

3 comments:
TOOL OVER KNEECAP DROP YOUR LOCATION
excellent point mr spooky. i think i basically agree with 9--down, i'd have to give magdalena bay another listen but i don't think i get it. def would prob have the same #1, waxahatchee on a dynasty run
I better watch that movie if Anonymous, Mr. Spooky, and brocarthy are all recommending.
Waxahatchee forever.
Post a Comment