![]() |
| as always, a stolen photo with no artists featured on this list |
"Listen to more music, but listen to less new music." This was one of my resolutions for 2024. It's one of the rare resolutions that I actually followed through with. I listened to a lot of music. Much less of that was new music released this year.
Doing the math: 27% of the albums I listened to in 2024 were released this year. That's compared to 45% in 2022 and 46% in 2023. A noticeable effort to listen to some older albums! And I think my year was better for it! I was just following my bliss, man.
Now, that doesn't mean I didn't listen to any new music. 90 albums were considered for today's list, which is still a lot! In some ways, making this Top Ten was easier than it's ever been. All I did was think about which albums I still love listening to, which albums I kept returning to day after day after day this year. The reasoning as described for each album below comes afterward; the real reason is that it was fun to listen to. That's it.
So here are my favorite 2024. Hopefully you can follow your bliss and find something you like here too.
Honorable Mentions (in alphabetical order by artist name): POPCORN by the Bawdies; Five Dice, All Threes by Bright Eyes; Final Summer by Cloud Nothings; All Hell by Los Campesinos!; Permanent Repeat by Macseal; Dulling the Horns by Wild Pink
Top Ten Albums of 2024
10. The New Sound by Geordie Greep
The tenth spot on such a list feels like the right place for an album that you don't even know whether it's good or not but it feels so preposterous that you can't help but respect it at the very least and at most obsessively spin it over and over and over. Y'all listen to this shit yet? I know Greeptober is over, but we're still out here, bumping the eight-minutes jazz-prog songs about fucking in the steakhouse bathroom. Greeptober never ends.
The tenth spot on such a list feels like the right place for an album that you don't even know whether it's good or not but it feels so preposterous that you can't help but respect it at the very least and at most obsessively spin it over and over and over. Y'all listen to this shit yet? I know Greeptober is over, but we're still out here, bumping the eight-minutes jazz-prog songs about fucking in the steakhouse bathroom. Greeptober never ends.
9. Flight b741 by King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard
This is not the first time my sister forced my hand and made me listen to the new King Gizz. It probably won't be the last, since these fuckers release like eight albums a year. I am glad she is a Lizard Wizard fan who is self-aware though, and that she is selective with what she sends over the blogging airwaves to my ears. This shit? This is my shit. Flight b741 finds the prolific band in a mode and style that goes down real easy. Kinda CCR meets Grateful Dead? Or roots rock meets jam band at least. And with an energy to outpace most of the output from either of those bands or genres. I don't need all the bullshit this band churns out. I just need the stuff I can blast out the windows on the highway.
This is not the first time my sister forced my hand and made me listen to the new King Gizz. It probably won't be the last, since these fuckers release like eight albums a year. I am glad she is a Lizard Wizard fan who is self-aware though, and that she is selective with what she sends over the blogging airwaves to my ears. This shit? This is my shit. Flight b741 finds the prolific band in a mode and style that goes down real easy. Kinda CCR meets Grateful Dead? Or roots rock meets jam band at least. And with an energy to outpace most of the output from either of those bands or genres. I don't need all the bullshit this band churns out. I just need the stuff I can blast out the windows on the highway.
I'm less concerned with the "return to his roots!" narrative that everyone seems intent on pushing with No Name. I like when artists get weird. I'm not saying that I always enjoy listening to the batshit stuff, but I definitely always respect it. Not too many other people liked Boarding House Reach, et al., and that's fine. I'm glad those people found their way back with No Name, the album that Jack White released by placing unlabeled vinyl LPs in gift bags at his own Third Man record stores. Mainly, it just sounds like Jack White having fun. I like the weird, but I also like the fun. The sound of a really good musician bashing out some garage rock tunes and recording them live is, like, totally my fucking thing. It's not weird, and it doesn't always have to be.
Another blurb regarding concerns about how the blogosphere views the artist versus how I view them, which I guess is always going to be a concern on a blog that doesn't do much in the way of "breaking music" so much as it does a really good job of taking music that is already pretty popular (again, relative to the music blogs) and putting personal spins on it. Do I totally need to know that Liquid Mike was picked out of obscurity and now is a certified low-to-mid-tier pop punk band? No, not really (though I think it's cool that Mike could quit his dayjob as a mailman and tour for as long as the hype will carry 'em). Did that narrative shoot this album up to #7 on this list? Again, no. I acknowledge that the narrative is the reason I heard of them at all. But narrative isn't enough. It would be nothing if the album behind it wasn't lethally catchy throughout its entire 25 minutes. But who the fuck am I? Just some guy pushing his own narrative, that's all.
On this side of the early November events that we shall no longer speak of here, it's tougher than ever to follow Willi Carlisle's example. In the title track, he takes his last stand and fights for what is right, even if for his efforts he called "a queer and a communist." More power to him. I'm tired, man. I'm just tired of having endless empathy for the people who hate me. It's worn on me so goddamn much. Listening to Critterland is a balm, but it only goes so far. This wasn't my favorite album of the year, though it was the album I needed the most, I think. It's more cathartic to hate sometimes; it's harder but healthier to love.
The album cover is pretty concerning, and possibly very bad, depending on how I'm feeling. But I'm trying to figure out a way to describe the ways in which Fontaines D.C. really stretched their own limits on ROMANCE, and maybe that horrific cover is the best way to do it. There's a face on there, right? A face that I assume was, uh, stuck in that pink shape, and, um, the face is pushing against the walls of its container and is trying to break free and the shape is now misshapen and only ironically does it look like a heart, distorted and ugly but also symbolizing love? Oh god, get me out of this fucking blurb, what the hell. Fontaines D.C. fucking bring it on ROMANCE. They've never sounded like this. They are still reaching.
I take recommendations from friends seriously. Even if the recommendation is only implied when that friend posts a song from that recommendation on a blog. Even if that friend asterisked his own recommendation by naming the ways it could have been better. Even if that friend is getting fatter and older and crankier by the day. Every recommendation is an opportunity to discover something new about the music, your friend, and yourself. I discovered in Kid Chameleon that there are still obscure artists out there who are making music as huge as this. I discovered that I don't need the production to be pristine or cost thousands of dollars for it to be big and have a big impact. I discovered a new artist that I would follow anywhere they go next—which will require some effort, since I'd never heard of them outside of the confines of PoYB. But the effort will be worth it. Consider this recommendation a success.
This was the first time that a new Waxahatchee album had the same sound and style as the last Waxahatchee album. Maybe that's why Tigers Blood is at #3, whereas Saint Cloud was #1 on its own year-end list (or maybe just that there are two better albums this time, who knows). This is not revelatory—Katie Crutchfield is extremely comfortable in this sort of indie-Americana mode, and if she stays here for the rest of her career, never swerving into completely new lanes like she used to, then I'll still be satisfied.
A level-up does not require a genre-switch, by the way. Yes, don't let the numbers fool you. Tigers Blood is better than Saint Cloud in every conceivable way. Songwriting even sharper, poetry just as obscure and just as likely to cut close to the bone, guitar licks at once lackadaisical and breathless, hooks abound.
I don't know what else to say anymore, except that Waxahatchee is a very special artist, and most assuredly my favorite artist ever whose discography starts after 2010. Weird qualifier, sure, but just remember all the music that I love just because it hit me during my formative years. Waxahatchee is an artist that is landing those punches to my soul without a handicap. I'm a fully-grown adult, and when I listen to Tigers Blood, I still feel those same old feelings of life being full and wild and weird and complicated and so so fucking worth it.
Here is a short list of things that brat did not do. It did not inspire me to act younger than my age. It did not make me join TikTok. It did not lift Charli XCX into the pop star A-list pantheon. It did not affect my summer in any non-musical way. It did not save our democracy.
Here is a shorter list of things that brat did. It made me believe in pop music again. It made me buy into the insane hype. It made me dance.
Believe what you've heard. This is the pop album of the year, and probably will be the pop album of the decade when everything is settled. There are just too many perfect songs on here for anything else to top it. I guess it might feel a bit frivolous on the surface, with the club beats and hyperpop stylings? But there's no bottom to the depth of this thing. Every song means something. Every song is a sincere autobiographical exercise into the mind of its author. This isn't pop music as a way to get streams (though hopefully they came too). This is pop music as an exploration of the self.
I won't say more, because I'm some 36-year-old asshole with a blog, and if I am the one doing the overhyping, then I'll ruin the whole thing for everyone. Suffice it to say that there's never, in my entire lifetime, been an album that sounded like this but has affected me emotionally like that.
I ultimately think that it has to tell you something about life. That's what I think should be a qualifying measure for the Best Album of any given year. It's gotta be good, too—musically, lyrically, overall gestalt. Of course that should be true, but that's true for a lot of the albums on these types of lists. Favorite albums are by definition those good enough to repeat and never get sick of. But what makes an album the best? I'd say that it's an album that transcends all that, and feels bigger than it actually is, due to, I dunno, just a gut feeling, maybe.
I ultimately think that it has to tell you something about life. That's what I think should be a qualifying measure for the Best Album of any given year. It's gotta be good, too—musically, lyrically, overall gestalt. Of course that should be true, but that's true for a lot of the albums on these types of lists. Favorite albums are by definition those good enough to repeat and never get sick of. But what makes an album the best? I'd say that it's an album that transcends all that, and feels bigger than it actually is, due to, I dunno, just a gut feeling, maybe.
The Past Is Still Alive is my favorite album this year. I don't think it was the album that I listened to the most, but that's not really a measure of a best album. I listened to Hurray for the Riff Raff a fuck-ton, of course. This was a great album, after all. But I'm not measuring it based on quantity. There's more to it than that. More than anything, The Past Is Still Alive felt IMPORTANT to me in ways that I am possibly still grappling with. But in the grappling, I knew for sure that this was my favorite. The grappling is the best part sometimes.
Hurray for the Riff Raff, and the indomitable Alynda Segarra, crafted an album that at once feels like a lazy day at the desert plain dive bar and an essential and desperate treatise on what it means to hold on tightly to the tragedies and lessons of the past. The pace is languid, but the focus on what's come before is anything but. In one song, the narrator hears a friend talking about celebrity culture and flashes back to when they were little and eating their meals out of the garbage. In another, there's a flashback all the way to when indigenous people used to hunt buffalo, and the patience and solemnity that act required. The album starts in media res, with Alynda's father telling them that he is dying of cancer. The album ends with multiple voicemails from that father. In between, an obsession with making an impression in the present by appreciating the footsteps we left behind us in the past. I don't know how to sum any of this up. Segarra clearly does.
The themes of "looking back" and having to get in this mindset to write this blurb are probably why I'm leaning on the idea of "what makes a #1 album" so heavily in this space. Thinking back on previous Favorite Albums of the Year, is The Past Is Still Alive the slowest? Probably! Even at its fastest, it really only reaches medium pace. But then again, I'm getting older, man. I'm not able to keep up sometimes. And often, it's like the final chorus of the final (actual) song on here: "To watch the world burn, with a tear in my eye." Let's not speed toward our end. Let's take our time a little.
The themes of "looking back" and having to get in this mindset to write this blurb are probably why I'm leaning on the idea of "what makes a #1 album" so heavily in this space. Thinking back on previous Favorite Albums of the Year, is The Past Is Still Alive the slowest? Probably! Even at its fastest, it really only reaches medium pace. But then again, I'm getting older, man. I'm not able to keep up sometimes. And often, it's like the final chorus of the final (actual) song on here: "To watch the world burn, with a tear in my eye." Let's not speed toward our end. Let's take our time a little.
See you tomorrow for our Best Songs of 2024!











3 comments:
You're such a greep freak.
January 14th at First Unitarian if you're looking for a good mid-week trip down from Rochester. The over/under for the number of women in the audience is set at 3.5.
The over/under for the number of guys wearing deodorant is also set at 3.5.
Post a Comment