I was thinking about the Overton window. That's a word for the range of political discourse that is acceptable at any given time to the general public. Anything inside the window is popular, or sensible, or at least acceptable. Anything outside the window is radical, unthinkable. And that window can shift, is the thing. Changes in the landscape moves the window, and sometimes once-radical policy becomes more generally acceptable as more and more people become attracted to and more accepting of that policy. Think about how, to conservatives in the '80s, aligning with Russia would have been unthinkable; now think about how many MAGAs today express a desire to worship Putin due to his unsavory connections with trump. Or, less pessimistically: think about how viciously homophobic public policy was even a few decades ago; now think about how gay marriage is enshrined into federal law, and the White House is lit up like a rainbow during Pride Month. The Overton window has shifted.
I wasn't thinking about politics too much this week, though, since that shit gives me an ulcer, but I was thinking about the general idea of "what is acceptable to your average person" in the course of listening to SOPHIE's one true studio album. This music feels radical. It feels different enough that your average listener is not going to like it, or possibly even be able to stand it for more than a few seconds. And yet, it sounds important in the way that it's so large and so different that it single-handedly manages to shift the pop music Overton window toward its abrasive sounds.
I think that's what people mean when they talk about SOPHIE's legacy. I don't say that confidently because I'm not close enough to the world of pop music to be able to say definitively either way. I do know, even just from listening to pop music chosen in Record Club, that this doesn't really sound like anything we've heard before. 100 gecs is obviously the closest, but I don't think you could call that "pop." That was more of a "little bit of everything." I was reluctant to gec out at the time, but their two albums have really done a great job in the four years since in shifting my own personal Overton window, in terms of what music I hear at acceptable vs. unthinkable.
But it was her role as a producer and song creator and sound creator within that specific realm of music—"pop music," more of a description of the tonality of the music as opposed to its literal popularity—that makes her important. It's not a direct impact; SOPHIE didn't change everything forever. But by giving us something so strange and caustic and yet still very catchy at certain moments and on certain hooks, she moved the needle a little bit from dead center to a bit left of center. Normality doesn't change all at once, it changes in inches, and OIL OF EVERY PEARL'S UN-INSIDES is a measure of one of those inches.
I think it's important to distinguish between the two types of songs on this album. The first song is the one that sounds, from a very distant perspective, like your typical dance-style upbeat pop song, but with lots of harsh sounds layered on top. An example of this is "Ponyboy," which you could hear Beyoncé singing, were it not for the clanging of pipes and screeching of tires and colossal bass drops over squelching discordant synths. The second type of song completely deconstructs the pop song format, dissolves it in acid until it's basically unrecognizable. An example for this type would be "Not Okay," with its GURLLL transported from a different song and left on skip as the horror film creeping noises and static tear it to shreds.
I have to imagine that the latter was purposefully melded into this album, in its second half, to really push boundaries. There's a version of this album that's all "Immaterial," and that album is hypothetical amazing. But instead, we have some of that, and some this, the ghostly chanting of "Infatuation" and the deep cavernous nothingness of "Pretending." I understand the choice. There were times that I regretted the choice—because "Immaterial" is just so goddamn good—but I get it. You can entrench yourself in what is already known to be good, or you can venture out into the bad so that what is considered "good" changes. SOPHIE made a sacrifice to shift the window of pop music. I don't necessarily love every song, but I am glad that these songs exist and are functional in an ever-changing landscape.
Will we ever have a song that tops the Billboard Hot 100 and sounds exactly like "Faceshopping"? Absolutely not. But pop music is only able to be great when it gets weird, and SOPHIE showed that there's a path for a pop music to sound kind of like this maybe a little bit if you squint, which is better than nothing. And remember that SOPHIE is gone from this world, too, and that's why we're talking about "legacy" and not "what she's gonna do next." Her music by necessity is going to live through the work of others, and the music that is created in her wake.
I can say that there are moments on OIL OF EVERY PEARL'S UN-INSIDES that have already burrowed deep inside of me, and that there are also moments that are waaaay too much for me, or even maybe forgettable at the end of the day. But sometimes it's more important to look at this from outside the self (the un-inside). What does SOPHIE mean to me, yes, but more crucially, what does SOPHIE mean to your average listener? And although that average listener will most likely never even give this specific album a listen at all, they'll be hearing distant echoes of it for a long time.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment