***SPOILERS!!***
1995
David Fincher
Occasionally, I'll affix a spoiler warning to the tops of these posts, but part of me wants to believe that they are unnecessary. You can't be reliant on warnings. You gotta be your own advocate. Now, some people don't really care if they are "spoiled" to a particular plot point in a movie (or TV show, etc.), and don't even care if that plot point is designed to be a surprise. Obviously I'm not one of those people. I believe in the power of storytelling, and I believe that the storyteller should have all the tools at their disposal, including that of shock and surprise and the release of tension built through mystery and the solving of that mystery. If you're like me, you don't need a spoiler warning for these blog posts—if you haven't seen the movie, you ain't reading, period.
All my life, I've viewed Se7en in these terms. That there was a big reveal at the end, and that it was shocking, and that it made the experience of watching this movie worth it and then some. Way back in elementary school, I recall a conversation with a friend in which he described the opening scene, something about a man who was purposefully fed too much and then killed. Hand to god, this was the same kid who was quoting Ace Ventura too much. It feels weird that a fourth grader would have been watching Se7en, but honestly, I think I'd prefer my kids to watch this film than Ace Ventura. Anyways, the kid said that the ending was crazy.
Must've been years later when I caught a few minutes of the film on basic cable (the scene in which Mills and Somerset chase the killer through the rain). I remembered the (slightly inaccurate) description from grade school, and I'm intrigued. But life's circumstances dictated that I didn't have the time to watch the movie then, for whatever reason, probably something banal like work schedules or whatever. But I promised myself that I would one day watch the entirety of Se7en. Not sure why I didn't just go out and rent it at Blockbuster or get a Netflix DVD as soon as I could, but you know how it goes. It became a test—how long could I go without having the big reveal spoiled for me?
And of course, I remember when I was finally spoiled to the fact of what was in then box. It was the meme bros. Always is. I was at an outdoor viewing of a Hallloween movie at Kev's apartment in Cheltenham. I don't remember the movie and I don't remember why someone started doing the meme of Brad Pitt yelling "What's in the box?!" However, someone needed to take it a bit further. A friend of a friend, that fucker, went ahead and yelled out "It's Gwyneth Paltrow's head!" I had failed as a movie-watcher. I had failed as a person. I allowed this particular film to linger, unwatched, for years, until it was finally spoiled for me.
It was probably only a few more years in between that fateful night and the creation of this list of 200 movies I've never seen before, thus giving Se7en a deadline. I would finally watch this goddamn film, spoiled or no. Smash cut four years and 152 movies later, and I'm finally here. So the questions become: Was it a good film, despite knowing one crucial fact about its ending? Can I get to a place emotionally in which I can feel the surprise, even though it's no longer a surprise? And is there still room for surprise, perhaps in the way that the big reveal comes about, even if the reveal itself is already known?
And of course, I remember when I was finally spoiled to the fact of what was in then box. It was the meme bros. Always is. I was at an outdoor viewing of a Hallloween movie at Kev's apartment in Cheltenham. I don't remember the movie and I don't remember why someone started doing the meme of Brad Pitt yelling "What's in the box?!" However, someone needed to take it a bit further. A friend of a friend, that fucker, went ahead and yelled out "It's Gwyneth Paltrow's head!" I had failed as a movie-watcher. I had failed as a person. I allowed this particular film to linger, unwatched, for years, until it was finally spoiled for me.
It was probably only a few more years in between that fateful night and the creation of this list of 200 movies I've never seen before, thus giving Se7en a deadline. I would finally watch this goddamn film, spoiled or no. Smash cut four years and 152 movies later, and I'm finally here. So the questions become: Was it a good film, despite knowing one crucial fact about its ending? Can I get to a place emotionally in which I can feel the surprise, even though it's no longer a surprise? And is there still room for surprise, perhaps in the way that the big reveal comes about, even if the reveal itself is already known?
I fucking HATE being spoiled, and so I just don't think that second question is ever going to be possible for me. It bothered me throughout the film that I knew the ultimate mystery's answer. A film is often designed like a journey that you are taking with its characters. Part of the emotional payoff is that you are experience intense feelings along with those characters. So it should have caused me just as much pain as it did Somerset when the bloody box was opened and we both realize what is in it. Instead, it clicked for me a lot earlier. There was a gap between my understanding and Somerset's, and the dramatic irony created in that gap felt unfair and cheap.
To answer the first question, I'll say that I still really liked the movie. It wasn't like the entire film was asking the question of what is in the box. That was just a question thrown in there in the final ten minutes or so. The question through the first 110 minutes of the film was basically: who is the killer, and why is he killing in this manner? You have Morgan Freeman's Somerset, a grizzled veteran who's seen it all, who goes to the library when he needs answers, who is scheduled to quit this job, so numb is he to the atrocities he witnesses daily. You have Brad Pitt's Mills, a hothead with good intentions, who moved to the city with dreams of making a difference somehow. They are working together to solve a series of murders, all connected, murders that the serial killer is explicitly stringing together by attaching each to one of the seven deadly sins. Who is the killer? Why is he doing this? How is he doing this? What can be done to stop him? These are the questions presented to the audience throughout Se7en's runtime. Some of the questions are even cut at the knees, like when "who is the killer?" is solved when the killer turns himself in with 30 minutes left in the film. It's a well-constructed film.
And very dark and gritty. Literally. The entire movie seems to take place during a rain storm. The city that the film takes place in (which is never named specifically) is presented as foreboding, run-down, crime-infested, hopeless. There is an intense, obsessive focus on the mysteries of the killer and there is very little room for anything resembling joy or optimism. The cinematography revels in gray. The music is industrial, soulless (it totally makes sense that Fincher would team up with Trent Reznor later on). I think if you're open to the idea of a film that is drab on purpose, to make a point, than Se7en is going to be a riveting experience for you, even if its shocking conclusion isn't actually a shock.
That's not to say that it couldn't have been better if I had been blown away by that ending. But I do think that the film surrounding it served its purpose well. And really, when you think about it, the contents of the box are a means to an end. It's more that the box serves to finally break Detective Mills, and acts as a self-fulfilling prophecy for Somerset, in that this city will fucking break you, just as it does Mills. That it's implied that Somerset cancels his retirement and keeps working should be its own sort-of-win—he has found that he does care... and yet he chooses to remain in a situation that will inevitably crush him again.
I find myself returning to the films on this list and films like it for the same reasons, despite the occasionally unfavorable circumstances. I knew what was in the box, and that fucking sucks, but still, here I am, ready for whatever experience they can throw at me, open to feeling the joy and the pain in equal measures, ready to discover new mysteries beyond that, some even more terrible. We open the box because we must know what's inside. No matter that there are those who know and who are uncomfortable with the knowledge and who feel the need to share that knowledge despite the disappointment it will bring to others, to be spoiled. There's a balance between knowing and not knowing. I didn't find that balance in Se7en. But I found something else, and that's okay.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
That's not to say that it couldn't have been better if I had been blown away by that ending. But I do think that the film surrounding it served its purpose well. And really, when you think about it, the contents of the box are a means to an end. It's more that the box serves to finally break Detective Mills, and acts as a self-fulfilling prophecy for Somerset, in that this city will fucking break you, just as it does Mills. That it's implied that Somerset cancels his retirement and keeps working should be its own sort-of-win—he has found that he does care... and yet he chooses to remain in a situation that will inevitably crush him again.
I find myself returning to the films on this list and films like it for the same reasons, despite the occasionally unfavorable circumstances. I knew what was in the box, and that fucking sucks, but still, here I am, ready for whatever experience they can throw at me, open to feeling the joy and the pain in equal measures, ready to discover new mysteries beyond that, some even more terrible. We open the box because we must know what's inside. No matter that there are those who know and who are uncomfortable with the knowledge and who feel the need to share that knowledge despite the disappointment it will bring to others, to be spoiled. There's a balance between knowing and not knowing. I didn't find that balance in Se7en. But I found something else, and that's okay.
GRADE: 3.5 pukes out of 5
Stray Thoughts:
- This is my sixth Fincher film, though it's been a really long time for a couple of them (I saw Benjamin Button in theaters! It was okay!). I think I understand the "aesthetic," though this was his second film, and the aesthetic was just being established. Dark and gritty and pessimistic, that kind of thing? I like it.
- I've seen Fight Club plenty of times but there probably should be a space on this blog to discuss it, so why not here? The movie is kinda overrated, no? A bit like the movie poster syndrome discussed last time?
- I guess Paltrow's character is a bit underserved here, but ya know, maybe that's the point, that she's this sort of beacon of optimism for her husband and even for her husband's pessimistic veteran partner. It was certainly enough to make Mills' pain at losing her to make more than enough sense.
- Sucks that Kevin Spacey was the actor who (surprise, again) plays the killer. But that's how it goes. My views on viewing visual art that involves "cancelled" participants is by necessity different than my views regarding music, but you probably don't want to hear that. Meet me in the comments if you do, though.
- There's something to be said about police in entertainment like this, how TV and movies by and large portray cops as the good guys, and in real life, they are rarely so. I thought the discussion between Somerset and Mills about how many times they've shot a gun was interesting, though, both in the context of the movie (how pulling the trigger is an emergency-only thing, and we're damn gonna see some emergencies at the climax of this fucker) and in the ACAB discussion (how pulling the trigger is often glorified in blue-line culture, and how fucked up that is). There's something to be said but I won't say any more because that's annoying.
- Part of Tommy's elementary school description of the gluttony scene was that you literally saw the killer kick the victim's stomach open. Wow, he was exaggerating. You don't say? The same seventh grader who was claiming that he drank breast milk when he got to second base?
NEXT TIME: There's been four Halloweens in a row when Pam hates that I couldn't watch The Shining, due to alphabetical reasons, but no worries, it's finally here! Just in time for the Fourth of July!!

No comments:
Post a Comment