See the rest of the exit surveys HERE.
1. Were you happy with the reviews that were published? How do you feel about your week as Record Club captain?
Pleased as punch. Weird album, weird band (singular, even, though more on that later). Yo, can you believe the fuckin' Oilers?
2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?
Joe and I both tangled with the idea of contextualizing BIG|BRAVE into whatever their genre is, and I was refreshed to have someone else rumble with that. Zach and Sunny both locked into the more naturalistic aspects of the album, which is also what I like about it. This thing is sort of like a noisy ocean crashing on the tide, and I felt that connect to the organic world in both their reviews, which was sweet.
Dude, the Oilers! I'm not a hockey-knower by any stretch of the imagination. I can maybe, MAYBE name five guys in the league and that is heavily dependent on some old-ass guys still being out there playing. But I think I know when something cool is happening, and something cool is definitely happening up in Edmonton.
3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?
No, I don't think so. If I had to rank the reviewers based on who I perceived to like the album most to least, I'd probably go Me, Zach, Sunny, and then Joe.
I saw a stat on the screen just now, maybe two minutes before the Oilers (THE OILERS!) went up 3-0 on the Panthers to end the second period, that teams that go up 3-0 in postseason have something like a 402-6 record. The Panthers were up 3-0! The Oilers looked cooked! They pulled the ol' "call an ambulance / but not for me" on 'em! I love it.
4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?
No, but I will say people locked in on the French shit more than I expected. That could be as much a symptom of the band being hard to talk about / weird to brush up against as anything else.
When they hung eight on the Panthers in Game 4, that would have been a fine showing of face-saving. Game 5 is when shit got tense. I only caught the third period because I was traveling for work, and I watched most of it on the back of a JetBlue seat. And, again, I don't know fuck-all about hockey and can count on one hand how many games I've watched this season. But when the Oilers were protecting a 4-3 lead in the third with six minutes left and the Panthers pulled their goalie, I was as locked in and invested as I have ever been for a game in any arena. And not only did they hang on, the hung another one in the empty net! THE OILERS!
5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?
I probably wouldn't pick it again. THE OILERS! God, what if they win tonight? By the time you read this we'll either be heading to Game 7 back in Florida on Sunday or we'll be talking about the brave but flawed Edmonton heroes. Warm-weather areas shouldn't have hockey. It's an affront to god. The sun is still out in Edmonton right now, figuratively and literally. Hockey rocks.
6. Any other takeaways from the reviews? Or from this experience in general?
Joe tips all his pitches, you just have to keep up with the lore.
7.
What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance
everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?
Club field trip to Edmonton to drink out of Lord Stanley's cup.
T
TH
THE
THE O
THE OI
THE OIL
THE OILE
THE OILER
THE OILERS!!!!!
THE OILER
THE OILE
THE OIL
THE OI
THE O
THE
TH
T

4 comments:
I am tickled by the thought of:
- Joe taking Nate's suggestion for improving RC seriously
- Joe organizing tickets for me, Sunny, Nate, and him to go to Edmonton, possibly securing a group rate
- Joe making the requisite connections necessary to allow us to get up close and personal with Lord Stanley's Cup
- Me, Joe, Sunny, Nate traveling together
- Relevant children and wives agreeing to this utterly inane boys trip
- Shaking hands with Connor McDavid
- Drinking milk out of the Cup
I will meet y'all halfway with a live chat if there is interest (though Zach might be asleep).
I plan to wake up at 5am to watch the 3rd period and am in if this live chat happens.
Tonight (tomorrow morning), we will all drink the milk of victory in honor of the mighty Oilers! Or, we will find comfort in the milk of longing in the shadow of the vile and putrid Panthers.
Post a Comment