Thursday, June 20, 2024

The A.S.S. Creative Writing Lab: Prompt #25

This is a weekly space for creative writing. Please check out the landing page if you're interested in what we've written already, or if you yourself are interested in writing creatively. Feel free to comment below (according to the request feedback level) with any comments or suggestions!


Prompt:


Author: Nate

Requested feedback: ???

~~~~~~~~~~~~

In the far future
If the wall don't get knocked down
they'll know about Kurt

2 comments:

Joe K said...

Here is the requested feedback.

First of all, thanks a lot for doing this, man! I always appreciate when you reach out and offer your creative writing services, especially when the writing is as long and as detailed as this. Much like a man standing at the bottom of a mountain cannot help but turn his head skyward and marvel at what god hath made, so too do I stand at the base of the blogging path, looking up, and wondering what it might feel like at the peak.

Let's take it line-by-line here.

First, there's "In the far future," which, man, holds so much power and mystery in its brevity, packed in dense like a black hole. The far future. I definitely spend a lot of my time wondering about this. It’s not an inevitability, ya know? It's like, yo, are we even going to have ACCESIBLE WATER in the far future? The thought haunts me.

Will there be a moment in time from now until the edge of eternity in which I will look out of the rumbling subway car and not see the Kurt Vile mural? Jeez louise. This is where the second line comes in: "If the wall don't get knocked down." That "if" holds a lot of water here, and the load is heavy, friends. It's like that moment before the fireworks go off—combustion soon, but for now, energy at rest, one spark igniting. I really appreciate the purposefully incorrect sense of grammatical person with the verb. "Don't" instead of "doesn't." It's more succinct in one-syllable form; it was the correct choice. So right in its wrongness. More punchy.

And then, of course, the third line of "they'll know about Kurt." This is the most haunting proposition of all. That there could be a world without Philadelphia's premiere slacker-rock musician. Worse still, that this wall is the only thing keeping that haunting alternate universe at bay. You can feel the tension here, in this line. You can feel the tension in every sense, including that of the metatextual, how someone really did paint over this mural one time, and how much of a travesty and tragedy that felt like then, and now, even after its restoration.

The poem leaves a lingering question just hanging there, over the stratosphere, like the blade of the guillotine, all glinty and sharp: would the world remember Kurt Vile if they don't have local Philly murals to remind us? Might not his deep and perfectly imperfect discography conduct similar electrical waves in its absence? Or could the man / the myth simply cease to exist in the snap of a finger? These are questions I cannot answer, but I appreciate that the poem you made here at least dares to ask the questions in the first place.

Taken all together, I'd be so bold as to say that this poem is a masterpiece of the highest order. It has everything—thrills, nuance, bold philosophy, stark realism, a command of the language, palpable danger, a dark trip into the madness of the human mind, and maybe, just maybe, the key to the locked box that contains the answers to everything.

I want to thank you for the work you've done today, for arduous task that you've completed here, on this day, which will forever live in my mind. I am humbled by this poem's publication, and I continue to stare upward, toward this mountain’s peak, continuing to wonder, and never regret a single thing.

In conclusion: fuck you.

Zach said...

This comment made me LOL multiple times. Favorite lines:

"Much like a man standing at the bottom of a mountain cannot help but turn his head skyward and marvel at what god hath made"

"it was the correct choice. So right in its wrongness."

"all glinty and sharp"

In an alternate universe, Nate's poem is the featured poem in a writer's conference; it headlines his new buzzy book of poetry that no one can shut up about. It is lapped up by the critics. He basks in his unanticipated fame, he mysteriously refuses all interview requests; he is like Banksy in his image. He must change his name and eventually go into witness protection. This all makes perfect sense to the general public.