Saturday, June 22, 2024

RECORD CLUB PRESENTS: Kailyn's Dozen, Week #5 of 12: Avenged Sevenfold by Avenged Sevenfold


I know I shouldn't be totally surprised that I like this album. I'm moving through someone's Favorite Albums of All Time list; it would be weird if there was a significant number of stinkers on there. Like, that's not how it works! Still, when I first received this list straight from Kailyn's keyboard onto my screen, my initial thought really was "oh shit, this list is terrible." That's the mark of a cynical pretentious asshole, though. I'm trying not to be that way anymore. I'm trying to look to Kailyn and allow her to be something of a guiding light for me. I assume that I'm going to like a band called Avenged Sevenfold, but then I listen to their 2007 self-titled album and am surprised to learn that this is pretty good! Not great, but leagues better than what I assumed it would be. I'd be lying if I said I wasn't shocked.

If you had asked me, I would said that Avenged Sevenfold is probably a dumb nü-metal band, right? And I guess it's not not that, but it's also a lot more. This band is way more versatile than I would have thought. There are plenty of nü-metal moments, and lots of vocal inflections and slippery drum patterns to make the uninformed believe that that's all there is. But I hear a lot more here too. I hear a lot more classic metal than nü-metal, maybe something like Iron Maiden. I hear some in-your-face politically informed lyrics here, akin to System of a Down for sure, like that whole spoken-word bridge about blood on children's hands in the very first song, "Critically Acclaim." I hear... I don't even know what this reminds me of, but that autotune section in "Lost" is pretty sweet and not as embarrassing as it sounds on paper. I hear My Chemical Romance, honestly, especially their more theatrical side circa The Black Parade.

I especially hear that sound in the penultimate song, "A Little Piece of Heaven," which is an eight-minute song that sounds like the heavy-metal version of The Wall, absolutely ripe for the stage. It was written by the drummer, who died shortly thereafter, adding to the myth. The video is even a homemade cartoon movie! This is the kinda shit I would have never expected from Avenged Sevenfold. Same with the final song, "Dear God," which I swear is practically nü-country, maybe something like Appalachian Nickelback, or just straight-up late-stage Aerosmith, with a goddamn fucking banjo in the mix. I cannot say that I loved it, but god fucking damn it do I respect it.

"Versatility" is the word that Bob used when I asked him about Avenged Sevenfold (and that I stole from him for a previous paragraph above). I didn't tell him why I asked him, because explaining that I'm writing about a stranger's Best Albums list would've been too distracting. I look to Bob to keep me grounded when it comes to music. I get way too highfalutin sometimes when I'm writing about this shit, and I need a certified "average listener" to keep me straight. I need my brother-in-law to tell me that yes of course he knows Avenged Sevenfold, one of their songs was on a hockey video game that he used to play back in the day. A quick check of the Song Challenge archives show no A7X tunes, which is surprising.

I don't know why I didn't think of this earlier. I spend way too much time crammed in front of this computer, imagining my own world in all its pathetic fiction, and pretending that I can look at someone's music list and pretend to know who they are, even though I don't know the person and I don't really know much of her music, at least not by name. It makes so much sense to ask someone who actually likes this music what they think. Someone like Bob would have his finger on Kailyn's pulse way more accurately than I would. I'm over here being fucking blindsided by Avenge Sevenfold sounding nothing like Slipknot, and I'm getting distracted from the task at hand. What does A7X say about Kailyn, the figment of my imagination?

Honestly, it feels like Avenged Sevenfold is Kailyn's musical tastes in miniature. The sounds of the first six albums we've heard from her list can all be found here... some (metal) way more than others (I guess "Dear God" could be loosely connected to Blake Shelton, barely, but enough that my point stands). If we're making one definitive statement at this juncture, then it's this: Kailyn cannot be tied down to petty childish bullshit like genre. She's gonna listen to what she wants to listen to; she's gonna love what she loves. If I never learn a single other thing about her other than this, it will have been worth it, because it's so goddamn fascinating, to try to feel a love for nü-metal and alt-rap-rock and fake-emo and pop-country in back-to-back-to-back-to-back weeks. I don't understand it, but the mystery continues to keep my engine running.

What's preferable, though, I think, is that there is some sense of self-curiosity. Why do I like the things that I like? I think it's an important question to ask oneself throughout the course of one's journey through music. I understand that this isn't something that people typically indulge in. I've tried talking to average listener Bob about this, and a lot of the time it amounts to "I used to listen to it in a particular context in my youth" or "because it sounds good." Which is totally fine, and what most people would say. I just personally feel like there needs to be more.

Clearly I obsess over the answers to the question for myself, as I've constructed an entire blog-sized excuse to explore it. But I wonder which kind of person Kailyn is. I wonder if she ever did what I'm doing for her in this space, if she's ever sat down and asked herself what her favorite albums say about her. Chances are that she is in the vast majority of Americans and would never, ever even think to ask herself the question in the first place. And I fear that, without knowing her or ever speaking to her again, I'll never get the answers I want.

GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

A PICTURE FROM KAILYN'S OLD INSTAGRAM THAT BEST ENCAPSULATES THE EXPERIENCE OF LISTENING TO THIS ALBUM:



THE FULL LIST, IN ORDER OF COVERAGE:
  • Hybrid Theory by Linkin Park
  • Masterpiece Theatre by Mariana Trench
  • Don't You Fake It by Red Jumpsuit Apparatus
  • Meteora by Linkin Park
  • Red River Blue by Blake Shelton
  • Boys Like Girls by BOYS LIKE GIRLS
  • Steal This Album! by System of a Down
  • Avenged Sevenfold by Avenged Sevenfold
  • American Tragedy by Hollywood Undead
  • Stadium Arcadium by Red Hot Chili Peppers
  • Relapse by Eminem
  • Strummin' On Garth by Brooks Jefferson
  • You Get What You Give by Zac Brown Band
  • Stand Up and Scream by Asking Alexandria
  • Me and My Gang by Rascal Flatts

No comments: