This is Joe K***, roving reporter for the K*** Family Newsletter, Vol. XXXIII, Issue 32. The biggest news to report this week is that grandma has decide to join us, and while this reporter is slightly reluctant to report it, the news is the news—it's very difficult to listen to music while someone is talking over the music about anything and everything.
While the Record Club crew huddled in the North Wildwood rental house kitchen attempted to listen to the opening salvo of "In Fate's Hands," we were treated to a story about how the day that she was gifted her first food processor was the same day as the MOVE bombing. The hard-hitting chorus of "Damn Regret" was overpowered somehow by a running list of everything that grandma cannot reach in her own kitchen without a step stool. And the blast-from-the-past tones of "Face Down" were...
Okay, this is actually pretty good. So grandma listened to "Face Down." Good song. I remember it from alt-rock radio back in the day. But you'll never guess who grandma said what band "Face Down" sounded like. Never in a million fucking years.
Train.
I said, "You mean, the band Train?" She says, "Yeah." I said, "Like, Train, like, you mean, the band who sang 'Hey Soul Sister'?" She confirmed.
Incredible. It's moments like these that made me glad I became a music journalist. This opinion is wrong, but it is also fresh. It doesn't make any sense, and yet, the more I sat with that opinion this week, the more I became convinced that grandma was onto something.
Not in tone, for sure. But I think there's something to be said about both bands being equal amounts derivative? Train for being the most banal vanilla adult contemporary folk rock band of all time, and the Red Jumpsuit Apparatus for being, hmmm, perhaps a double-digit-place runner-up in the race of top-tier post-hardcore-inflected third-wave emo?
I heard some of the same shades and hues that I heard in My Chemical Romance's music. But that's probably just because that's my own personal touchstone as far as third-wave emo goes. I'll admit that my credentials in this field are weak. I played that to my advantage while listening to Red Jumpsuit Apparatus. Derivative? Absolutely. But who gives a fuck? What the fuck do I know? I heard a rough, slightly-screamy, and somewhat hooky teenage angst sound that is right up my current alley, and I liked it.
It's especially nice being like six beers deep and listening to it. There's an argument that I'll like anything you put in front of me after six beers. Maybe you could say that Red Jumpsuit Apparatus was no exception, and that I'm overrating it because of that. So be it. What, you want me to be sober in Wildwood, NJ? Have you ever fucking been here?
I am happy to report that there were no repeats of last year's Slipknot debacle. My dad listened to Don't You Fake It, and had no subsequent judgments about my parenting style. In fact, I'd even say that off-color remarks from older family members are at an all-time low this week. That's probably half because I'm not drinking as much (yo, I was fucking loaded when I wrote all that Slipknot stuff last year), and half because my family is tired of my "wokeness" and have collectively decided—consciously or unconsciously—to stop saying hateful bullshit around me to just save everyone the trouble. (Grandma has dropped a few racist nuggets on me, but that's pretty par for the course, unfortunately. She spends too much time on Facebook.)
The worst take my dad had about this album was completely inoffensive, and mostly due to his lack of understanding about any music that isn't played on XPN (the fact that he listens to XPN should be commended, by the way, since that means he actually does listen to and enjoy modern music, as opposed to following many of his peers off a fucking cliff with classic rock radio, but, like, c'mon, XPN is still pretty safe and would absolutely never touch Red Jumpsuit Apparatus with a ten-foot pole).
His take was to ask me the next day if "this was the album of the week" when I was listening to Relient K, a Christian pop punk band from the early '00s. Dudes with guitars playing music that you've never heard before? Understandable mix-up. And I really only bring it up due to journalistic obligations—did you know that Red Jumpsuit Apparatus have branded themselves as "Christian rock" since shortly after the release of Don't You Fake It? I have no idea if that should color one's opinion of their only "non-Christian rock" album in either direction, but it's interesting nonetheless. Like, what does Red Jumpsuit Apparatus say about god? I have no idea. I am the least qualified person on earth to discuss it.
I guess I'm slightly more qualified to talk about the grounded and intense themes found within "Face Down," the only song in the entire discography that Red Jumpsuit Apparatus could call a "hit" and not get laughed out of the room. Good song. Maybe that's because it was recognizable. Then again, it's not the best song on the album—"Damn Regret" is fucking great, and I'd never come anywhere close to hearing it prior to this week—so maybe that's not true. But, I don't know, the lived-in experiences with domestic violence stand out because of their raw honesty. I'm not saying that the theme was presented in some nuanced way, but maybe the subject doesn't necessarily need nuance. Maybe you just need to be presented with clear, plain, understandable, relatable emotions when it comes to domestic violence. So RJA did a good job with that.
Like I said at the beginning, music listening time was limited this week, so I'm sorry that this review comes off as slightly uninformed. It's true, I did not have the space to really experience this album like I would normally. But perhaps that is ultimately a good thing. Maybe this album works better as an ironically dark soundtrack to a sunny and warm week. But I know that this is the most subjective fucking thing in the world. I know that I'm going to read some negative reviews this week, and I can understand why. But I am also 100 miles away from all that negativity. I can see it in the distance, and I'll give it a wave, but then it's back to the beach, back to optimism, and back to the best generic third-wave emo album I've ever heard.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment