~~~~~~~~~~~~
1. Was there anyone who convinced you to consider a different opinion regarding the album itself?
Not of the album, but Sunny coming to bat for Ohio as (checks notes) an underrated exporter of culture? Has Sunny ever been to Ohio? Has he seen the "Hell Is Real" billboard with his own eyes? Has he eaten Skyline Chili five ways? Flummoxing stuff.
2. Was there anyone who you felt did a good/bad job at presenting their own views, regardless of whether you agreed with said views?
I don't walk away with a clear picture of what Zach was trying to say about this album, but I enjoyed the hell out of how he expressed whatever his feelings were about the music (if I had to guess, it would be something along the lines of "it's fine."). I'm pleased Kai found so much to love in the record, and would like to encourage them to continue to travel down the lonely road of Bandcamp, as there is a world of interesting—and even quite good!—stuff that never makes it to major streaming platforms. Joe does well to mark the line between "I am impressed by / I appreciate this" and "Ifuckinglovethishit," between analytics and emotion and how they need to cross (or not) to become beloved. I do find it curious that Pam and I both used this album as a platform to talk about other shit, which is what I argue is the strength of the album in the first place. I would never buy a hermit crab, let alone two.
3. Were the reviews varied, or did this album elicit same-y opinions? What about that album made that true? Or do you think that this answer is reviewer-dependent and not album-dependent?
I don't know that I could have picked an album that would be easier to zone out to and say "that was okay," so the fact that anyone got more than a passive experience out of it is a minor miracle. Something that Zach (I think) and Joe pointed out—that I think it true, too—is that this feels small scale and workman by design. That's the beauty of it, I'd argue, but that's what also makes it easy to overlook. Especially since you really have to go find this shit.
4. Did the variety of reviews justify the album choice? Would you choose a different album (yes/no) based on the reviews received?
5. What can Record Club do differently to make your RC experience (especially as a weekly captain) a worthwhile one?
Ranked voting after all reviews come in so each week a champion of reviews can be named.
6. Any other takeaways you have from this experience?
I expected the Perennial review, but I did not expect the re-pivot back to long odds. Bit of a euro-step there from Joey Blogsalot. Game recognize game.

1 comment:
I could go for a skyline 4 way rn
Post a Comment