Saturday, August 20, 2022

A Year of Blind Spots: At Fillmore East


I've always thought it a little strange when a band's "best album" is a live album. Not that I can think of too many examples off the top of my head, maybe just KISS (Alive!) and Peter Frampton (Frampton Comes Alive!). It just feels like an indictment on the band, that they weren't talented enough to translate their music in the studio, where the quote unquote "real" art is made. It certainly has played into the fact that I tend to avoid listening to KISS and Frampton when I can. If I'm being honest, it's probably played a part in me not getting into the Allman Brothers before now as well. At Fillmore East, a live album, is generally considered their best.

Well, that, and the fact that I've always known them to be a "southern rock" band. Not that I dislike southern rock, per se, but "Ramblin' Man" sucks ass, and even though that song came out two years and two band members deaths after At Fillmore East, I still made assumptions. Different blind spot, but the same ol' story, ain't it?

The funny part is that, if I were listing the genres I found on At Fillmore East in order of prominence, then "southern rock" would be at least fourth, if not lower, coming in behind blues, jam band, and maybe psychedelic. They seem to have more in common with Grateful Dead than they do Lynyrd Skynyrd. Don't get me wrong, if you take a step back, you can see some of the southern influences, but they definitely take a backseat in this insane live show.

I guess another weird thing about listening to live albums to fill a blind spot is that this will ruin my experience listening to the original studio versions of the songs, ya know? It's a legitimate concern! Then again, at this point, do I need to hear the studio album version of "Whipping Post"? By all accounts, this 23-minute live version is the definitive take. So maybe I don't need anything else. I don't know.

I also probably won't be able to tell you if this is a "good live album" or whatever. The sound is as great as it could possibly be for a live album, as far as I can tell. Nothing is muddled. I mean, it sure seems like they took great pains to have this sound like a purposeful, legitimate recording, and not like a bootleg. The professionalism shows.
 
Is Duane Allman a good guitar player? Again, as far as I can tell! He sure does play a lot of guitar on this thing. Christgau accused the guitar playing on this album as "not really going anywhere" in his review back in the day, but shit, man, that's not anything I would have the capacity to judge. Sometimes the songs go on for so long that I kind of lose interest, sure, but then something else in the recording pulls me back in. If it's too long, then that's the point—it's long! The Allman Brothers sweated it out on stage! They gave you their all! It really is electrifying in its best moments.

But this will probably be an exception, not a rule. Yes, the Allman Brothers created a pretty great work of art here with this live album. But typically, a live album is not a good place to start. Because where does it go from here? By their own admission, the Allman Brothers studio albums lacked the heat to make an impact, and that's why they put effort into their live album. But so then what, am I supposed to go out and grab a copy of an Allman Brother studio album now? It doesn't make sense.

Sometimes music doesn't have to make sense. I know. I get it. I'm just writing out of my ass. I'm gonna stop now and listen to a few more hours of this not-southern rock band tear up this legendary concert venue.




No comments: