There's a chance I'm running this subject into the ground on the blog. What is this, the fifth or sixth time I have to bring up the fact that my favorite baseball team willingly and purposefully employed a known domestic abuser this season? I understand that "what baseball team Joe is rooting for" is, on a ranked list of things the typical PoYB reader cares about, in a numbered position with at least six digits. Maybe this update would've worked better as a comment on a previous blog post; maybe I'm just trying to fill a little space before I head down the shore.
Or maybe this really is a subject that has been a true emotional pox on my psyche this year. Mixing sports and morality is always a dicey proposition, and yet the Phillies organization has forced my hand in the matter. I've made my voice as clear and concise as possible (okay, probably not "concise," but definitely clear). If a baseball team is going to give millions of dollars to a known and unrepentant domestic abuser, then I'm not going to support that baseball team. I've drawn the line, and I'm comfortable with where I stand in regards to that line.
But I'm also flying blind, because I've never really had to stop watching baseball due to a reason like this, ya know? I'm trying to do the right thing, but it's been made clear throughout the entirety of my life that I often don't know what "the right thing" even entails. So please excuse me as I try to untangle it all, publicly on the blog.
The MLB trade deadline was last week, and I guess the Phillies picked up enough spare parts that they finally felt comfortable jettisoning the two known and unrepentant domestic abusers on their staff, including the dude whose name I don't have to mention at this point. Over a 24-hour period after these two players were DFA'd, I received no less than FIVE texts from friends and family who all wanted to know the same thing: So am I finally going to be watching the Phillies this year?
It kind of caught me off guard, I'm not going to lie. Mostly because I didn't expect the Phillies to finally get rid of these creeps at all this season, so I hadn't even thought about what I'd do if they did. When I did finally give it thought in response to the big news, I had trouble processing how I was feeling without seeming judgmental toward anyone who wanted to know.
I honestly have not held any judgment in my heart for anyone who is still watching the Phillies this year, by the way. We all have to draw our own lines, and if we start inspecting other people's lines, then things start to get pretty icky. In the same way that I cannot judge anyone for dancing to a Michael Jackson song on a wedding dance floor, I cannot judge anyone for rooting for the boys in red pinstripes. As I've stated, I have a very tenuous grasp of what "the right thing" even is, and to assume that I do know, and that others should follow my lead, would easily turn into me having some pious, holier-than-thou attitude that I similarly despise. So I'm not gonna do it.
But I also have to be honest with myself, and be true to my emotions, both those in the moment and those that arise after some reflection. And thinking about the prospect of rooting for a Phillies team that suddenly doesn't currently employ any known domestic abusers seems... still kind of off to me. I feel really uncomfortable with the idea of it, to be honest.
Took me a couple days to really pull that feeling apart, but here is what I came up with. I forwent the Phillies this year because they knowingly rehired someone who beat the shit out of his girlfriend and never repented in any tangible way. "They" meaning the Phillies as an organization, including anyone in that organization who holds the power to make those kinds of decisions. It's less about the player who made the despicable decision to violently attack his significant other and the cowardly decision to not make amends for it, and more about the baseball team that decided that this was all okay and that the domestic violence didn't really matter at the end of the day, since there was a figurative hole in center field and it was just easy to fill that hole with a dude who beat a female bloody.
So with that distinction made, I don't know why the decision, in August, four months into the season, to cut O. H. changes a single fucking thing, right? The Phillies hired him because they needed his baseball skills, they fired him because they no longer needed his baseball skills. Where does his off-field crimes factor into any of their decisions? Where does the VICTIM OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE factor into any of their decisions? Answer: it doesn't. It never fucking has.
In that regard, I feel extremely uncomfortable with the idea that I'd all of a sudden start tuning into the Phillies games. Because nothing has changed. NOTHING.
If you need a timeline, let's say that maybe I'll ease my way into it at the start of the 2023 season? Assuming that, I don't know, O. H. is not resigned (which I thought literally impossible before 2022, and yet here we are), or any despicable men of similar stature aren't hired (shit, man, imagine being a Browns fan right now).
The bottom line, though, is that I still feel pretty burned about the whole situation. After supporting a baseball organization emotionally and spiritually and financially for well over a decade, it was really tough to swallow the realization that our outlooks on life were so violently opposed. I don't know if I'll ever get over that. I do miss Phillies baseball, and like I said, if things get better from here, then I'll cautiously start to get back into it next year. But I don't think I'll ever be able to fully get over it.
One final note: I try to mitigate some of the "me me me!" that naturally comes about in writing such a blog post as this, and as always, I will attempt that act of narcissism mitigation by putting my money where my mouth is. I'm donating $100 right now to Philadelphia's Women Against Abuse (which runs the local domestic abuse hotline, among other services). And I'll encourage anyone reading this to donate what they can, if they can. Along those same lines, there is a chance that I'll be going to Citizens Bank Park for one single baseball game this September, since my Blue Jays are going to be in town (and they can all make the trip, since, unlike the Phillies, they are all vaccinated); if that happens, I'll be right back here, and I will match every single dollar I spend that night at CBP in another donation to WAA.

No comments:
Post a Comment