Friday, August 19, 2022

Don't You Fake It, Ryan


My only experience with Red Jumpsuit Apparatus before this week came as a result of the cultural phenomenon that dominated the 2000s, RuneScape. RuneScape was an online game that was free-to-play, did not require a download, and its limited polygon count meant you could play it off a toaster if you had to. This made it the perfect creative outlet for the poor and dispossessed of our society: ten-to-seventeen-year-old children.

This manifested itself in many powerful ways, but today we are talking about Red Jumpsuit Apparatus. You see, at the time, if you were to draw a Venn diagram of the RuneScape demographic and the pop-punk/emo demographic, it would look like a single darkly colored circle. Masterpieces like this one poured out regularly as the internet achieved its first golden age.

This is what became known as a RuneScape Music Video, or more commonly an RSMV. "Face Down" was made into a bona fide classic in the scene along with "The Diary of Jane" by Breaking Benjamin and the entire Linkin Park discography. Like how NOFX and Bad Religion had Skate Videos, My Chemical Romance and Five Finger Death Punch had RSMVs. There was a cresting wave of emotion coming over America, and now that the tide's receded, I'm a little confused.

Listening to this album took me back to this simpler time, and made me wonder just how that cultural moment came to be. In 2006, at the time of this album's release, the pop-punk market was already palpably oversaturated. Even as a child, it felt like the radio was absolutely soggy with music that, in all honesty, leaves a lot to be desired. The songwriting is typically pretty uninspired and sonically they tended to be rather flat. The standout quality is undoubtedly the dramatic subject matter and emotional delivery of the lyrics, which is another curiosity all on its own. I can't remember if I realized "Face Down" was about domestic violence at the time. I was about eleven or twelve when I first got into it, and I always paid close attention to the lyrics when I listen to music, so I am sure I must have known it on some level, but I doubt I had any real conception of what the scenes it describes actually looked like or the impact of what they meant. 

More interestingly, looking back as an adult now, I am not sure the young songwriters in the band really knew what it was that they were singing about either. I think all that mattered was that it was emotionally provocative, serious, and intense. It was also eminently successful, and not just among the RSMV creators. Albums like Don't You Fake It, and many like it, struck a real chord in suburban America. Why was this? Why did their popularity fade? Did something change?

Looking around, I don't think so much has changed in middle-class America. Kids still seem starved for excitement and importance and emotions always hit harder for teenagers. On the contrary, I think the vein that albums like Don't You Fake It tapped into is still undiminished. Looking around the contemporary music scene, it looks to me like the emo-style lyrics are actually probably more popular than ever before. But instead of hearing them in a shmorgishborg pile of hardcore sub-genres like in the 2000s, we hear them now in genres like hip hop and country. These genres have both taken pretty hard swings away from the tough exterior of their past, and, notably, these are the two genres that this brand of rock had been in competition with back in 2006. 

As is the way of many things, it seems the popular parts live on and the parts that honestly were kind of hard to listen to have died away.

No comments: