Friday, August 5, 2022

Mirrorland, Nate


It is not fair to say that EARTHGANG fall victim to the same self-indulgence that hinders Chance the Rapper, that keeps many (your friend included) at arms length from Kendrick Lamar. It is fair to say that EARTHGANG stay hewed close enough to these dual-influences to make it difficult to enjoy Mirrorland on its own merits in a limited listening window, whatever those merits might be.

Here is something that happens in rap songs a fair amount now: the song begins, the rapping happens, and about 90 seconds in the engine drops out and the stuff that was building momentum is supplanted for some other, less dynamic shit. It happens on "LaLa Challenge," when a chicken order upends what was a completely serviceable cover of "Juice." Same shit on "Blue Moon." This feels like Travis Scott's fault, but a lot of shit feels like it rests on that dude's shoulders.

EARTHGANG is from Atlanta, and at least someone in the crew has an ear to the Dungeon Family. As much as Mirrorland feels like a nu-Chicago product, there are enough flourishes of ATLiens and Soul Food to give the pantomime color, if not personality. There's a line between elevation and feeling too good for the form. EARTHGANG is confident on which side of the line they sit, at least.

No comments: