I was forced to try to explain this short, temporary blog project out loud this week. The idea of me listening to Blake Shelton of my own volition was just too far-fetched for Pam to believe. And so I walked her through the process, making sure to underline the fact that I know this is dumb and that that's part of the bit, I guess. How we got here, the SparkNotes version, for those who missed it last week: Kailyn was PoYB's in-house artist based on a cat drawing she made for me, but then she went off the grid, and now I'm sitting here wondering who she really was this whole time. And I'm tracking that thought process with her self-proclaimed favorite music, one album per week.
The big point here, which I made to Pam and which I'll make to you now, is that this is an exercise in trying to learn about a person through their music. Usually I'm working from the opposite direction, right? I have a friend, and I ask them what their favorite music is, and they tell me, and I learn something new about that friend that perhaps readjusts slightly my overall picture of who they are. But with Kailyn, I know close to nothing about her. The hypothesis then stands as: Can you know a completely stranger based on their favorite music alone? That's what I'm trying to determine, for the next eleven Saturdays at least.
Kailyn is such an interesting case study because her list of Favorite Albums of All Time is sort of all over the place. I listened to Linkin Park last week and I made assumptions about a human being whom I'll never meet, but now I'm listening to Blake Shelton, and this shit is nothing like Linkin Park, but they are both adored by the same person! So now where do we stand in making those assumptions? How can someone be defined by music if the music that defines them is so dissimilar?
I think this exercise will be the most interesting when my assumptions look like excuses. If someone told me that one of their favorite albums of all time was an album by Blake Shelton, I would assume that this someone was extremely lame at best and vaguely racist at worst. This is a bad album. Very bad. I knew it would be, but that doesn't excuse me from trying to use it as a function of knowing a stranger. But if I'm trying to use Red River Blue as a way to know Kailyn, I'm forced to say things like: "Well, I know that 'Good Ol' Boys' has conservative undertones, and 'Hey' is a bit homophobic, but I'm SURE that Kailyn didn't like this album because of those songs, she liked it despite those songs." We'll never know what's true, but it's tough for me to try to make up facts about a stranger if I'm not going to be assuming the best about them.
The worst songs quote Larry the Cable guy and indulge in substance abuse tropes. The best songs, though, are pretty innocuous and silly examples of boilerplate country-pop radio tunes. I think Kailyn probably leans on the latter, and excuses herself from the former. I think that she fell in love with this album because it really is calming in its best moments. It's nice to think about life through the lens of your typical pop-country song's protagonist: life is easy, everyone is nice to each other, let's get dee-runk, America is beautiful and free, etc. I get it. It's easy to like if you don't think about it.
And it's easy to not think about it if the not-thinking is combined with some circumstantial nostalgia. Maybe one of her parents indulged in country, or maybe her friends all liked music like this because it was fun to hang out with those friend and drink in parking lots, something like that. What it definitely betrays, though, especially if we're assuming that Kailyn does NOT partake in the more sinister stuff lying beneath the surface here, is that Kailyn isn't really all that into music, or at the very least not into thinking about music beyond the "this sounds good to me so it must be good" basicness that your average listener stops at.
That's sort of the opposite of where I land with Blake Shelton and Red River Blue. I pretty much hate this album as a collective statement of music, but I love thinking about it and its existence. In fact, this isn't even the first time I've considered a piece of this art here on the blog. Back in 2019, as I was lying on the beach (or more accurately sitting underneath a now-contraband canopy holding a baby) and I heard Blake Shelton's "Honey Bee" for the first time, and thought it was just about the dumbest goddamn thing I'd ever heard. And I used the song to make what I thought was a pretty fun and silly blog post.
It didn't really have anything to do with "Honey Bee," beyond the fact that I thought it sucked, but here I am, still listening to the song, since it's the first tune on Red River Blue. And I'll tell you something else—it's a bad song, but due to the context of my knowing it, I actually have some fond feelings for it. Especially because I remember ever single time that Pam has ever complimented me while enjoying a blog post that I wrote, and this was one of those times. She said "that was a good one" and her words burned into me forever, as compliments usually do in my attention-starved perpetually-adolescent male brain.
I suppose that's something we should consider here, in the case of Kailyn and her love for this album. We should consider how easy it is for someone's kind words to persuade you into thinking about the world different. This could just be a matter of someone whom Kailyn deeply cared about saying something nice about Blake Shelton's Red River Blue, and that compliment really making an impression on her, and maybe even growing in time, glowing warmer and warmer within her to the point that she's going around telling internet strangers that it's tied for her favorite album ever. Maybe, like Shelton's now-ex-wife Miranda Lambert in the video intro to "God Gave Me to You," this album is a part of Kailyn's story, regardless of what happens or happened afterward.
What did happen to Kailyn? We'll probably never know. But in the meantime, we can try to know her a little better through the one thing that I know to be true and fair in this life: music.
GRADE: 1.5 pukes out of 5
A PICTURE FROM KAILYN'S OLD INSTAGRAM THAT BEST ENCAPSULATES THE EXPERIENCE OF LISTENING TO THIS ALBUM:
AND HERE'S ONE FOR METEORA, SINCE I ONLY THOUGHT OF THIS IDEA AFTER I PUBLISHED THE WRITE-UP FOR THAT ONE:
THE FULL LIST, IN ORDER OF COVERAGE:
It didn't really have anything to do with "Honey Bee," beyond the fact that I thought it sucked, but here I am, still listening to the song, since it's the first tune on Red River Blue. And I'll tell you something else—it's a bad song, but due to the context of my knowing it, I actually have some fond feelings for it. Especially because I remember ever single time that Pam has ever complimented me while enjoying a blog post that I wrote, and this was one of those times. She said "that was a good one" and her words burned into me forever, as compliments usually do in my attention-starved perpetually-adolescent male brain.
I suppose that's something we should consider here, in the case of Kailyn and her love for this album. We should consider how easy it is for someone's kind words to persuade you into thinking about the world different. This could just be a matter of someone whom Kailyn deeply cared about saying something nice about Blake Shelton's Red River Blue, and that compliment really making an impression on her, and maybe even growing in time, glowing warmer and warmer within her to the point that she's going around telling internet strangers that it's tied for her favorite album ever. Maybe, like Shelton's now-ex-wife Miranda Lambert in the video intro to "God Gave Me to You," this album is a part of Kailyn's story, regardless of what happens or happened afterward.
What did happen to Kailyn? We'll probably never know. But in the meantime, we can try to know her a little better through the one thing that I know to be true and fair in this life: music.
GRADE: 1.5 pukes out of 5
A PICTURE FROM KAILYN'S OLD INSTAGRAM THAT BEST ENCAPSULATES THE EXPERIENCE OF LISTENING TO THIS ALBUM:
AND HERE'S ONE FOR METEORA, SINCE I ONLY THOUGHT OF THIS IDEA AFTER I PUBLISHED THE WRITE-UP FOR THAT ONE:
THE FULL LIST, IN ORDER OF COVERAGE:
- Hybrid Theory by Linkin Park
- Masterpiece Theatre by Mariana Trench
- Don't You Fake It by Red Jumpsuit Apparatus
- Meteora by Linkin Park
- Red River Blue by Blake Shelton
- Boys Like Girls by Boys Like Girls
- Steal This Album by System of a Down
- Avenged Sevenfold by Avenged Sevenfold
- American Tragedy by Hollywood Undead
- Stadium Arcadium by Red Hot Chili Peppers
- Relapse by Eminem
- Strummin' On Garth by Brooks Jefferson
- You Get What You Give by Zac Brown Band
- Stand Up and Scream by Asking Alexandria
- Me and My Gang by Rascal Flatts



No comments:
Post a Comment