Friday, June 28, 2024

RC@5: Lumos by Harry and the Potters

Record Club covered this album exactly five years ago. I gave it another listen this week. Here are some thoughts. Nate's thoughts included this week as well!


Lumos
Harry and the Potters
Week 21: June 23-29, 2019

Nate

The most charitable thing that can be mustered up about Lumos—now five years removed from being five years removed from catching a cultural wave—is that the band stands as an example of the whims of the muse. Here are some cats who really threw their shoulders behind an idea well past its sell-by date, and did so with aplomb, pathos, and craft. It's not to be recommended, but it demands to be admired.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Joe

Okay. Let me say this first. This column is not designed to be in-depth. I already went deep into the album the first time around, exactly five years ago today. I don't need to do it again. If there really is THAT much to talk about, then that means I didn't do my job the first time around. Which wouldn't be completely unheard of, but I don't want to make a habit of typing 2000 words for RC@5. I have a finite number of hours in the week to blog. This is supposed to be a bit tossed-off. This is supposed to just act as a "hey, remember this?" exercise. That's all. I like that I get to revisit music that meant a lot to me a half-decade ago.

The complication here is that Harry Potter's legacy has been upended a bit since June 2019, and if this really is a follow-up, then I'm forced to talk about it. Even though Lumos the album is at least one step removed from that controversy, and even though we are here to talk about Harry and the Potters and not Harry Potter. The nature of this album's existence ties the two together irrevocably, and so you can see why I have to do this.

Here is where we are at in 2024: the beloved children's book series' author is intensely bigoted toward trans and nonbinary people. Explicitly. She is extremely vocal about her hateful beliefs. She hedges nothing when speaking on the subject, and she speaks on it very often, without apology. Rowling is, as far as I can surmise, the most famous transphobe on the planet.

My thoughts regarding music in this particular context are well-documented on this blog. As succinctly as possible: if the musical artist is abusive or outspokenly bigoted, then I believe it is my responsibility to not engage with that artist's art, past or present. That doesn't apply here, since the members of the band Harry and the Potters are not, as far as I know, infamously transphobic. They made an album based on the work of an author who is a reprehensible person, but they are fans just like you or me, and this album was made before any of that came to light.

I will also say here that I don't believe that my theory about personal moral responsibility with music also applies to other media. Movies and TV shows and books are more complicated. I don't think it's a matter of it being easier to make excuses for other forms of art. I do think it's a matter of how seriously I take music, though, and how much I ascribe the power of each album to the artist who made it. I participate in the exercise of listening to music by emotionally bonding myself to it, and that means the author is a necessary factor in that, and thus, the author being an abusive piece of shit is going to affect my bond to that art. Whereas I see film as something to engage with a bit more distance, emotionally speaking. I think... I'm still parsing through my thoughts here. But I know I feel differently about film, and I know that this is the fault of my love of music, and not the fault of loving movies less.

With books...  I mean, I can't say that anyone besides Rowling is responsible for creating the Harry Potter world that I know and love. But I do think that the phrase "kill the author" was made for books for a reason, and I do think that it's possible to read a book, knowing full well that the author is a monster, and still be responsible for your morals and personal beliefs. It would be so different, and so much easier, if the idea of hate won the day in the Harry Potter narrative, but it doesn't. Love is the whole point, love for your fellow human, which is why it's so fucking perplexing that Rowling is dying on the hill she chose to die on. It seems to contradict the point of the story that she created.

I don't blame anyone for bailing on their love of Harry Potter due to this, especially our friends in the LGBTQ community who grew up loving this book series and only after the fact discovered that its author wants them dead. Just like with music, I don't think it's appropriate to judge someone for choosing to engage with Harry Potter regardless; that doesn't change just because I'm reluctantly on the other side of the issue with this one. I think this issue is a personal choice for everyone. Can you kill the author? Do you have it within you to do it?

I don't know. I really don't know. I don't know how I'll feel if I ever read this series again (especially with my kids), and I don't know if the endeavor will be worth it. I don't know if its message, the one that resonated so strongly with me as a teenager, will ring hollow now, or if it will still soar in spite of its author. I don't know.

What I do know is that Lumos is still worth engaging with, despite ALL this bullshit. If anything, it might be the only safe way to engage with this narrative now. There are no concerns about supporting a bigoted monster by listening to a band churn out some goofy-ass songs about a fictional character. I gotta assume that Rowling hates these fucking guys, and fucking hates the federal parody law that protects them. So let's all listen to Lumos.

That is, if you can stand it, which, ya know, based on the reviews at the time and in the years since, not many people besides me can. Was a 4.5-puke grade an overrate on my part? Absolutely! But not by much!! I'd stick with 4 pukes if given the option to re-grade. I think that this is a touching and very catchy tribute to an already affecting story. The songs manage to examine some nuance that not even Rowling felt like doing, and it hits on some real emotional moments that are really only possible through music. Yes, some of the musical parodies are goofy (what's worse, the Townsend swipe or the Weezer swipe?), but you cannot deny these hooks. You cannot deny the emotional pathos of, like, the chick from Moldy Peaches crying out for Ron, or the narrator wondering out loud about non-Death Eater Runcorn's role in Voldemort's rise, or fans lining up to thank Harry Potter for his sacrifice (and Harry Potter for its presence).

There was always a price of admission for this album, but in the years since, that price has only risen. Damn transphobic billionaires causing inflation! I think I am still willing to pay the price, though. As long as that money doesn't go directly to Rowling. Listening to Lumos and rehashing this album as an act of nostalgic music criticism means that my Galleons and Sickles are safe from terrible people.

No comments: