I can assure you that I know how to have a good time. Listening to an absolutely terrible album and feeling every negative emotion under the sun during its runtime does not negate that fact. In fact, sometimes it can be even more fun when I get to write about those negative emotions. It's fun because it's easy. It's so much easier to tear something down then built it up. In the context of Record Club, even when the rare awful album of the week hits your Sunday morning email, there's still the paradoxical joy of getting the opportunity to write about it that saves me from packing this whole fucking thing up in a suitcase and skipping town. So this first point I'm making—that this is me, having fun—is a self-protective measure. I hate CANDIACE's Deep Space—absolutely fucking despise it—but it gives me discomfort that someone could read this forthcoming review of said album and assume that I am the type of person who doesn't know how to be happy. The problem is not me. The problem is that some rich asshole decided to force a vanity project into our world, and now we have to deal with that reality. It brings me no pleasure to sit down and listen to the album. It brings me great pleasure that I have the opportunity to say something about it. This is me, having fun. Come join me in talking shit on this disgusting testament to the idea that money will buy you anything you want, even the alchemy of turning anti-talent into more money. FUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
There is no mystery here. That's where we usually start with this type of thing, right? The mystery of why something is as bad as it so obviously is. The knee-jerk reaction is that I just don't get it. That the problem is me. It's me, hi, etc. I find that it's so easy to say something like that because it's a really great way to cushion the blow. What "blow"? How about the crushing reality that something as vacuous and useless as Deep Space actually exists? It hurts too much to think about this idea that I've built up in my head—the idea that music is our world's one true pure gift, the one thing in this world that always heals, no matter what—is mocked and proven false by some fucking prick with a bank account, and so I usually shy away from that pain, and take the easy way out, and say something like: whelp, I guess I just don't get it. Whomp whomp. See you again next week. Etc.
Not this week, though. I know exactly what is going on here. And because the artist in question is a celebrity of sorts, and the act of attempting to eviscerate her quote-unquote "art" would undeniably be an act of punching up, I have no qualms in making it clear in this specific instance that I am not wrong. The only people who are wrong are those who defend the existence of Deep Space. If you are one of those people this week, then I'm sorry to report the following: you are wrong, and may god have mercy on your soul.
There is no denying this fact, because Candiace Dillard Bassett makes it extremely clear, through her very existence on a television reality program, why she does what she does. It's for attention. That's all it is. She makes it very clear, starting the album with various clips of people talking about her. The things these anonymous figures say about Candiace are pretty negative. There's value in being able to live with your critics and let their toxicity fade away, I guess, but that's not what this is. This is an attention seeker proving that she has the attention she desires.
Far be it from me to decide to what and to whom people should give their attention. This isn't me talking shit on anyone who watches any of the Real Housewives shows. If you choose to devote your attention to these monuments to bottom-rung society's twin goddesses, cravenness and hollowness, then you do you. I understand that there is a certain appeal to these shows, a sort of alluring voyeurism to the whole production. Look, I'm just coming out of a two-year master's program whose main point seems to ultimately boil down to: listen to people first, and only then can you help them. I get the listening part.
But the problem is when you are seeking attention for the sake of it, and not because you are actually worthy of the attention. That has to come first, then the attention would be warranted. What exactly is the reason we are supposed to be paying attention to these women (and their senior citizen husbands) in the first place? From what I can tell, it's a snake-eating-its-own-tale situation: they are famous because they are on this show, and they are on this show because they are seeking attention, and they are seeking attention because they desire to be famous. There's no substance here. It's all hot air. I'm not even saying that everyone who is famous needs to make tangible contributions to society, but the housewives of this reality show program seem to me to be at the far end of the spectrum. They are reaping the benefits of attention-seekers without doing a single fucking thing to warrant that attention besides, I dunno, provide entertainment for those who enjoy attention seekers?
The purpose of me talking about all this in the context of an album review is that the album, Deep Space, is itself just a tool for this superficial nothing of a celebrity to seek more attention. It is completely devoid of value as a work of art. There is no quality to speak of. There is nothing that the worst Spotify-algorithm-powered artificial intelligence couldn't have come up with on its own. The emotive notes are a clear and flimsy façade. This isn't art meant to exist on its own; it's a means to an end. That end is more money, more fame, more name-brand recognition, and it all honestly makes me fucking sick to my stomach.
I mean, fuck, man, being a reality TV star has to be more interesting than CANDIACE makes it seem on this album, right? I'll cop to the fact that being a Real Housewife©™ must be a unique experience that the vast majority of humans in history will not experience for themselves. And so but why doesn't this album speak to any of those unique experiences? Besides the cacophonous interludes, which are a cheat and don't apply to this argument, the album is awash with generic clichés about love and loss, using the same lyrics you've heard on a thousand R&B/pop albums before, some in this very Record Club. CANDIACE has a unique perspective, as an Obama aide turned pageant queen turned reality show star named Candiace, but literally none of that comes out on Deep Space. What a fucking waste of an opportunity to salvage this fucking garbage can of an album.
We've listened to plenty of atrocious music in the past 218 weeks. Think about Surfaces. Remember them? Two fuckbois from Texas decide to make dubiously facsimiled TikTok-algorithm pop album, and they go crash and boom and flame out and leave our lives forever, hopefully. But the one good thing I can say about those fucking morons is that at least their intentions were pure. They sucked shit and their music sounded like sewage, but they made Horizons because they wanted to make art. That was their intention. That they failed spectacularly doesn't diminish the fact that they gave it an honest try.
Ask yourself honestly this question: What was the intention of CANDIACE in creating Deep Space? I can't imagine anyone being so willfully ignorant of how this whole thing operates that they could pretend CANDIACE made Deep Space out of any desire to create art. Her intentions are so obviously impure, in a way that we honestly haven't come across yet here in Record Club (I'll hear arguments about Former Child Actor, but I'll ultimately dismiss them as something different—intentions of creating art are no less pure if the creator is utterly delusional).
It's fucking insulting, is what it is. It's so fucking disrespectful to the idea of music as art, and I hate Candiace for that. This isn't art, this is a fucking weapon, designed to bludgeon its listener until the desired attention is obtained. It kills me that I'm wasting thousands of words on this calculated disaster when I could be pumping up the word count elsewhere, on music that actually means something to somebody. Because this is exactly what people like Candiace Dillard Bassett want. I know it. I'm aware. I'm just another fucking talking head, with a bunch of negative shit to say, only to find that my intentionally critical words are being packaged into soundbites to be used at the beginning of the next album that this martyr-complexed maniac releases.
I just don't understand how anyone could possibly deign to defend this avarice and this narcissism. It's not right, man. It's not right. There's a way to get me agitated and still be artful. This isn't it.
I'm also thinking about the fact that there's probably a way to make something specifically designed as an attention-seeking tool, but for it to still be pleasant to listen to. It would piss me off still, mostly, but at least I could point to certain songs on that hypothetical album and say "Well, it was made for the wrong reasons, but at least it's fun, I guess." There's nothing like that on Deep Space either! I'll admit it, R&B isn't typically my cup of tea. We've covered our fair share of R&B in RC, and each time, I'm careful to point out that there is still value there on that album, even though I personally can't connect to those sounds associated with that genre.
What I'm saying is that a song doesn't necessarily need to say something meaningful for it to be a good song, and conversely, I'm also saying that a bad song can be redeemed if there is some intended or even inferred meaning behind it. I think that "On Bended Knee" by Boyz II Men is a pretty terrible song, but if you think about these dudes coming up from the streets of Philly, and entering their imperial phase on the back of a genuine love song, with some pretty sweet harmonies, then you can find redemption in that terrible song. And then you think about something like Sisqó's "Thong Song," which is one of the best and catchiest songs of the past forty years, and yet says nothing of substance, unless you count horndog slobbering as "substance," which I do not.
I'm not asking for good songs that mean something. I'm just asking for one of those two qualities. Deep Space fails to deliver either throughout its entire runtime. Name one fucking song that hits even one of these targets. Can't be done! "Drive Back" I guess comes closest to being a song worthy of release as a single, but its lyrics are so elementary that to rhyme with "dairy air," CANDIACE stoops to tacking on a "yeah!" to "out the door." Do "out the door, yeah" and "dairy air" rhyme? The fact that I even have to ask the question should tell you the answer. So, like, okay, that means it's catchy, right? No. This is the sound of every single asshole trying to go viral on TikTok. I'm honestly surprised that ChatGPT didn't get a writing credit. Imagine trying to compare "Drive Back" with the majesty of "Thong Song." Neither of these songs have anything to say, but yo, imagine CANDIACE creating music that practically demands pyrotechnic-enhanced kung-fu booty theatrics. Fuck out of here.
Sigh... okay, here's another thing. I'm trying not to look a gift horse in the mouth. I was handed an opportunity to take a week off from Record Club, to consume Deep Space like I would a single stale Ritz cracker, and have some fun writing some words about it, and then forgetting about it forever. But I'm looking in that horse's mouth. I can't help it. Here's what I found stuck in the cavities like so many carrots and hay: a need to acknowledge that Candiace by all accounts is a strong and successful black woman who worked hard to make her own way.
I feel the compulsion to point this out because the context of intersectionality of race and gender as it pertains to success in society is important, generally. I've usually felt some sort of responsibility to couch my criticisms in this context, as a way of acknowledging my own privilege. Say I wanted to be an aide in the White House like Candiace was during the Obama Administration. It's a fact that I would have to work half as hard as she did to get there. Same thing if I wanted to make an R&B album, probably. I'm obviously not saying this to brag or to be funny or whatever, I'm saying it because it's true. Racism and sexism are alive and well in 2023 America.
So in situations like this, I usually feel pretty uncomfortable making my sincere and art-related criticisms known (or at the very least, I refrain from shouting them from the rooftops) because that feels, to a certain extent, like punching down from my perch of privilege. I don't know if I'm making sense. Let's talk about an example real quick.
Okay, so RuPaul's Drag Race. This current season is probably the sixth season I've watched overall (including All-Stars), and I've by and large hated most of the music-related activities that they get into on the show. I'm talking about music selections for the Lip Sync for Your Life, and I'm talking about RuPaul's original songs that double as both the basis of Maxi Challenges and advertisements for her brand, and I'm talking about any time any of the queens have to write their own lyrics.
But so what? The music is terrible, but what purpose would criticizing it serve? Luxx Noir London said it best just last week—she's had to work twice as hard to get where she wants to be in this life, because she's black and she's gay. So what if the personality she portrays on TV is incredible toxic and has truly grinded me down these past fourteen weeks to the point where I can't stand it any time I see her on screen? So what if the four bars of original lyrics that she "sang" last week, lyrics and singing that were explicitly praised by the judges, were 30 seconds of some of the worst, most fucking embarrassing music I've ever heard in my miserable 34 years on earth?
So what? I'm here to be an ally, and if that means supporting my least favorite drag queen as she performs her art in this free democracy we call America, then I'll fucking do it. Fuck any asshole who thinks differently. Whether you're a white supremacist threatening to bomb a Drag Queen Story Time, or you're sitting at home silently tut-tutting the idea of a man dressed in women's clothes and lip-syncing to Doja Cat, then I say this: FUCK YOU.
I don't feel the same way about CANDIACE, and that's because I believe that the realities of money and fame supersede any need for allyship. Whether Candiace Dillard was born with privilege or without it due to her race and gender is besides the point here, because of the money and the fame and then intentions of this album. There sure is a lot of noise on Deep Space, and a lot of it sounds lush and expensive. When you try to listen for anything about subjects besides the ostensible trappings of being famous and hot, then all you'll hear is a deafening silence.
I guess what I'm saying here is that, a lot of the time, my emotional and/or political support can be counted on automatically, but that this is an important exception. There are plenty of reasons why we as a society should feel obligated to support art from members of communities that have historically been met with injustice and inequity. To quote Candiace on the interlude "I'm Gone": "That... that is not the same! It's not the same!"
It's all washed away because Candiace Dillard Bassett has chosen to prostitute herself to the world of reality television, where "real" means "scripted," and everything is done in the name of hanging onto that bag for as long as the Bravoheads will allow. There's nothing sincere here, and I'm so why should I even try? I have no responsibility to this at all. Deep Space exists as the antithesis to everything I value in this world. It exists to mock me and everything I hold closely. Why should I give a shit about Deep Space?
The only thing I'll stop short in doing is claiming that CANDIACE is self-aware about how harmful her brand and her "music" are to me and to the idea of art in general. I sincerely don't know. I don't want to call her malicious, because she might just be obtuse. To be ignorant, or to be so blinded by your own image that you can't see anyone else, does not necessarily make one innocent, per se. But it does soften the blow of the pain she inflicts. It's quite possible that she got caught up in this great big machine that overpowers even the best and the brightest of us, and she wouldn't be able to escape even if she wanted to. Maybe there are malicious actors behind the scenes, profiting off her brand too, motivated to keep the game from stopping for as long as possible. Maybe, just maybe, she genuinely does not see the harm she imposes in releasing this shitstain of an album into the universe. It's unlikely, but it's possible, and I'll give her the benefit of the doubt on that one.
I seriously have no clue, though, whether the Real Housewives©™ are self-aware about how silly and profane they look under the bright lights of the reality TV cameras. Are they in on the joke? I'll admit, I only watched 40 minutes of one episode of Real Housewives of the Potomac this week, and so I don't know enough to make a decision one way or the other. The episode we watched had a section featuring Candiace and her husband, Chris, meeting with the fertility specialist to discuss freezing some of Candiace's eggs for future pregnancy plans (I'm not making this up: they agreed that she cannot get pregnant now because she is too busy working on her album!!). But so one of Candiace's concerns, besides the intricacies of creating such a critical and creative masterpiece such as Deep Space, was that Chris's work schedule was erratic. To show-not-tell what Chris's job was, they edited in a quick Instagram clip of him making some food in his chef garb. But guess what food he was making? That's right: eggs. He was making an omelette. During a conversation about Candiace's eggs.
I'm inclined to think that this blink-and-you-miss-it joke was intentional, and not coincidence. Right? Isn't this dude supposed to be a world-class chef? And he can't visit the fertility clinic regularly with his celebrity wife because he's too busy making omelettes? Are you fucking kidding me? It's almost too unbelievable to assume that this is anything but a joke that everyone is in on. Which is good, I'd argue, for the sake of the television show. It's helpful to know that at least the show itself is self-aware. The Housewives on that show? Jury's still out. There were a bunch of women talking about how one of the Housewives was "exhibiting attention-seeking behavior on her Instagram," which is one of the most imperceptive and self-righteous things I've ever heard uttered on television, given the circumstances.
But if you step back for a second, then ultimately I don't think it really matters if CANDIACE is in on the joke of Deep Space or not, or whether she is innocent or not, or whether she is being malicious or just oblivious. Either she's so self-absorbed that she thinks using her money and fame to shoulder her way into making the most generic album of music in the history of music was a good idea (so good of an idea that a DELUXE VERSION was necessary), or she knows that ultimately this is a vain attempt at attention-seeking but released it anyway because she hates music listeners and subconsciously wants to punish us for ever giving any of these clowns the time of day. Either way, it's a bad album, it shouldn't exist under any circumstance, and CANDIACE was in the wrong for releasing it (and let me stress again: she released it not once, but twice).
Stepping back even further: I get the joke for Record Club, and it's a good one. What if the music/writing club that takes music very, very seriously was forced to grapple with an album from an artist who doesn't take what we love seriously at all? Sure, I get it. I'm having fun, sitting here, typing away, getting myself worked up, trying to drop the worst burns my feeble untrained mind is capable of. I get it! There's room to laugh here! I hope you, the person reading this now, found time to listen to this fucking fuck of an album and you laughed when you read the reviews and you found your catharsis in some small way on this fucking blog. It's all fun and games, but listen up:
When it comes to music, I'd prefer not to fuck around. This is some serious shit. I like music so much in part because it opens a world into someone's soul, which can be an intimate experience. Even when the music sucks, when it comes from an honest place, it's a worthwhile endeavor to listen. This is the sacred rule that CANDIACE has violated today. I don't think I've ever had the displeasure of interacting with a more dishonest piece of "art" in my entire life. I'm not exaggerating when I saw I'm deeply insulted to my very core. To use music as some vacuous way to further your brand and grab attention from more deserving (or: actual) musicians in an already crowded room is just plain fucking wrong, man.
I get that this is how the world operates, and I get that I'm in the minority here, in my own little reality where I'm pretending that I'm the only enlightened one who can see these Housewives for what they truly are. Forget all that. Focus on CANDIACE, and her album Deep Space. What is the purpose of its existence? You know the answer to that. And then ask yourself: Does its existence jive with what you consider important about music?
I asked myself that question one thousand times this week, and the answer every time was: No. This isn't why we listen to music. This is the opposite of why I listen to music. I hated every minute of it, because every minute that it was in my ears, I could hear CANDIACE trying to tell me that I am wrong, that music isn't art, that it's just a way for people to display their narcissism. And I could hear her accuse me of being the same. That I'm a narcissist too, for hating her so much, and for feeling the need to write 4000 words about it.
NO. I'm not fucking do that this week. I'm not doing the whole "Maybe I'm the one who's wrong?" thing. Life is too short, and music is too precious. Deep Space doesn't deserve any excuses. I know exactly what CANDIACE meant to do here, and you do too. What she does on Deep Space is simply unforgivable. ARE WE HAVING FUN YET?!?!
GRADE: 0 pukes out of 5

No comments:
Post a Comment