Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #12 and is featured on pages 99-104.
"Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds"
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
1967
At this point, we're taking the psychedelia at face value. Yes, there are some vividly nonsensical lyrics set to some trippy music. "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" is not that far removed from "I Am the Walrus" in this way. It actually might up the weirdo factor. The lyrics explicitly draw your attention to the colors and shapes ("Picture yourself in a boat on a river..."), and the instrumentation replaces the orchestra with a big drippy bass line and a Hammond organ and a fucking sitar. If you're thinking "Beatles drug song," then "Lucy" is the one you're reaching for, not "Walrus."
And so it makes sense that the big "aha!" moment experienced by Beatles fans in the summer of 1967 was that "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" has the same initials as the psychedelic drug LSD. This is like Beatles 101-level trivia here in 2023, but in 1967, this was some galactically impactful shit: the Beatles are singing about drugs!!!
Except, you know the story. As claimed by John Lennon until the day he was murdered and even in a Playboy interview from beyond the grave, "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" was taken from a picture that Lennon's son Julian (the ostensible subject of "Hey Jude") drew at school, literally featuring his school friend Lucy up in the sky with diamonds surrounding her. Okay, alright, fine.
When I was in high school, and I listened to Sgt. Pepper's for the first time, and I started to immerse myself in Beatles lore, this was always something that stood out to me as questionable. Repeating the same mistakes as the generation before me, I started to think, "But what if it's actually about LSD?" Despite the mountains of evidence—as compiled dutifully by Snopes—the doubts still linger to this day. Look, if anyone is going to keep a running gag a secret and perpetuate it for over a decade, then it's John Lennon. I don't think it's unreasonable to believe that Lennon knew that the title was named that way because of LSD, and he decided that it would be pretty funny to consistently lie to everyone on earth for the rest of his life.
I mean, the truth isn't even that far away from it. Lennon and McCartney are both on record in saying that many of their songs from this era were inspired by drug use, including "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds." We're not arguing about that aspect to it. We're just arguing about the titular phrase, and whether it is directly or indirectly inspired by the psychedelic drug. It's not that big of a lie. Either this LSD song was named after LSD, or it was named after a child's drawing that happened to have the same initials as LSD. I abide by Occam's razor, and the former seems more realistic to me. The latter is such a weird coincidence that Lennon committing himself to a lie seems like the more reasonable option.
The authors argue that LSD is kind of besides the point when it comes to the lyrics and the song in general, stating that tens of thousands of people have tripped on acid, but only one person was ever crazy/genius enough to come up with such a crazy/genius song like "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds." I tend to agree with them there. I remember thinking that I was a better writer when I was drunk. I've grown to see the folly in that belief. There's a way to free your mind enough to get the words out without any help from stimulants or depressors or hallucinogens, it just takes practice. Drinking just makes your brain tired. I can imagine it's the same thing with acid. It's not like Lennon (with help from McCartney) sat down and ingested a tab and then wrote all the lyrics to this song. These were minds that knew what it meant to feel that way but weren't currently feeling that way artificially. The words are supposed to hint at that feeling, not speak directly from it.
I guess what I'm trying to say is that any radio station manager who refused to play this song in '67 was a fucking moron.
BEATLES TRIVIA: Elton John took a cover of this song to #1 on the Billboard charts, which is kinda crazy. Not that his version sucks—it's fine—but I can't imagine there was a time when cover versions of songs regularly became hits. This book alleges that John Lennon himself played rhythm guitar on Elton's version, and also came up with the idea for the reggae breakdown. That's one of the first sincerely new pieces of trivia I learned on this Beatles trip, so thanks, book. And I think this speaks toward my theory that John Lennon was a committed trickster. If he can secretly play guitar on a cover of his own song, then I don't know why anyone would doubt that he could secretly name a song after LSD and keep it to himself forever.
BETTER BEATLE: I quite like this song, but it's a little too "fanciful-psych" for me, if that makes sense. It lacks the punch of many of John's and Paul's other trips into the unknown. Not to say that Ringo doesn't do his best here to punch it up a bit with those bass drum blasts. Let's honor Ringo and say that the preceding song, "With a Little Help from My Friends," is better.
NEXT TIME: "Nowhere Man" at #13
No comments:
Post a Comment