Wednesday, April 5, 2023

Phony Beatlemania: "I Am the Walrus"

Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #11 and is featured on pages 93-98.


"I Am the Walrus"
Magical Mystery Tour
1967

Let's actually start with another song today. "God" by John Lennon on his first solo effort post-Beatles, John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band. It came up on shuffle a few weeks ago, and hit a lot harder than it would have if I wasn't trying to immerse myself in Beatles lore for this project. The first half of the sparse piano-based song is Lennon listing all the things he doesn't believe in, some more pointed than others—tearing down idols like Elvis and Bob Dylan, making backhanded insults at former bandmates ("I don't believe in I Ching" is a direct reference to the last song we covered, "While My Guitar Gently Weeps"), and then most infamously declaring that "I don't believe in Beatles," which, wow, still hits pretty hard all these decades later.

Anyways, the seconds half of the song is an affirmation of simplicity—he is none of these things, he's just John Lennon. He is his own person (well, his own and also Yoko's). But he drops this line to make this fact clear: "I was the Walrus, but now I'm John." If "God" is Lennon tearing down the façade and presenting the Real Me, then it's a tacit admission that calling himself "the Walrus" was a bunch of fucking fake phony bullshit. Which makes sense, because the lyrics in "I Am the Walrus" are nonsense, right? But then so what do we make of the great and ostensibly eleventh-best Beatles song now? How can we possibly take it seriously, now that John Lennon has so thoroughly dismissed its fallaciousness? 

For once, the authors of our official Beatles tome admit that the lyrics are poppycock. There's a whole page devoted to the idea that one might possibly try to find meaning in the lyrics, but that you'll find countless dead-ends and red herrings. There is a vividness to the various psychedelic imagery, but ultimately, it's just—as Lennon himself described it—a "dream," and dreams don't have to make much sense.

My kneejerk reaction, of course, is to argue with the authors, even though for once they are taking my side that Beatles lyrics are a lot more nonsensical than those wacky Beatlemaniacs would argue. I can't help it! I have deep-seeded contrarian tendencies. So I do have an argument, but it's not against the idea that the lyrics don't make sense. They don't, not on a figurative level, and certainly not on a literal level. It's a LSD-fueled word salad. But my argument is that maybe good songs don't have to make sense, and THAT'S the point. The point is the lack of a point. It feels like the authors are trying to say that "I Am the Walrus" is a good song despite the fact that it's gibberish, but I'm more inclined to say that "I Am the Walrus" is a good song because it's gibberish.

So then if it's gibberish, then what's the point? Either there's purpose or there's not. Lennon could have easily written a song like this just to see if he could get away with it, or maybe because he knew he would get away with it, and people would still buy the record and future authors would still rank the song #11 on their own personal lists. That seems possible.

Or it could be that the gibberish is designed to make you feel something anyway. The gibberish is of course combined with some seriously thrilling orchestral work, and some deeply ominous King Lear background recordings, and some haunted chanting, and some slyly excellent vocal work by Lennon (agreed with the authors on that point—pronunciation is on fucking point here), and so all that helps. But the gibberish is suppose to make you feel something on a gut level. Like, I wouldn't be able to tell you what a whale is trying to say when they make noise, but that monstrous guttural underwater roar is gonna make me feel something if I ever got close enough. "I Am the Walrus" is like the call of a whale. I can feel it without understanding it.

I don't typically practice what I'm preaching here, I know that. But I'm working on it. I'm working on following my heart instead of my brain when it comes to these types of songs. Had I not tried, then I would've ended up underrating "I Am the Walrus," which doesn't feel right. It's a great song.

But I also wonder now if it doesn't make me like John Lennon a little less than I have before, because while it does end up being a great gut-punch of a song, it is also pretty clear that Lennon is bullshitting his way through it, or at least being impish about creating a hit out of bullshit parts. Like, this is the equivalent of the honors-track kid accidentally placed in remedial math—he's too smart for this, and so he decides to be an asshole about it and fuck around all day and get the easy A. Or, like, imagine that Paul McCartney really had recorded "Yesterday" with the original lyrics of "Scrambled Eggs." It still would have been a hit, because the melody could not fail if it tried, and also it's the fucking Beatles, but then it would have been like "What, Paul is just fucking around, right?" So here's Lennon, master of his craft, fucking around, succeeding anyway. Doesn't affect how I feel about the music, which is impeccable, but it definitely affects how I feel about the artist.
 
It's hard to take John Lennon seriously even if I wanted to, honestly. I mean, c'mon, you don't believe in the Beatles?! "God" is a great song because it's shocking, but when you take a step back and really think about what Lennon is actually saying here, then it starts to feel like he's just being a child lashing out at mommy and daddy. Which... I guess what the point of that whole primal scream therapy, but we don't have to go in that direction just yet. My point here is that a sane and self-aware person would acknowledge that, despite things ending poorly for the Beatles members at the end of their run, the Beatles as an idea is an inarguable positive for our world and everyone in it, including those four Beatles members, whom we would not be talking about on this blog or on any blog were it not for the popular and landscape-altering rock band that they were members of.

Lennon might not believe in Beatles, but I do. Lennon might dismiss the idea of the Walrus being something more than its song's lyrics suggest, but I certainly do not. John Lennon might not want to be the Walrus, but that doesn't mean we can't have the Walrus for ourselves. "I am he as you are he as you are me and we are all together"—it doesn't make sense at first, but eventually it does.

BEATLES TRIVIA: Marianne Faithfull, for some weird reason, always gets dragged up in conversations about the "meaning" behind some of the lyrics of "I Am the Walrus." Apparently she had this theory that the line "Semolina pilchard" is a reference to some crooked cop (redundant) in '60s Great Britain named Detective Sergeant Norman Pilcher who made a habit of arresting rock stars on drug charges, including Lennon himself. Look, she's wrong, because Lennon did not write this nonsense line in reference to some asshole cop. But she's also right, in that you, the listener, are allowed to impart your own meaning into any lyric you so choose. And if Marianne Faithfull wants to hear a stupid two-word line about fish paste and use it to reflect on how police abuse their power, then more power to her. I do think she's missing the larger point about "I Am the Walrus," though.

BETTER BEATLE: "Glass Onion," which we'll eventually get to at #56, makes a reference to "I Am the Walrus," and I think it's a better song because of its self-referential nature. In "I Am the Walrus," you don't know whether to take Lennon seriously, and in "God," Lennon is begging you to take him seriously. But in "Glass Onion," Lennon doesn't say either way, but the wink and the smirk are evident, and I appreciate it. But we'll get there eventually.

NEXT TIME: "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" at #12.

No comments: