Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #10 and is featured on pages 87-92.
"While My Guitar Gently Weeps"
The White Album
1968
Alright, are you familiar with the term "slotting"? Have I talked about it here on the blog before? Probably. The basic premise is that there is a ranked list, and ostensibly that list is a ranking from best to worst, and yet the creator of the list "slots" certain items onto that list in order to create a certain narrative. So something that is ranked #10 on that list might not actually be the tenth best item on that list, depending on what the author (or authors) were trying to say with that list.
This isn't a PoYB-original thing. I heard the term at some point in the mid-'10s, and, having been the type of person who "slots," it totally tracked, and I've remembered the term ever since. And I was thinking about this term and this idea as I read about what the authors of this Beatles book in question considered their tenth best Beatles song of all time. "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" is a really good song, but you have to consider the strong possibility that this song is in this particular position due to slotting.
Put yourself in Spignesi's and Lewis' shoes. You are tasked with writing about your Top 100 Beatles Songs. You are sculpting the Top Ten. You figure out the Top Nine easy. Now it's time for #10. And you realize that every single song in your Top Nine are Lennon and/or McCartney tracks. You're crafting a narrative that the Beatles are the best band of all time, and yet a Top Ten filled with songs written exclusively by only half the band threatens to upend the narrative. And so you look desperately around for a song to round out that Top Ten that, while not being actually worthy of the Top Ten, still speaks to the general point you are trying to make. In other words: what is the best George Harrison-penned Beatles tune, and can anyone come up with a good enough reason why it shouldn't be #10?
This isn't a complaint. I totally understand that you're trying to sell a fucking book here. Doesn't make sense to talk Beatles if you're not willing to give a well-rounded picture, and a Top Ten without George Harrison is not well-rounded. Actually, for the first time, I thought to look up alternate Beatles Top Songs lists, and found one from Rolling Stone. Funnily enough, "While My Guitar" was #10 on that list. However, #6 is "Something," which is also Harrison. We won't get to our second Harrison song on this list until #14 with "Here Comes the Sun." All three are great songs. I sincerely don't know if any of them are Top Ten-worthy.
I'm not making a case against Harrison here, by the way. You know me better than that. The third-man in the Beatles is absolutely going to be the type of underdog I'd be rooting for, don't worry. If we're talking Beatles solo albums, then All Things Must Pass is pretty much a lock for the top position, no slotting required. The narrative is just too juicy to ignore—the dude who was constantly overshadowed finally breaks free and flexes over every Lennon and McCartney who gets in his way.
During his time with the Beatles, it was probably more hit-or-miss. For instance, the authors insist that the other three White Album songs indicate that George was "on top of his game," but two of those three songs are kinda shitty ("Piggies" especially, and also "Long, Long, Long"—"Savory Truffle" is pretty good I guess). Let's call George Harrison what he was: a late bloomer. No one gives a fuck about "While My Guitar" if this dude fades into the background after Abbey Road. No one feels the need to do any slotting.
This is definitely one of those Beatles songs that I grew to appreciate fully because I was tasked with writing a blog post about it. Not that I dislike it by any means. More so because... I dunno, I'm not a guitar dude? Obviously some good guitar shit going on here, but I'm not the guy to appreciate it. Especially if that guitar work is by some uncredited asshole name "Old Slowhand" or whatever the fuck. Look, I'm definitely into the idea of cuckolding if all parties are cool with it; Eric Clapton just straight up stole George Harrison's wife. That's wrong. The dude is a piece of shit for plenty of reasons, including this, and including his current anti-vaxxing rhetoric. Not gonna lie, it definitely holds me back from really appreciating any "weeping" heroics in this song.
Nah, forget about all that early-2020s political shit, in which I hate people like the guitarist on this album. What say you of the quality of this song in a vacuum, Joey? I say: very very good. I really appreciate the philosophical argument, even though it's one that's kinda confused me since I first sat down to listen to the White Album. My confusion stems from not knowing whether George Harrison is saying whether his guitar is weeping because of his fans' actions or because of his own actions. Could be either way, to be honest, because of the obtuse lyrics.
"I don't know how you were diverted / you were perverted too." What do you think? If that George talking to the audience, or is that the narrator talking to George? The authors indicate that it's the former. They say that it's a follow-up to John Lennon's message about Love being the only answer, basically positing that the fans haven't been following the Beatles' advice that "all you need is love," and now here is the pushback, that y'all don't even know what love is, yo.
I do not buy it. Seems too harsh. Not really something the Beatles were into, honestly, the whole "calling out your fans" thing. Nah, I see "While My Guitar Gently Weeps" as a self-flagellating thing. George is saying that he—being the heightened-consciousness Buddhist whatever-the-fuck—is doing all this to achieve peace and happiness and unity, and yet the songs seem to just exist to make money, and that becomes the rub. The more George whips that guitar, the more money he makes, and the farther he gets from his stated purpose on this earth. It's a pity thing. "My guitar is weeping because I am using it for capitalistic gains."
What freaks me out personally is the final verse, when George goes: "I look at you all—" and then it's nothing. Either he forgets the verse or he purposefully forgoes it. And then so what? What is he doing when he is looking at us all? Is this his way of turning the mirror toward us, the audience? I see you looking, George! Now what? How can we get this guitar to stop weeping? Or do you not trust us to achieve that goal? Are you a judgmental prick or what? Answer me!
Just kidding on that last part. It's just a song. But, like many of the songs on the White Album, it's kinda haunting if you choose to view it that way. Here's a man who has everything a normal human could possibly desire, and yet he's out there using his wife's bull to convey a feeling of longing anyway, like he's unsatisfied, which, if we're really getting into the emotional weeds, is pretty frightening, since George Harrison was the fucking man, and history would bore that out. Yes, his guitar was weeping, but yo, it's making some good music in the meantime, so let's just let it do it's thing.
BEATLES TRIVIA: We haven't talked about the whole "Paul is dead" conspiracy theory in this column yet. It's probably one of the more well-known pop culture conspiracy theories of all time, so I probably don't need to go into it too deeply. But one of the more prominent "clues" pops up on this song. People here George moaning: "Paul! Paul!" as if he is mourning Paul's death. It does kind of sound like that, but if you listen closely you can also pretty much tell that he's singing the actual lyrics of "No! No! No!" I love the Paul Is Dead thing. I don't love it because I believe it, I love it because the world was a stranger and more mysterious place before the internet gave us all the answers, and this is proof of that.
BETTER BEATLE: Here's some slotting for ya—Ringo motherfucking Starr's "Octopus's Garden" is a better song.
NEXT TIME: We break out of the Top Ten and hit #11, "I Am the Walrus"
No comments:
Post a Comment