Thursday, March 9, 2023

Ranking the Best Original Song Oscar Noms

Programming note: PoYB's annual ranking of the Best Picture nominees will be published on Saturday, since I couldn't finish them in time for today. Blame Avatar.

surprised the Academy couldn't figure out how to nominate this hack again

This is a fun exercise for a few reasons. First, talking about movies is a challenge for me, still, after all these years, because I still feel like I'm a newbie and I don't get it, and so discussing the music in movies is sort of a comfort, a breath of fresh air, flexing a muscle that I'm more confident in, etc. Second, listening to nominated songs is doable even if you haven't seen the film that it's from, and so it's a less overwhelming task, which is something that Oscar season can feel like, sometimes, for me. Third, songs that are nominated for Best Original Song by and large suck, and sometimes it's fun to just talk shit for a couple minutes on a weekday morning.

Here are the nominees, ranked from worst to best. Sidenote: this year's snub is Eilish's "Nobody like U" from Turning Red, so know that every song on this list is worse than that one, and that the Academy can suck a fat dick for snubbing it.

5. "Applause" — Diane Warren (performed by Sofia Carson)


If there had been a single Diane Warren-penned song that I liked since 1998's Aerosmith masterpiece "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing," then I'd say that what the Academy has done to Diane Warren is unspeakably cruel. This poor woman has been nominated for Best Original Song thirteen times before this current nomination, and hasn't won a single time. Will this year be the year? No! Not because Diane Warren is apparently a glutton for punishment dolled out by stuffy suits who hand out the awards. And not even because once again you've never even heard of the movie that Warren's song is from (Tell It like a Woman). No, it's because "Applause" stinks. It's awful. It's hackneyed bullshit that doesn't even deserve a sliming at the Nickelodeon's Kids' Choice Award. If Diane Warren keeps pumping this shit out, then I want nothing more than for her to lose the Oscars another thirteen times.


4. "Lift Me Up" — Tems, Rihanna, Ryan Coogler, Ludwig Göransson


"I need love" is a nice sentiment to repeat over and over for a song about a film about grief (ostensibly, though it's really about profits, but this isn't the time to discuss Wakanda Forever), but all I heard was "I need some motherfucking drums." I'll be the first to admit that I don't like any of Rihanna's songs, but that hasn't stopped me from appreciating her as an artist. This continues the trend. This is a stupid nothing of a song, but Rihanna looks pretty cool singing it. Still: bad. Very bad. Fuck this noise.


3. "This Is a Life" — Ryan Lott, David Byrne, Mitski


Let it be known that "This Is a Life" is here at #3 by default. It's boring, which is made worse by the fact that we expect so much better from legend David Byrne and legend-in-the-making Mitski. But this goes to show that all you need to be nominated for an Oscar for Best Song is a bit of star power and the willingness to scrape together some B-side-worthy bullshit for a runaway hit movie. I wouldn't touch "This Is a Life" with a ten-foot pole if it wasn't attached to one of the most fun film-watching experiences I've had in the past ten years.


2. "Hold My Hand" — Lady Gaga and BloodPop


"Hold My Hand" is generic Lady Gaga, which is better than boring Lady Gaga (is there such a thing?!), and which is WAY better than boring Standard Oscar Nominee in This Category. At least there's some bombast here, ya know? It's corny and not all that original and, like, did we need to have a "My Heart Will Go On"-style ballad for the fucking Top Gun sequel? No. Nevertheless, the song is fine, and dressed as a fighter pilot, Lady Gaga has never looked hotter.


1. "Naatu Naatu" — M. M. Keeravani, Chandrabose (performed by Rahul Sipligunj and Kaala Bhairava)


The only thing I know about RRR is that I will be watching it at some point this year, and the music video for "Naatu Naatu" confirms that decision. I expect RRR to be nothing less than the most fun movie I've ever seen. Everything about this song and this video is so silly and happy and energetic. I can't say I know anything about this genre of music, but "Naatu Naatu" has me itching to get into the dance battle. And when you compare this to the other songs on this short list of nominees? A no-fucking-brainer.


(Not sure where else to put this, but as far as Best Original Score goes, all the nominees can go fuck off, because this was Dan Deacon's year, with his genius score of Hustle. But maybe the film community isn't ready to acknowledge Dan Deacon just yet. It'll happen eventually, mark my words here, in the postscript of a blog post.)

No comments: