See the rest of the exit surveys HERE.
1. Were you happy with the reviews that were published? How do you feel about your week as Record Club captain?
Absolutely. I love reading what my friends write. Thanks, pals, you did awesome yet again. I also think of Record Club at this point as a good way to stay grounded. Clearly it was a weird week for me personally (sorry about airing that in the review, haha), so it was helpful to be able to have something tangible in my life that I could be like "yes, this is a thing we did, it exists, it's real." Feels good.
2. How was the variety of opinions? A wide range, kinda samey, or somewhere in the middle?
Probably tough to have a wide variety of opinions when we explore a genre of music that we don't usually cover here. The understandable temptation to speak toward jazz as a whole was evident, either "I like jazz and I liked this" or "I don't like jazz but I liked this," that type of thing. In terms of How Much We Liked It, everyone was more or less on the same page, with a general sense of "this was surprisingly pleasant." I'll take it!
3. Were there any differing opinions that made you view the album in a different light?
I was surprised there weren't more words spilled on people's feelings about the drums themselves. I think maybe we could've gotten there if the album was entirely drums, but those solos only amounted to about 50% of the album, so I get it. Maybe the hyper-focus on drumming would've been detrimental, I don't know. It's better to consider the whole then focus on a piece. Gary and Sunny had more focus on the instrument than anyone else (you can definitely tell that Sunny has been reading Infinite Jest, by the way). I appreciated Pam's take on caring vs. not caring, because it can be applied to drums and jazz and music itself—to listen, to hear, to be open to new experiences, that's what it's all about, even if that new experience is a five-minute drum solo.
4. Was there anything about this album or this artist that you wished that people would've written about more?
I was definitely taken aback by the idea that this album could be a normal soundtrack for someone's normal day, e.g. Melissa's playtime with the kids or Galia's breakfast. I didn't expect that, because, I dunno, I think I'm coming at it from this sense of awe, like "holy shit listen to these DRUMS!!" However, the more I thought about it, the more Melissa's and Galia's arguments made sense to me. I started thinking a lot about Birdman, and about that episode of It's Always Sunny called "Charlie Work"—both chaotic single-takes, both perfectly soundtracked by the sound of jazz drums. Maybe drums have the power to make chaos more grounded.
5. How do you feel about your album choice now that the week is over? A success? Any regrets?
A success! Quantitatively, there were six reviews, which is one more than my last pick, so it's trending in the right direction. Qualitatively, I stand by my goal of getting people to listen to shit that they normally wouldn't listen to, even to the detriment of that quantity of reviews. I hope there are six people sitting here this morning glad they listened to some fucking hitherto unknown jazz album (I am one of those six). There are plenty of people who are choosing albums because they know RC members are probably already listening to it and they wanna know what those members think. I love it. But I also want to make room for music that we would have never listened to in our personal lives otherwise. Hope that's cool with everyone.
6. Any other takeaways from the reviews? Or from this experience in general?
Nate felt like he needed the excuse of "hating jazz" for not writing a review, when the excuse of "my third daughter was literally just born" would have more than sufficed. Welcome to the world, McClusky Future Hendrix A****.
7. What is an improvement that Record Club can make that would enhance everyone's experience, either as a captain or as a listener/writer?
Taco Bell party is happening soon, hopefully. If you didn't write twelve reviews in 2022, your invite is going to get lost in the mail. But if anyone wants to set any personal goals for themselves this year, let me know! I'll make sure to compensate in some way as my way of saying thanks. Even if that compensation is more tacos.

1 comment:
Jazz sucks and I do not.
Post a Comment