All Eyez on Me
2Pac
1996
It's probably important to remind you this week that these A Year of Blind Spots entries are not reviews. I'm giving my opinion, but it's not structured in a way that I'm asking you to take my opinion seriously or to use my opinion to make choices in your own listening habits. It's not a review because many or most of these "classic" albums stand too tall and are too important for me to be able to make a worthwhile judgment in the span of one week. These are snapshots of opinions, and the point is that these albums are going to stick around, and grow along with me, long after the words are on the blog.
I give the reminder for this week's All Eyez on Me in particular because 2Pac's magnum opus is incredibly complex in legacy, and incredibly long in, well, length. There are 130 minutes of hip hop on this album. That's a fucking lot. That might honestly be the longest non-compilation album on my iPod right now (whoops, let's not forget about 69 Love Songs). On top of the usual caveat of not being able to digest any album in the span of five-to-seven days regardless of the blog project, there's now the additional warning that I literally could not make enough time during that span to consume this mammoth during that time.
With the length comes the question of filler, and I think that's the case here. Look to any retrospective of All Eyez on Me and you'll find the same concession. "Important" doesn't necessarily mean "best." There are some great songs on the album, and there are some bad songs, but ultimately, I'm listening to this today (and the music community at large is still listening to it today) because of its importance, as tied to the artist and his story, a story that has only grown in stature as the years after his murder peel away.
Now, I'll frame All Eyez on Me as a piece of the 2Pac story, obviously, but this is Puke on Your Birthday, and so I need to frame it as part of my story as well (sorry, folks, that's the price of admission). And the story that I am trying to weave into some of these aYoBS entries, this year especially, is one of discovery and of acceptance. Hip hop. What is it, how do I feel about it, can I come to understand it on some deeper level necessary to call myself a "music fan." This is important to me. This is also how the length of All Eyez on Me becomes an important function to me.
It's not that I was overwhelmed with great songs. It's that All Eyez on Me afforded me enough time with 2Pac in enough different ways that I felt comfortable knowing who this rapper is and what he sounds like in a general sense. And that starts to become more important to me as I move through some of the "rap legends," because then I can start trying to understand the ways in which rappers sound different. We're starting from a point of ignorance here: "All rap sounds the same." That's not true, it's ignorance, but as someone who was not raised on rap, that is sincerely where I started. So here is where I am right now, after a week with Pac.
I can tell the difference between 2Pac and Wu-Tang. I can label them as "west coast" and "east coast" respectively, and I can actually hear the difference, which is new to me. Whether I can articulate that difference is another matter, but an attempt: the production on All Eyez on Me sounds lush and full and expensive, while the production on Enter the Wu-Tang sounds harsh and spartan and cheap; the production on All Eyez on Me being what it is means 2Pac is kind of like its sparring partner, and he dips and dives all over the beat, rocking along to its rhythms, whereas on Enter the Wu-Tang, the production is completely in service of the vocals, and acts less like a partner and more like a spotlight, trained on each member of the Wu as he steps up the front of the stage.
Now, the only reason I'm comparing 2Pac and Wu-Tang specifically right now is because of complete chance. They happened to be the last two rap artists that showed up on my randomly generated list of Blind Spots. I'm lucky that they are both pretty high up on "important rappers in history" lists, but still, my point in this paragraph is to say that it's not just a dichotomy. There are an infinite amount of rap styles, and only by going through each in the spectrum, one by one, can I truly start to understand rap in all its varied glory.
What might have been too easy, or too difficult, is to compare 2Pac to the Notorious B.I.G., who began our journey in honest. To compare those two artists would be to try to do something that too many people in the past have already tried to do, and indeed were trying to do in real time, as they spearheaded the so-called East v. West rivalry of the '90s. I won't try to add my two cents here, because it's too early to try. Also... I'll admit that maybe 2Pac sounded surprisingly similar to Biggie? Maybe I was expecting 2Pac's voice to be a lot higher than Biggie's, since I have been told forever that these two artists are polar opposites? But no, Pac's voice was deep in a similar way.
If I were to dip my big toe in these waters of compare/contrast tomfoolery—okay, fine—maybe I'd say that 2Pac's voice has finesse, and Biggie's has strength. There was a rhythmic flow to Pac's delivery, in which the emphasized words in a bar were expected, and thus baked into the rhythm, whereas Biggie's emphases are more surprising, and hit you like a punch from behind. In general, the beats seem slower on Ready to Die, but that enhances their power. All Eyez on Me is more like a motorcycle—fast, loud, and kind of important to keep upright over long lengths of road.
Let's not do this too much though. I am not confident in what I'm saying. There is a great chance that I'm going to be reading this after a few years and a few dozen more rap albums and I'm going to be extremely embarrassed. Like I said: a snapshot. I'm working through my discovery in real time. Bear with me.
We should focus on 2Pac from here on out (sidenote: I keep saying "2Pac," since I'm under the assumption that this is his artist name, whereas "Tupac Shakur" is his real name, but please correct me if I got this wrong). There is a lot to consider here as well, more than I have any right or any obligation to cover at this time.
No judgments either way about the artist, but it feels like crime is an important part of the legacy, and I'm handling this aspect with kid gloves. He was born to a revolutionary mother, and became a folk hero by shooting cops and being cleared of charges (taunting the police is a pretty good theme throughout the lyrics). He also was out on bail on sexual assault charges, which makes me pretty uncomfortable (and indeed, there is an extremely misogynistic song on Disc 2 that has aged terribly). In terms of themes of this work and the life of its author, I will probably place it all to the side for now, if that's okay (totally understandable if it's not, I'm just saying that this really isn't my intended focus in this column for the most part).
Also, Tupac Shakur was infamously murdered in 1996 as part (probably) of that aforementioned East/West rivalry (B.I.G. was murdered six months later). Pam and I actually lived right down the street from the Las Vegas corner he was gunned down at, but that's not really the point that's important about his death. I feel like I engage differently with art created by artists who have since met their demise, especially if that demise was untimely. And so that aspect of Pac's story is important here, obviously. It plays out in many ways, not just the obvious ones (e.g. "Life Goes On," in which he remains stalwart in life despite how much death surrounds him). It hits me hard that he was only 24 years old when this album came out, and 25 when he was murdered. That seems really young. The subject matter is he touches upon scans as real to me, and lived by its artist, and man, I can't imagine wishing any of this on anyone, especially at this age.
But sometimes I also take too much stock in death and its place in art. Maybe this isn't the time for that, I don't know, especially because Shakur's murder is pretty general knowledge at this point, and thus would come off as cliché if I went too far down that road. I can't possibly know who this guy was, even musically, in this short amount of time. If anything, I'm happy that I got to spend the time trying anyway. I really do feel like I got something out of the experience, which is nice to feel, especially after my eyes popped out of my head when I saw the runtime. This is worth it. It's all worth it. Listen to "What's Ya Phone #"! It's worth it!!
We'll be back with another rap album in less than a month, so we'll continue the main PoYB rap storyling then. As far as 2Pac's story goes, I hope this is enough coverage for now.

No comments:
Post a Comment