Saturday, March 11, 2023

PoYB's 6th Annual Blog Post About the Oscars


One of these years, we'll watch every single Oscar nominee. I say that every year, and I mean it every year, but it seems like I always get started way too late, and then life gets in the way. Life being as full as it is this year, we are content with just watching the Best Picture nominees. Here they are, listed in order from worst to best (in my opinion). I'll write a little something under each, but I can't promise anything too intense (if you crave more content, you can always follow Puke on Letterboxd).

10. Avatar: The Way of Water

This was the longest Playstation 2 video game cutscene I've ever seen. And it was unskippable. True: I watched a bootleg version on my computer, and while, as a literal video-camera-in-theater copy, it was a better quality than it had any right to be, it still wasn't the TRUE IMAX EXPERIENCE or whatever the fuck people are gonna claim is "necessary" to "truly" have an "Avatar experience." Here's my takeaway from suffering through watching these stupid blue people learn to swim for three and a half hours: if the Academy nominates Avatar 3 for Best Picture, I will probably stop watching movies all together, and maybe switch to cheap Netflix true crime docs, or maybe TNT's Claws.

9. Elvis

People will tell you this was a bad biopic. They aren't wrong, but it was a good type of bad, if that makes sense. The bad parts were funny, and the good parts were cathartic. No one is being hyperbolic about Austin Butler's performance—it's just that good. No one is being hyperbolic about Tom Hanks' performance—it's just that bad. But it's a good bad! It's the type of performance—and the type of movie—that sticks with you for a while, like a wild blackout in your formative years.

8. All Quiet on the Western Front

I was down on this movie when I first watched it, because I'm tired, man. I'm tired of watching movies that think that "WAR IS BAD" is some revelatory message. Thank goodness All Quiet is saved by the intense cinematic value. War is bad, okay, fine, but that doesn't mean it can't look good. 

7. Top Gun: Maverick

Very stupid that this movie is nominated for Best Picture. It's a good and possibly even great movie, but, I don't know, it feels like there should be something more than that for films being honored with the highest Oscar nomination. It feels like they secretly added that forsaken "Best Popular Movie" category this year. Top Gun made a lot of money? Best Picture nom! To its credit, it really is one of those rare sequels that is better than the original. Especially because the original Top Gun stinks. Who knew all you had to do was take an old '80s movie and make it coherent?

6. Women Talking

Take this ranking with a grain of salt, since I was tipsy and I fell asleep for a little bit while watching Women Talking. From what I saw, it was a good talkie. My kind of movie, honestly. But also the type of movie that I imagine when I think about Oscar Best Picture Nominees—artsy fartsy stuff that your Avatar freaks are gonna pooh-pooh on premise alone. Correct, there is no action here. It's all dialogue and philosophy and crucible-hot performances. Probably could go for a rewatch, to be honest.

5. Tár

Here's where we start getting to the point in the list where you could reasonably be like "wtf Tár is down at fucking #5?!" and you'd have a point. Tár was a great movie, kept great by a great performance in Cate Blanchett. I appreciated how much this film asks of its audience, emotionally. How much empathy are we supposed to have here? To what degree are we willing to judge the protagonist? Should we judge in the first place? Just because the answer to that last one is "yes" doesn't mean it's not a tough answer to get to.

4. The Banshees of Inisherin

Shit, man, I love movies that are designed like plays. There isn't much action—sure, a couple fingers are lost along the way, but most of the actual explosions are happening across the river, on the mainland. Here on Inisherin, the drama is interpersonal. Just watch as that drama is heightened, to the point that it really does feel akin to that civil war happening across the way. Nicely done.

3. Triangle of Sadness

Movie reviews are spoilers. Don't read them until after you watch the movie. Go into every film-watching experience completely in the dark. Only then can you experience the true shock and awe that a film like Triangle of Sadness is meant to convey. What a wild fucking ride. The middle section especially is absolutely fucking bonkers. I know the message is a little on the nose, but I don't care. Tough to care when I'm laughing and gasping this loudly.

2. Everything Everywhere All at Once

EEAaO lives in that magical space where over-the-top is just enough. It took at least an hour to adjust to that heightened reality, but once it clicked, it stayed there for the rest of the film. By far the most creative film of the year. Look, there's no universe in which I'm not loving a movie with an extended gag about Ratatouille, okay? I'm sorry. Silly, yet satisfying.

1. The Fabelmans

If I had seen more than like five or six Spielberg movies in my life, I would say something really cool right here, like: "Isn't it interesting to experience a film that acts like a skeleton key for the director's entire filmography?" I don't know if I have enough experience to say that, but I feel it in my bones that it's true. This is a director being bold by being real and true and honest. It's a film that isn't afraid of saying that life is hard, but that the solution to your problems is easy: movies. Or escape, whatever. It's a trite and corny answer, maybe, but daring to be trite and corny becomes its own kind of courage. A movie that makes the case that movies are great by being a great movie—can't get any better than that.


Final rankings:

1. The Fablemans
2. Everything Everywhere All at Once
3. Triangle of Sadness
4. The Banshees of Inisherin
5. Tár
6. Women Talking
7. Top Gun: Maverick
8. All Quiet on the Western Front
9. Elvis
10. Avatar: Way of the Water

If we're talking about which films that I think I would be okay with winning the prize, you can split the list exactly in half. The top five films on the list all deserve Best Picture.

If we're talking predictions about what WILL win, then as always, my answer is: I have no fucking clue, what do I look like, some rich snob with an Oscar vote? It'll probably be fucking Avatar or some shit. 

No comments: