Thursday, March 24, 2022

PoYB Oscars Week, Day 4: Best Picture


This is the fifth year that Puke on Your Birthday has covered the Academy Awards (or, more accurately, Joe's dumb ill-informed thoughts about the films nominated at the Academy Awards), and more than any other year so far, this one felt like a chore. Maybe I really am biting off more than I can chew—committing to watching as many nominated films as we could and then forcing myself to come up with an opinion about each is too tall of a task for someone who, even after all this goddamn time, still doesn't feel too comfortable filling those film critic shoes. This is supposed to be fun, right? Then why does it feel like work?

Regardless, we soldier on, completing our week-long coverage of the 94th Academy Awards by going through the ten Best Picture nominees, and then eventually ranking them. I will be stealing liberally from my Letterboxd account and the "reviews" I already wrote there, since I assume there are maybe two people at most who read both, so they will just have to excuse the shortcut today. Plus, it's been pretty well established by this point in the week that I don't have anything intelligent to say about movies anyway. Maybe you're just here for the ranking. If so, welcome, and feel free to scroll directly to the bottom of this blog post.
 
Look, okay, I didn't really have much time to write this week about any of this, but I didn't want to forgo the Oscar thing this year, so I figure the copying/pasting is a good compromise for this morning. I'm literally waking up early to write about Nightmare Alley, which we just saw last night. I'm dedicated to the cause, I promise! I just didn't have the energy to write brand new thoughts for every single film! Sorry!

Best Picture
 
Belfast


To those who stayed
: I thought this was a pretty poignant snapshot of the search for joy in unrelenting cruelty. To those who left: I really don't get why I was told repeatedly that this was a boring film. To those we lost: At this point, out of all the so-called "frontrunners," I'd be the least disappointed if Belfast won, even though there are other worthy films here.


CODA


The premise of "the whole family is DEAF but her true passion is SINGING" sounds like it could be an SNL skit, so I was truly shocked how much emotion they were able to wring from it. Truly remarkable how expressive everyone was without saying anything out loud.

 
Don't Look Up


A movie that I both enjoyed and also can understand why other people don't enjoy. It was like getting beat over the head with a sock full of nickels for two and a half hours. I enjoy considering the sock full of nickels. I believe it exists, because I feel it hitting my skull. At a certain point I'm just wondering whether I need to be beaten with it. Still... it does make an impact.

 
Drive My Car
 

This took us three nights to watch. By the end of the first night I was wishing that she'd just drive him to the fireworks factory already. By the end of the third night, I think we had gotten there (but, ya know, emotionally). This one is gonna take a bit to sink in, but I know now that it touched something within me, even if I can't name that thing specifically just yet.


Dune


Thought it would be confusing and it wasn't. Thought it would look stupid but it didn't (i.e. visually stunning blah blah blah). Thought it would have something special, something Oscar-worthy, and it didn't. But I also thought it would suck ass, and it definitely didn't.

 
King Richard
 

Always kind of weird when the main character is a real person and the people involved in making the film have a reason to make sure that character looks good. I was hoping for some crazy tennis parent fun. I instead got kinda crazy and kinda fun, albeit SUPERBLY acted as well. I just wonder if this is the truest version of this story, is all.


Licorice Pizza


"You only think this is funny because it's the Haim sisters." This was Pam during our viewing when she saw me smiling ear to ear. Yeah? So what? It's cool seeing a star being born in real time. Same with the Hoffman kid. This film lives and dies with its fantastic leads.


Nightmare Alley


Much like a carnival, there's plenty of entertainment to be had. I liked Nightmare Alley, but I dunno, it was missing a certain je ne sais quoi. I felt the exact same way about The Shape of Water a few years ago, and that was a Best Picture winner. This begs the question: who's the geek, Guillermo or me?


The Power of the Dog


The twist is really only answers the question "what genre of movie is this?" It didn't, like, require multiple viewings or anything. That kid was creepy enough that he deserves an Oscar. Cumberbatch voices the Grinch in the 2018 adaptation; I couldn't not hear the Grinch here. Plemons once again strikes the balance between "he was really good" and "my fear of being as pasty as Jesse Plemons fuels every single mile that I run." The twist is really the only thing that makes this movie worthy of conversation, but that's more context than subtext, so points off for that. Overall, I'll say "tentatively overrated."


West Side Story


This is how you make a movie on cheat mode. Have one the greatest film directors ever take what is already considered one of the best movies of all time and improve it in almost every conceivable way. It's like when you play solitaire by flipping over every card instead of every third card—it's almost impossible to lose. But winning feels so good!!


BEST PICTURE NOMINEES FROM WORST TO BEST

10. The Power of the Dog
9. Nightmare Alley
8. Dune
7. Don't Look Up
6. King Richard
5. Drive My Car
4. Licorice Pizza
3. CODA
2. Belfast
1. West Side Story

And I'll draw the line between #6 and #7 for which films I'd consider "worthy" of the Best Picture award. 

Alright, that's it for PoYB's Oscar coverage. Enjoy the show Sunday night. I'll talk to y'all Monday morning after I wake up and look on Wikipedia to see who won. 

No comments: