This week's Record Club is a reminder of the power of peer pressure and how it's not exclusive to childhood and adolescence. Though I can't say that I feel this pressure in the same way I might have in my youth to fit in with others or do something because "everyone else is doing it," I am still plenty susceptible in my adult life to the suggestions of others to do things I might not necessarily choose on my own. As it pertains to this week's participation, the "pressure" is low stakes and mostly positive—money will be donated for a charitable cause; mental benefits will be gained by exercising critical thinking and writing; this community of PoYB contributors will grow stronger. It was pretty much a no-brainer when there is so much to benefit from writing a review this week. That being said, now that I have listened to Smart Kids, I wonder if I would have made the same choice had I been fully aware of what I was getting into prior to committing.
I have very mixed emotions about this album. On the one side, you have this children's album full of tunes that are reminiscent (and almost an homage/ parody) of popular '80s R&B/Pop songs or cheesy '80s sitcom openings with plenty of funky brass instrumentation and some synth peppered throughout. The lyrics are bland, repetitive, and lack any real substance, and McGruff's vocal ability is less than angelic, but the sound of the whole album is very playful and kind of fun when context is disregarded. If I were judging the album solely on vibes and sound, I think my opinion would be quite favorable.
However, it's this other side to the album—the context of this album—that is hugely problematic for me. The War of Drugs campaign introduced in the '70s, along with the Anti-Drug Abuse Act passed during the Reagan administration, both vilified and punished those struggling with drug addiction. It's probably safe to assume that PoYB contributors and readers are plenty familiar with how the War of Drugs impacted society negatively over the past three decades, so I'll refrain from ranting. Having this children's album, which was released the same year as the Anti-Drug Abuse Act, spread such detrimental rhetoric and push such an evil political agenda is despicable.
Final Verdict: If I scraped away the propaganda, replaced McGruff the Crime Dog's rough vocals, and added unbiased drug awareness and prevention information, this would still be a corny children's album but I would at least be able to justify and approve of its existence. Despite flashes of fun and artistry in this album, context matters, especially today, which is why I cannot give this album any more than 1/5 Bites Out of Crime *chomp*
No comments:
Post a Comment