Friday, March 4, 2022

Lumos, Sunny


Surely the only thing more cringey than reviewing an HP music album in 2022 is a grown man whinging about the whole IP. For my money, Nate nailed it on the head with his review—there's quite a bit of interesting song writing and real emotion here, but, uh, gotta look past the core conceit of what you're singing around. Somehow these guys are singing about 'Arry and the gang for about as long as Hozier is singing about organized religion. Basta.

Okay, maybe I have a personal axe to grind. So what? What is PoYB for if not the time-to-time personal rant? I mean, I'd drop it, but the world doesn't seem to want to. You see there's another Harry Potter movie coming out this year? Cursed Child, based on the 2016 play, with the original cast and even Chris Columbus! Wow. To level set, Deathly Hallows Pt2 was over a decade ago. Folks, have you checked out this plot?

I understand some have not seen the play and want to avoid spoilers. Ok, no problem, I get it. Here are some (even more) meaningless words to fill up vertical space on the screen, to give you some time and room to close the browser window, turn away, never read one of these putative "album reviews" of mine again. How come Harry, who is massively rich due to some trust fund situation, never bought his poor friend Ron like a gift card to the wand store or whatever when his wand was torching his ass every day? Why do wizards even have money and commerce and banks anyway? Like, you can possess magic but still be poor as shit. They live in Great Britain so they must be aware of the works of Smith, Ricardo, Marx, &c, but uh, irrelevant right? I guess, because there are also straight up chattel slave elves, most of whom, in the parlance of the story, like being slaves, so yeah, money-value of things is irrelevant! But still, don't be poor, or your wand will torch your ass. Bootstraps young Ron. Alright that's probably enough vertical space.

Spoilers.

I mean what the fuck. I get the general theme of "don't fuck with time" except there was a whole book in the core series whose plot hinged on "fucking with time!" But NOW if you fuck with time you really fuck stuff up. Maybe it's because I'm a clear Claw/Puff houser, but the plot of the play reads to me like a reverse It's a Wonderful Life. Cedric Diggory: It's a HORRIBLE Life. Stay dead next time ya dumb b—!

Anyway, "Gone Campin'," "Where's Ron?," and "The Sword, the Cup, and the Dragon" were fun. I'm glad everyone who had fun, had fun.

P.S. After being burned enough times, I am highly skeptical of Kickstarter. This album was a Kickstarter? 1,202 people spent $55K on a promise. But I guess the band had already spent $30K+ on making and publicizing it by then. Yeah? $30K? See again the point about having fun.

No comments: