I've decided that these mini-reviews should be explicitly framed as follow-ups to reviews that were written during each artist's Record Club spotlight. The reviews here should answer the simple question of: "How does this album stack up against the album that RC reviewed originally?" This means that none of this will mean anything if you weren't keyed into Record Club when we originally covered these artists. To that I say: get thee to the archives!!
I'm trying to finish up most of the RC alumni output from 2020 and 2021 today, since, as you saw this past Sunday, the list of RC follow-ups is growing exponentially larger by the month. Hopefully I can do another one of these next week!
Such Pretty Forks in the Road by Alanis Morissette
Released: July 21, 2020
Follow-up to: Jagged Little Pill, Week 50
I think the big takeaway from our week with Jagged Little Pill was how cool Alanis sounded, even all these years removed from the '90s. Her voice is preserved in amber. Obviously, an album from 2020 is not going to have the same power, and I didn't expect it to. However, I also didn't expect it to sound this... exhausted? Not so much the voice itself, which aesthetically sounds the same. I'm more talking about how she employs it. There are a lot of slow, sad ballads on this thing. I'd be willing to grant such a legend a certain amount of leeway, but she goes overboard. Seen in the right light, maybe the songs could seem powerful. In the context of her being decades past her prime, most of it just comes off as weepily nostalgic. Maybe that was the point. If so, call it a success. I'm over hear falling asleep through the back half, though, so I can't in good faith say we have a late-career resurgence on our hands. Pick out a few good songs for your playlist and call it a day.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5 (-2.0 from previous review)
My Mamma by La Rappresentante di Lista
Released: March 5, 2021
Follow-up to: Go Go Diva, Week 79
When we first came across this festival-ready but often mysterious Italian pop act, all I could hear was Florence + the Machine. As ambivalent as I am toward Florence (and as inscrutable as La Rapp were, with the foreign language lyrics), I was sold with this RC selection. Credit where it's due to La Rappresentante di Lista for trying some new things on this most recent album, even though there is probably less than a 50% success rate. You have something like "Sarà ," which takes the sound away from the festival stage and deep into the club (it's an okay transition I guess). You have something like "Fragile," which tries to be this dembow-type thing with a male vocalist (boo!!), and is terrible (boo!!!). Then you have "Amare," which tries to recapture what made Go Go Diva so special, and gets there by going even farther into the confetti-strewn molly-dropping festival-algorithm sound. I mean, if Go Go Diva did one thing really well, then My Mamma is the band failing at one thousand things. I greatly admire such an attempt, even though I'll never actually like it all that much. This was an INCREDIBLE album to listen to once and then never think about again.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5 (-1.0 from previous review)
Sensational by Erika de Casier
Released: May 21, 2021
Follow-up to: Essentials, Week 37
Stereogum's The Number Ones column is currently moving through the early-to-mid-'90s, and so I'm getting my healthy dose of TLC, with Destiny's Child right around the corner. So in this way, I should be primed to return to the sounds of Erika de Casier. And yes, I am more mature than I was back in Week 37 of Record Club, and my outlook has changed so that I can appreciate the fact that de Casier took what was originally an immense, world-conquering sound, and pulled it all into her bedroom. Imagine T-Boz singing the old hits at your local coffee shop. That's Sensational. I admire it, and I think that a few of the songs connected with me on some subconscious level, but the fact still remains that this isn't really my style. I no longer think of it as "spa music" (i.e. this is actually closer to PinkPantheress than the last album), but that's about the highest praise I can afford at this current juncture.
GRADE: 2.5 pukes out of 5 (+0.5 from previous review)
Intra-I by Theon Cross
Released: October 29, 2021
Follow-up to: Fyah, Week 28
Alright, I'm not gonna lie, I was excited for this one. The biggest problem with Fyah was that a tuba can simply not handle the weight of carrying an entire album. On Intra-I, however, it doesn't have to. There are vocals! As it turns out, the tuba can work wonders in a supporting role. Just feel that motherfucking rumble as Remi Graves gives a poetic intro. The tuba can lend a real power to these proceedings when it knows its place. In the spotlight, it just looks silly. The spotlight on Intra-I turns instead toward the guests, and they all shine. Shumba Maasai has real swagger on "Roots" while rapping over the tuba. Afronaut Zu and Ahnansé invite the tuba to a night out in the club. And then even something like "We Go Again" succeeds without vocals, because the trumpet and the synths(!) take turns, while the tuba is just the hypeman, as it should be. Look, I don't want to say that Fyah sucked because of its central conceit; it was instead a good album, crucially, despite its central conceit. And I'm here to say that, on Intra-I, Theon Cross has heard our pleas and has fixed everything. What a humbling experience that must have been. I, for one, appreciate it, and admire him for making that decision.
GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5 (+1.0 from previous review)





No comments:
Post a Comment