In honor of Pam's birthday this weekend, Puke on Your Birthday had a conversation with her about her favorite albums of all time. The following is edited and occasionally paraphrased, but is in Pam's own words, as told to the blog. The albums are listed in the order that she discussed them, and is not necessarily indicative of any ranking (mostly since ranking favorite albums is really hard!).
Blue by Joni Mitchell
It's not the first thing that comes up when you search "Blue" on iTunes—that would be either that song "I'm Blue" or a Bluey album, oh god. Anyway... I think, on the surface, a lot of the songs are not complex, but the more you listen to them, the more they reveal themselves. And maybe that I can see myself in that reveal. There is more than meets the eye. Gary once told me I was a chicken sandwich, because I "seem like I'm boring, but I'm not." So Joni and I? Spicy chicken sandwiches.
Blue by Joni Mitchell
It's not the first thing that comes up when you search "Blue" on iTunes—that would be either that song "I'm Blue" or a Bluey album, oh god. Anyway... I think, on the surface, a lot of the songs are not complex, but the more you listen to them, the more they reveal themselves. And maybe that I can see myself in that reveal. There is more than meets the eye. Gary once told me I was a chicken sandwich, because I "seem like I'm boring, but I'm not." So Joni and I? Spicy chicken sandwiches.
I liked Carole King before seeing the musical Beautiful based on her life, but afterward... First of all, in the musical, someone is playing her life. It's not a jukebox musical, but there are a lot of songs that she and her husband wrote for doo-wop groups. But Tapestry is her breaking out into her own, and the musical helped me visualize that arc. I would've heard it as more one note, before seeing and hearing what lead up to this album.
It's impossible not to view this album in terms of nostalgia. It's tough to pinpoint what about Bruce is "nostalgic," and I don't even know if I have a right to be nostalgic about it. This album came out before I was born, so if "nostalgia" means a time and a place specifically, I can't say I was there. But I think we've created our own nostalgia—like, we play it on the way to the shore—and it helps that it just has a specific sound to it. It sounds like the Jersey Shore. I don't know if people who've never been to the Jersey Shore could say that, or if they've created their own nostalgia around it. I don't know! I just know how I feel about it. You play an album so many times, and then eventually the most recent time you play it becomes that nostalgic moment. "Thunder Road" was our cake-cutting song at our wedding! This is that album.
I think because it's not a "classic" Beatles pick, that it's a little weirder than the other picks—Sgt. Pepper's, Abbey Road—it's a little quirkier than some of the other Beatles albums. It's not something our parents would pick as their favorite, is basically what I'm trying to say. This pick is an attempt to find something personal in the band that is the most impersonal, universal band of all time. I have to have a Beatles album on my Top Ten, but I would never have, like, The White Album or something. Everyone who really listens to the Beatles would pick one of those. But this isn't to say I picked this arbitrarily. I do love Rubber Soul a lot.
It's not easy to pick a favorite song off this album. Maybe before we reviewed it for Record Club, I might have chosen a different song—I probably would've picked "Dreams" or "The Chain," but now I'd say "You Can Go Your Own Way." It wasn't until I sat down and really studied the lyrics that I felt a connection to that song, and this album as a whole. This is a breakup album, but it's not a typical breakup album. "I'm okay with parting ways." You have to think past all the diabetes commercials to get there at this point, but I still feel like I'm able to. We've spilled too many words about Fleetwood Mac this year already, but still...
Is it important for me to feel like an artist "gets" me? Yes and no. I don't need all eleven of my albums on this list to be like that. But it's important sometimes. There is so much good music out there, and I feel like if I listened to music at the same clip that my husband does, than maybe I'd have different albums here. For me, though, when I get into an album, I listen to it all the time. This was one of those albums. I listened to it nonstop. So I guess that means this album connects with me. And it's not even like the whole album speaks to me, but it doesn't have to! "If We Were Vampires," "Anxiety," these songs speak to me on a deeper level, which evens out with the cowboy stuff that I might not necessarily relate to in the same way.
If I was made to choose a number on the Wong–Baker Faces Pain Rating Scale, I'd definitely be at a 0 when listening to Jens Lekman. He makes me so happy. That's his nature, as an artist and a songwriter and a person. I listen to Jens and I feel calm. That's honestly just the easier answer I can give you. Isn't Sweden a happy country? I seek out Scandavian music, because it all seems to fit that aesthetic. Jens... he's a little ABBA-ish! Especially on this album. It's not so much "Swedish-written pop" like that. It's more eclectic. It has an indie feel to it, which is important to me. But definitely draw the line between the Swedes being happy people and me being the happiest person when I hear Life Will See You Now.
I can tell you the exact time that I first listened to this album. My husband burned me a mix CD in 2010, and I discovered them through that. I didn't listen to this type of music that much before meeting that asshole. But so I was in grad school. I was taking the subway to La Salle from my old apartment. I was sitting on the Broad Street Line. It was cold out. I always associate this album with wintertime because of that. I still think about sitting on the bright orange seats, with my earbuds in (pre-kids, oh god, not having to worry about anything). Things are different now, but Funeral is still here for me.
In the last decade, this is probably the album that I would more often than not claim was my "favorite album of all time." It came into my life during a time when I was struggling with some things, certain decisions I had to make, and this album helped me through all that. So I grasped onto it. It's not an album specifically about those decisions—like, I was deciding career path and whatnot, it's not like Local Natives were singing about nursing—but certain lines stood out to me. "I want to start again" is the first line on the album! I know it's probably mostly about relationships, and I was happy in my relationship at the time, but... employment is just a different type of relationship, you know? This album is like a Rorschach Test, and I saw/heard the album the way I needed to.
This might seem like an outlier among the rest of the albums. Call it representative of what I was listening to during a specific time in my life. Up until this album, I was listening to whatever the radio told me to listen to, which was mostly Christina Aguilera and Destiny's Child. When this came out, I was headed to a Christina Aguilera concert. But a friend burned me all the Saves the Day albums he had when we were in high school, and my life took a sharp right turn.
If I were to rank how much I like these artists, as people, then Father John Misty would be near the bottom, right? But my feelings about the artist doesn't necessarily overshadow how I feel about their music. It could, like for instance you won't see Kanye West on this list, but it doesn't in this case specifically. Father John Misty seems kind of arrogant, ya know? Someone I would've wanted to hook up with in college, basically. My "type." Tall, skinny, bearded men! (We all know who I'm really talking about here—the Guy from High Maintence.) But like I said, this is all separate from how I feel about the music. And it's on this list, so you can obviously surmise how I feel about I Love You, Honeybear.
Thanks Pam! Have a great birthday!!
No comments:
Post a Comment