Saturday, March 12, 2022

A Year of Blind Spots: Slow Train Coming


The crux of today's A Year in Blind Spots entry, as presented by Puke on Your Birthday, is as follows: Yes, you've experienced Bob Dylan, but have you ever experienced Bob Dylan on Christianity?!

The thing that makes Bob Dylan one of the best musical artists of all time is the fact that he is still, 60 years into his career, such a fucking mystery. Usually, when you spend that much time in the public eye, that public gradually starts to feel like they know you, more and more, year after year, as more things are revealed. With Dylan, as I grow from my teenage years with him until now, I feel like year after year I continually know less about him. And if we are accepting the fact that this inscrutable man will always remain a puzzle, no matter what, then the puzzle piece that has most intrigued me is the idea that Dylan spent three years (and three albums) as a certified born-again Christian zealot. What a career.

Now, the temptation is to dismiss these religious efforts outright, especially if you're like me, your humble atheist/agnostic/unknown blogger. No, on the surface, Bob Dylan singing out Jesus Christ does not sound like an appealing prospect. But I'm old enough to know that one can find good music in the strangest places, and I wanted to see if that could be applied here. Plus, it's not like Slow Train Coming, et al., haven't been critically reappraised in the past ten years or so anyway. I'm not plumbing unknown depths here. I have a fucking map.

I've tried to approach this material the same way the album's producer Jerry Wexler (chosen because he was already a legendary name in the soul music scene) did when Dylan tried to evangelize him: "I said, 'Bob, you're dealing with a sixty-two-year-old confirmed Jewish atheist. I'm hopeless. Let's just make an album.'" Let's just make an album. I fucking love it. I listened to a ton of Slow Train Coming this week, and that was my outlook every time. Let's just listen to an album.

Because the worst part by far is the saccharine Christian rock lyrics. If you think Bob Dylan was insufferable in incomprehensible-figurative-language mode, just wait till you hear him God's love and the Gospels and the creation myth and so on. All the preaching comes off like how the priest at the wedding I attended last week acted in Mass—dude spent five solid minutes before the Eucharist lambasting the idea of non-Catholics even thinking about trying to come up and receive that goddamn Eucharist. At a certain point, it was like, yo, I get it, I don't want your Jesus flesh anyway, jeez! Christians love othering non-Christians. They get off on it. Dylan has a big spiritual boner throughout this album.

But you know already what the other side of the coin is. Of course. It's Bob Dylan. Of course the music is going to be fun as hell. Goddamn, what a pretty mix of blues and funk and soul he created here. Musically, it might be one of my favorite Dylan albums, which is an insane thing to say, since it was created by a clearly rabid, drooling Jesus freak. I'm almost tempted to say the music is so good that it proves God exists, but then, why are the other 99.999% of Christian rock albums so shitty?

It's worth asking the question whether I am able to separate art from religion better than I was with Mahalia Jackson, and if so, why that is. In some respects, I think it's easier to separate the two, mainly because this is widely known as a "phase" for Dylan—within four years, he wasn't practicing Christianity anymore—whereas Mahalia Jackson was in the game for life. In other respects, it's more difficult to separate the two here, since Jackson presented her religious beliefs in a way that was kind and empathetic and full of love, whereas Dylan spits vitriol and hate on Slow Train Coming for all those who don't believe, and he has no problem in telling the non-Christians that their time is up and that hell awaits.

It's tough to get offended, because I'm sure even Dylan today would regret being such an asshole in the late 1970s (though he'd never, ever admit it). This isn't one of my favorite artists telling me to go fuck myself; this is his ghost, and Slow Train Coming is a transmission from another time. It's pretty easy to split those transmissions in half, to take the good (incredible music) with the bad (moronic religious bullshit). I'll gladly fucking do it, I don't care.

If you are already a fan of Bob Dylan, and you've held off on his Christian period because you think Christianity is a net negative for the human race (an extremely reasonable take), then I can say that I definitely understand, but that I would also give this a shot. This is a great opportunity to separate art from artist, because for once in our fucked up lives, that separation is completely harmless. Fuck God, Bob Dylan forever.



No comments: