- Encanto
- Flee
- Luca
- The Mitchells vs. the Machines
- Raya and the Last Dragon
Y'all know the deal—I'm an interloper here. I'm not well-versed in the art of filmmaking, or even filmwatching. This is my fifth year writing about the Oscars on Puke on Your Birthday, and the perennial slogan for this ongoing feature is, as always: "I have no idea what will win." I don't know how the film industry works, and I'm not going at pretending to tell you what makes a movie worthy of an award. What I can tell you is what should win. The "should" part is easy. "Should" is the name of the game on this blog. I'll tell you "should" all goddamn week about any subject I goddamn well please.
And I'm starting today's Oscars blog post (first of four this week) with this introduction, because it's leading me into saying that I think the Best Animated Feature category, out of the 23 awards presented this Sunday, is the one I feel most comfortable making a "what should win" judgment, maybe even enough that I could take a stab at the "what will win" question.
Because most of these movies are ostensibly for kids, right? Four out of the five in this category this year are, as far as I'm concerned. And I have kids who watch movies. The four non-Flee films on this nominees list have all been in at least semi-constant rotation in my household since their respective release dates. This is not an exaggeration: combine the total number of hours that either Encanto, Luca, Mitchells, or Raya have been on my living room television screen, and you're approaching triple digits, if not crossing that barrier. I know these fucking movies. My kids know these movies, so yeah, that means I know these movies. Intimately, I'd argue.
So maybe the first thing we should talk about is Flee, and how much of an outlier that is. Pam and I have seen Flee, of course, but it was absolutely the only one on this list that we've watched after 8 PM. It's an incredible movie—the story of an Afghan refugee, as told by that refugee, but anonymously, as the story is animated to protect the identities of all those involved. I mean, it's definitely the first film to be nominated for both Best Animated Feature and Best Documentary Feature, right? So there's no questioning how unique it is. Watching it will confirm how harrowing and how truly emotionally affecting it is as well.
I'm not saying that the other films aren't emotional in their own ways, but Flee's stature as an "adult" movie sets it apart. I'm not even saying that this makes Flee a better movie than the others—it's not true, but it's close?—I'm just saying that it's really strange to consider even comparing Flee with something like Luca. They are worlds apart, and yet they are jammed into this same category based on the fact that they look the same (i.e. they are animated).
And then there is the fact that Flee is a bit removed from our lives here in the K*** household, as compared to the other films on the list. If I watched Flee the same number of times I watched Raya and the Last Dragon, then maybe I would feel a strong emotional connection to Flee in the same way. But that would mean I'd have to watch Flee at least 25 more times, and that's just not how my life is structured right now. To put it another way: Flee has a handicap that might be impossible to overcome, as far as my own personal opinion goes.
Will it win this award? I dunno, probably? Either that or Encanto, I guess. But if we're asking what should win the award for Best Animated Feature, then I cannot in good faith say Flee. Which is so fucking weird! Because it's such a great film!
But there are better on this list, personal bias be damned. And look, I'm gonna be hemming and hawing all day if you forced me to rank these animated films, but I think, if we take Flee out of the equation, then we can comfortably, at the very least, split the remaining four movies into an upper and a lower echelon. Lower: Encanto, Raya; Upper: Mitchells, Luca.
My reasoning for the split basically comes down to how tight I felt each script was. With Encanto and Raya, there was what I felt was a decent amount of meandering in its story. Nothing outwardly miscalculated, just honestly stuff you start to notice after four or five viewings. Raya is a "collect 'em all" adventure quest, and so maybe they spent a little too much time establishing settings that weren't all that important for the main conflict. Encanto takes its protagonist on a goose chase in a similar manner, but maybe in ways that don't even make sense, story-wise? So many nits to be picked—the clunky way the two sisters are roped into the plot to service their songs; the magical rules never really making a whole lot of sense; glossing over Bruno's redemption; and so on.
And if we're comparing those two, then Raya is really the only one whose ending whips me in the heart. No matter if the road to get to that ending slogs a decent amount—every time we get to that ending, I feel that kumandra. Holy SHIT. Encanto doesn't really have that. I appreciate the ending—"so it appears that Mirabel had a gift all along" and all that—but it's not as gut-wrenching. Simple as that.
Which I think probably puts Raya neck and neck with The Mitchells vs. the Machines, if we're being honest, since the latter doesn't quite stick the landing as strongly either (plus, that landing involves a crucial dance number set to a late-'00s pop song sung by a sexual abuser). But shit, man, the road there is just so delightful and joyous that I can't fault the lack of a gut-punch (and the queerbating too... shit, do I not like the Mitchells ending?!). The animation is so goddamn fun (wait, should this be the the deciding factor?), and the story of a dysfunctional family that learns to appreciate themselves, warts and all, is a story I can love and maybe even relate to a little bit (like, you want to be loved in an imperfect family than just be another member of a perfect family, right?). And it has multiple Los Campesinos! songs!! So goddamn good.
Luca might be better. I mean, I don't think it's because I've watched Luca the most times out of any of these films, but maybe? So take it with a grain of salt when I say that this was my favorite. Brightly animated film, lovable characters, an intimate treatise on childhood friendships, so fun and so funny and an ending that fucking wallops me no matter how many times I see it. Pixar knows how to get to me, and they did it again.
So if we're putting weight on the endings of these respective films, then I think Luca is definitely on top, and Mitchells beats Raya in a photo finish. Encanto is last, but even that feels fucking wrong, because I love that goddamn movie (I'm watching it even now, as Willow is asleep next to me and I am editing this blog post). And then what about Flee?!
It's a really tough category! Which is probably why I could easily write 1000 words about it! Sorry to bore you! I like all these movies!
Alright, fuck it, let's close our eyes and rank 'em and then regret our decision forever and never speak about this again:
5. Encanto
4. Raya and the Last Dragon
3. Flee
2. The Mitchells vs. the Machines
1. Luca
No comments:
Post a Comment