Sunny said something in his Sturgill review that I've been mulling over throughout the past week—that steadfast participation in Record Club has a way of giving "a softer eye to all genres." I think that's true, but I also think that's a function of just being more willing and open to enjoying things that you may not have enjoyed before. It's optimism couched in music criticism. There was a time in my recent past that I would have automatically dismissed Future's Honest for being what it is. Not so anymore, after 213 weeks in the
I hear a lot on Honest. I hear a lot of qualities that I'm coming to really appreciate in rap (how good artists command the rhythm and rhyme). I hear a lot of qualities that I'm still grappling with (the use and/or misuse of autotune). But on Honest, what I really hear is good storytelling. This is the quality that will stick with me whenever I think about Future's 2014 album.
The subgenre of "coke rap" is infinitely fascinating to me, just from a logistical standpoint. No judgments from me for selling drugs, but rapping about it publicly seems a little reckless, no? But at the same time, cocaine and the illegal sale of cocaine provides a specific subject matter to base the machismo around, and I dig it. It's one thing to say you're the best and that you're rich and women want to have sex with you and you're the king, but it's another to say that you are all those things because you are awesome at selling drugs.
The question becomes: how much of this should we believe? And here's where the storytelling gets really interesting. My thoughts are that the tales and the boasts contained on Honest are a healthy mixture of truth and fiction. This means that Future is an unreliable narrator, which in my opinion makes fiction a lot more fascinating. Think about the title track, in which Future repeats "I'm just bein' honest" a total of 39 times. No one claims honesty that often and is actually being completely honest, right? I have to believe that Future is full of shit. Again, that's not a judgment; if Future is a storyteller, then being full of shit is an asset.
Considering Future an unreliable narrator strengthens some of the better songs, and softens the blow of some of the weaker ones. An example of the latter first: "I Won" immediately follows the skeleton key of "Honest," and it is a truly terrible song. It is gross, it is misogynistic, it features a Nazi talking about impregnating his social parasite now-ex-wife with an angel. But maybe we can view this as Future giving space for a different/competing POV, I don't know. Or maybe we can ignore the Nazi and just focus on Future, who is reducing his then-fiancée to an object, right before allegedly cheating on her... if we pull ourselves away from the gossip columns long enough, we might consider this interesting storytelling too.
Let's stick with that "different POV" point though for another paragraph or two. Future is telling us a story through whom he allows to infiltrate his space on this album (i.e. the featured players). It was pretty interesting to read that Pharrell was skittish about appearing on a coke rap song ("Move That Dope"), but Future insisted that he would have the space to present an alternate opinion (which ends up being a relatively anti-materialistic message, made stronger by its juxtaposition with the other crude guest verses). Same thing happens when André 3000 shows up on "Benz Friendz." He's like "I think owning fancy cars is stupid," and Future, after spending an entire album rapping about how he's so rich he can buy any car he wants, is like "oh yeah, ha ha, I definitely agree lol." It's not that Future is saying sell coke or don't sell coke, buy cars or don't buy cars, or whatever, he's just making an attempt to tell both sides of the story.
If we look at Honest in this manner, then it's especially hilarious that the only rapper he does not give adequate space to is Drake, who is pretty much cut off mid-sentence. Yeah, yeah, I know that Drake originally had a verse on "Never Satisfied," and that it was Drake, not Future, who decided to remove it. But like I keep saying, I like thinking about this music as fiction, and so maybe Future's explanation about emasculation of Drake is fiction too. Doesn't it make this whole ordeal more interesting, to consider choices in language and point-of-view?
If we look at Honest in this manner, then it's especially hilarious that the only rapper he does not give adequate space to is Drake, who is pretty much cut off mid-sentence. Yeah, yeah, I know that Drake originally had a verse on "Never Satisfied," and that it was Drake, not Future, who decided to remove it. But like I keep saying, I like thinking about this music as fiction, and so maybe Future's explanation about emasculation of Drake is fiction too. Doesn't it make this whole ordeal more interesting, to consider choices in language and point-of-view?
I don't want to live in a world where every writer is telling the truth all the time. That's boring. I don't want to live in a world in which rap lyrics can be used as evidence in court. That seems insane to me. I like to believe that there is truth behind "Was it cold nights that made me cold?" because that builds empathy. I like to believe that there is hyperbole behind "I woke up in that Bugatti, went and bought me three Lambs," because that's still vivid world-building. I get sad when I hear Pusha T rap about having teenage sex with adult junkies in his kitchen, because I don't know if he's telling the truth, and I don't understand how he manages to turn something so bleak into a flex. I have to believe that Future's hook on that same song has some measure of truth to it—"young n****, move that dope"—i.e. that selling cocaine is a young man's game, and I find pathos in a relatively older man (Future, 31 years old when he laid down this track) rapping about the cycle of violence and poverty and hustle culture and, yeah, again turning that into triumphant braggadocio and the catchiest earworm on the album. That's a lot to chew on.
And don't let my focus on the lyrics overshadow the myriad ways in which the music and the production contribute to the storytelling. Some of the songs, particularly the first few, have a sort of cinematic quality that heighten the drama of the lyrics. There's also the autotune to consider. While I don't particular enjoy the way autotune strips the soul from an artist's vocals (Breihan is full of shit saying that they make Future sound "more human"), I do think the use of it is interesting. I think about Empath, and the way they employed lo-fi sounds as a defense mechanism, and I wonder if Future is doing the same. Finally, I thought it was funny every time a producer yelled out his name at the beginning of the song. It's always been something I've thought was stupid in hip hop, but I'll admit it makes sense in this context that I'm talking about. It's an author making himself a character in the story.
This isn't me saying that Honest is a great album, or that I loved it or anything. It's more than I'm saying that I love being open about these kinds of things, and am more willing to engage with the artist's techniques than I might have been four years ago. There was a lot I liked, there was a fair amount that I thought was boring or trite, but pretty much all of it was fascinating on both a fundamental level and on a meta level. That's the mark of a good storyteller.
GRADE: 3 pukes out of 5
P.S. Before this week, the only thing I knew about Future was that he was an avid drinker of lean, a.k.a. purple drank. Don't ask me why I knew this. I hope it has more to do with my deep appreciation for drinking culture more so than a racist entertainment industry that is going to promote popular black artists to white people like me as if the most important thing about them is their drug abuse. I thought about trying Dirty Sprite this week, in celebration of Future Week, but Pam would have killed me (if the Dirty Sprite didn't). Shit, maybe Future would've killed me too, since 1) I have a knack for making even the coolest things certifiably uncool, and/or 2) Future publicly quit lean after realizing how strong his influence was on sixth-grade boys, all of whom were now drinking lean. There's a story here too! Future is on the fucking Wikipedia page for lean! But that story is only really brushed upon maybe once or so on Honest (I forget which song), and so I didn't think it would be fair to get into it in the review proper. Don't do drugs, kids, especially if that drug is codeine mixed with soda and candy.

No comments:
Post a Comment