Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #5 and is featured on pages 53-58.
"All You Need Is Love"
Magical Mystery Tour (but first, a single)
1967
It's easy to get wrapped up in the pageantry of the Beatles. Think about the incredible fanfare surrounding Our World, a television program broadcasted in 24 different countries simultaneously (this was huge in 1967), watched by an estimated 400 million people, all tuning in to see the most famous rock 'n' roll band on the planet perform a new song and send a message to every person on earth. That's a big deal! I won't say that the Beatles are the only band that could pull this off, because, I dunno, the world is a lot more connected these days, and "Let It Go" has three billion views on YouTube... but still. You can hear a song like "All You Need Is Love," and you can rightfully think: "holy shit!"
C'mon, though. Let's be reasonable here. Let's take a step back and really think about this. All you need is love? Ask the Beatles, and they won't flinch. Yes! All you need is love, apparently! Our book authors even attempt to make the case that they were right, that all you needed was love, that the Beatles' performance on Our World sincerely did move the world in tangible ways toward world peace. If you want to gaslight yourself into thinking that way to justify an insane #5 ranking for "All You Need Is Love," then go for it. I refuse to be so obtuse.
But we don't even need to go that far. There are people with their boots on the ground here, not pretending that the Beatles ended international conflict, but instead fooling themselves into thinking that the phrase "love is all you need" is important for the Beatles, or important for themselves, or both. That's still a little too strong for me, I fear. It's just too trite of a phrase. It's just too saccharine for my tastes. You're a sucker if you really believe that all you need is love, because there are people in this world all too willing to take advantage of you when they find that out about you. You need love, sure, but let's try a little self-awareness too.
It's like... people pretend that anything the Beatles say is written on a golden scroll and is automatically accepted as infallible wisdom, ya know? Tell me with a straight face that you are comfortable with "There's nothing you can do that can't be done." You can't. It's gibberish. It's like staring at the sun—it seems so bright, until you start going blind. People don't even think about it too hard, though. They just hear something they don't quite get and the reaction is "Oh wow that John Lennon is brilliant!!" These guys were the best snake oil salesmen of our time. "All You Need Is Love" is the unction that burns real fucking bad.
If you couldn't tell yet, I fucking hate this song. I fucking despise it. Its placement at #5 would be a fucking outrage if it wasn't so funny and predictable. Of course these fucking Beatles bozos are gonna lap this corny bullshit right up. It's called "simple and straightforward" after spending a good amount of time defending "A Day in the Life" for how complicated it is. It is written that the song has "passion," and that can't be farther from the truth (think about how slowly it drags; think about the guitar solo that just kind of gives up a measure before the scheduled end of it). And it's said that "All You Need Is Love" changed the world, even in personal ways, i.e. that there must be those people who decided that they were going to love people more because they were convinced by the Beatles to be better.
I am masochistic and so last year I watched that Machine Gun Kelly documentary (better not to drop its title again on this blog, once is enough). Among its many, many sins was Kelly's claim that teens "need" his music, because his music saves teens from committing suicide. I loathe this man and I think this statement is so fucking absurd that it should be labeled as a crime, but this is the same thing that the authors (and seemingly everyone else) are saying about the Beatles too, right? That we need the Beatles to remind us that "love is all we need."
If you need a goddamn rock 'n' roll band to tell you how to love, then baby, there ain't no hope for you in the first place.
There will be many instances in this column of my negativity being in the third degree. It's not the song that I'm reacting so strongly against, but instead it's that primary reaction to the song that I'm reacting against. If this was just a random B-side, it'd be like, cool, this is a neat little track from a talented quartet of young moppets (and: hey! they snuck in the hook from "She Loves You" at the end! and hey! that's the French National Anthem at the beginning! and hey! Keith fucking Moon is one of the backup singers! and etc. etc.). But no. It couldn't just be that. It had to be a STATEMENT. We have to pretend that it is IMPORTANT. We have to all pat ourselves on the back, saying, yay, we're Beatles fans, we are enlightened, we know how to LOVE better than those who don't listen to the Beatles, and let's all pretend that we can SAVE THE WORLD if we just, like, ya know, love each other a little, maaaaaan.
Fuck this cloying piece of shit and send it into the sun, but know that my reaction is an equal and opposite reaction. There won't be many of these outwardly negative assessments throughout the rest of my time here, because there won't be many other Beatles songs that can match the sheer audaciousness and true pretentiousness of "All You Need Is Love." Let's all just fucking chill, okay?
BETTER BEATLE: I mean, this is near the bottom of my personal list, so the options are vast here. But let's name something truly middling just to really stick the point home, shall we? How about "I'm a Loser" from the only true underrated Beatles album, Beatles for Sale. That's a pretty okay song! And yet "All You Need Is Love" makes it sound like goddamn Aretha Franklin's "Respect."
NEXT TIME: We rehash "Hey Jude," and consider whether it's worthy of #6.
No comments:
Post a Comment