Follow along in the book HERE. Today's song is at #3, and is featured on pages 41-46.
"Let It Be"
from Let It Be
1970
I hate to be a John Lennon, but I scoffed when I saw "Let It Be" as the #3 song on this list. Lennon has said various things about this song as "it's too evangelical," comparing it to dreck such as "Bridge over Troubled Water," threatening to "giggle" during the guitar solo during its recording, mockingly calling it "Hark the Angels Come" on the album right before it begins, and also "Oh, I have no idea, you see I don't know what he's thinking when he writes 'Let it Be.'" He was dismissive, so was I, and the fact that Paul's bandmate did the dismissing first gives me permission, right?
As will probably happen in this blog column more often than I'm likely to admit, I've softened my opinion of this Beatles after reading what the superfans have to say about it, and then listening to it ten times in a row. I have problems with "Let It Be," but nothing that I'm unwilling to forgive. This song is fine. Maybe even good, if I'm in the right mood.
The problem I have with it makes me the same type of cynical smug asshole that John Lennon was, and I find that part of me difficult to overcome. Yes: I think "Let It Be" is extremely lame, and that indeed has a lot to do with the religious imagery. There's "Mother Mary"—both Paul's and Jesus' mothers were named Mary, you see—and there's the light that shines down from above. The "answer" that is provided appears divine, literally from a dream version of Paul's dead mom, but figuratively from a divine figure who resembles an angel from heaven. The gospel sounds of the song, such as the simple piano and repetitive lyrics and showy vocal stylings, add to the religious aspects of the song. It was not necessarily intended to be religious, but the understood implication shared by everyone who made it and everyone who has ever listened to it is that "Let It Be" is a song of worship. Lame.
The message of "let it be," which our authors call "uplifting," I find to be a little too pat. Perhaps one of the glibbest "words of wisdom" ever muttered on a Billboard Hot 100 topper, rivaled only by "Don't Worry, Be Happy" eighteen years later. I present to you the same argument that I did when Record Club reviewed that album. You can't just not worry. You can't just let it be. The world doesn't function that way. You can find happiness in the balance of life, in letting the unimportant things be, which not letting certain important things just be. It's also extremely important to remember that when Paul McCartney sung these words, he might have already been one of the most popular and well-known musicians in history. Not as difficult to just let it be as it would for me or you, ya know?
That's the cynical way of looking at it, again, and I swear I'm not purposefully trying to be a John Lennon here. I understand that this song is a very powerful tool for those in need of its message. But so too is actual church, and I don't need that either. I respect your right to choose the church of the Beatles, as long as you don't attempt to impress your views upon me without my permission.
That's the cynical way of looking at it, again, and I swear I'm not purposefully trying to be a John Lennon here. I understand that this song is a very powerful tool for those in need of its message. But so too is actual church, and I don't need that either. I respect your right to choose the church of the Beatles, as long as you don't attempt to impress your views upon me without my permission.
It's funny, there's a PoYB Contributor who has the words "let it be" tattooed on her wrist. I won't reveal who it is without her permission. I should have interviewed her for this column though. I think she'd be able to give some real insight into what the phrase "let it be" means, especially to her. I can't imagine that the phrase has any religious connotations for her. I instead choose to believe that she, along with anyone else who might find affinity for this particular Beatles aphorism, finds it healing because it simplifies life's various pain-in-the-ass complexities. It's more about optimism in the face of struggle than an avoidance of that struggle.
So maybe my lack of true appreciation for "Let It Be" stems from the fact that I've lived a charmed life thus far, and if that's the case, then I am truly sorry for lacking humility here. Author Michael Lewis indicates in his "What we really like about this song" blurb that he lost his mom and his grandmom while writing this book, and that "Let It Be" gave him peace in those "times of darkness." Who am I to say he is wrong? But if that's true, then that means that "Let It Be" sounds like condolences to me. And that's pretty unappealing, honestly, if we're just talking about a four-minute pop song.
I want to warn you about something that I don't find very interesting, and it's going to pop up a few more times before we're finished this project. I don't really care about "alternate takes" for Beatles songs. As far as I'm concerned, the "Let It Be" that exists on the album of the same name that was released in May of 1970 is the only version that exists. This argument is especially tenuous for Beatles fans for the songs on Let It Be, since Phil Spector applied some overdubs to the album without McCartney's approval (if only Spector's mother had come to him in his hour of darkness, speaking words of wisdom before he murdered Lana Clarkson). There are "Naked" versions of all these songs, released later, but I'm not going to seek them out for the purposes of this project. One could say that I'm letting it be.
I want to warn you about something that I don't find very interesting, and it's going to pop up a few more times before we're finished this project. I don't really care about "alternate takes" for Beatles songs. As far as I'm concerned, the "Let It Be" that exists on the album of the same name that was released in May of 1970 is the only version that exists. This argument is especially tenuous for Beatles fans for the songs on Let It Be, since Phil Spector applied some overdubs to the album without McCartney's approval (if only Spector's mother had come to him in his hour of darkness, speaking words of wisdom before he murdered Lana Clarkson). There are "Naked" versions of all these songs, released later, but I'm not going to seek them out for the purposes of this project. One could say that I'm letting it be.
But that speaks to the bigger issue here, I think. We're all interpreting these Beatles songs as we see fit. Our authors spent a lot of time interpreting the songs and then ranking them based on those interpretations. I'm going to see something different in "Let It Be" than another might. My opinions about "Let It Be" might say more about me than they do about the authors or about Paul McCartney. That's what I hope to make clear throughout these 100 write-ups. I think "Let It Be" is a fine song, but I'm not just gonna kowtow to the so-called superfans because they think it's the third best song in the canon.
I want you to know, through this journey, that I am cynical, but that I also love the Beatles. This is where John Lennon and I differ. I get the sense that John despised the idea of "The Beatles" by the time they broke up in 1969. That wariness and bitterness comes out in every Lennon quote about "Let It Be." I'm approaching it from a different angle. I love this band and I think their legacy is well-earned. I also think that they work best when they recreate hard and basic rock 'n' roll through a thick lens of psychedelia. I don't think that "Let It Be" does that at all. I think it's a soupy ballad with a lame message, steeped in imagery that I purposefully distance myself from as much as I can. It's a good song because it's a Beatles song. It's not a great song because it's a bad Beatles song.
I want you to know, through this journey, that I am cynical, but that I also love the Beatles. This is where John Lennon and I differ. I get the sense that John despised the idea of "The Beatles" by the time they broke up in 1969. That wariness and bitterness comes out in every Lennon quote about "Let It Be." I'm approaching it from a different angle. I love this band and I think their legacy is well-earned. I also think that they work best when they recreate hard and basic rock 'n' roll through a thick lens of psychedelia. I don't think that "Let It Be" does that at all. I think it's a soupy ballad with a lame message, steeped in imagery that I purposefully distance myself from as much as I can. It's a good song because it's a Beatles song. It's not a great song because it's a bad Beatles song.
Oh well. I'm not concerned. I should just... um... what's the phrase for when you just want to leave something as it is and not allow it to bother you? I'm coming up blank.
BETTER BEATLE: We'll have a lot more to say about it in a couple weeks, but "Hey Jude" is an easy comparison, and despite what I've said in the past about it, the song is definitely better than "Let It Be."
NEXT TIME: "Yesterday" at #4
2 comments:
Holistic rankings
1. Strawberry Fields Forever
2. A Day in the Life
3. Let It Be
-To underscore how simple this song, I can play both the piano part and the guitar solo — two tasks I don’t normally excel at.
-I like the idea of “Let It Be: Naked” especially for a totally overproduced song like “Long and Winding Road.” But Specter’s wall of sound approach is handled deftly in this song.
-Billy Preston, as always, is fun here.
I'm just seeing these comments! Thanks for following along, dude. I appreciate the ongoing ranking, and I look forward to the day that we start disagreeing in those rankings.
Did you look at the book? Just curious. It might even be better if you weren't. I am responding to the book and you are responding to me. Now we just need someone who isn't reading the blog posts and is only responding to your comments.
Post a Comment