Saturday, January 28, 2023

Review and Discussion: Crying in H Mart


I'm fascinated with the idea of an artist doing two things well enough to be at least a little bit famous for both. Michelle Zauner is known for her music—fronting Japanese Breakfast—and now also for writing a best-selling book—Crying in H Mart. The very best part, though, is that one side of her success informs the other. Crying in H Mart has unlocked a whole new level of appreciation for J-Brekkie's back catalogue for me. The text seems deeper and richer now that I know the context in which some of it was made.

So I can't praise the functionality of Crying in H Mart enough. In terms of the written word, I have a lot to praise too. I think the idea of "death" is not necessarily a unique one in literature, but Zauner manages to find enough to fresh angles to the idea that I was hooked throughout. I appreciated the constant connecting of food to ideas of life and death and togetherness—the book opens at H Mart, where people from different (but similar) walks of life are brought together because of the food. Zauner obsesses, in both her real life and in her writing, over the culinary wonders of her family's home country, and by the end of the book, she does a fantastic job of really hammering home the reason that she devotes so much of the book to it. Food is important symbolically. That's one of the bigger things I'll take away from this experience.

It's weird stepping back and trying to describe the "action" of the memoir. There... isn't much. Zauner's mom is dying, and then she dies. That's basically the extent of it. And yet, Zauner really hones in on why this simple plot was so important to her, so earth-shatteringly impactful. You get wrapped up in it too. You find yourself grieving the loss of someone you never knew.

I have no fucking clue how they are going to make a movie based on this book, but seeing as how Michelle Zauner is an ace musician and an ace author, I don't see why she couldn't be an ace screenwriter as well.

GRADE: 4 pukes out of 5


BOOK CLUB DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1. How do you feel about Chongmi's idea of "saving 10% of yourself for yourself"? How did we see that affect her relationship with her daughter?

2. How do the characters in this memoir react to sickness? Is it something to be treated, or a "rite of passage"? How do you and your family view sickness?

3. What are your thoughts about Chongmi's abortion?

4. There's a lot of talk about Michelle feeling like she has to "repay her debts" by taking care of her mother. How do you feel about that view of the human life cycle?

5. What can we discuss about Michelle's view of her own identity, how she wanted to be "more white" when she was younger, but after her mother's death she feared that her "Koreanness was fading"? What does this say about the importance about how we view ourselves?

6. Let's talk about Peter, and what it means to be a supporting character in this type of story.

7. Michelle describes in detail all the various ways she reacted to her mothers death (e.g. going to the farm, going on vacation, etc.). What was the most interesting to you? Which tells you the most about Michelle Zauner? Which tells you the most about how humans grieve?

8. Zauner's relationship with her Aunt Nami was interesting—how Nami coined the "Famous Bad Girl" nickname, how they needed each other in grief and found a connection despite the language barrier. How important is Nami in this narrative?

9. What are your thoughts about parenting styles presented in this book? There is a juxtaposition presented between Chongmi's style (tough love, I guess?) and what Zauner describes as "mommy-mommy." Is there a right or wrong way to parent?

10. Does pain inspire art? Michelle talks about the years after her mother's death feeling "charmed." Is that because her mother is watching over her ("sticking her foot on god's neck?"), or is it because her mother's death inspired her best art? (Sidenote: does her mother's absence in her best album prove this one way or the other?)

No comments: